Reviews for Upper West Side Vacation Rental - VRBO 228204 - 1 BR Manhattan Apartment in NY, Lincoln Square

Comfy, cozy, spacious and clean!!

Guest Michelene K.
Date of stay 02/21/13
Review Submitted 02/27/13

My boyfriend and I are frequent visitors to the city. We've stayed in just about every trendy hotel within every neighborhood. And we have to admit, of all these hotels, we are so glad we stayed in this property. James was wonderful to deal with! The apartment was clean, spacious, had all the necessities and then-some, the location was perfect! 1 block away from Lincoln Square, short walk to CP, and Columbus Circle. There were plenty of trendy bars, lounges, restaurants, and shops with in a 5 min walk. But I must say, nothing beat the view!! The view was spectacular for a quiet dinner, and sunrise breakfast!! Wish we had more than a long weekend. We definitely recommend this place, and we will be visiting again. :)

Recommended for: Adventure seekers, age 55+, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: thanks guys, glad you enjoyed your stay. Looking forward to having you back soon.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

75 West End Ave, Apt P33D

Guest Jim
Date of stay 12/26/12
Review Submitted 01/02/13

Two comments on this property and our experience. First, the apartment is exactly as represented in the description. It is located in a safe neighborhood about three blocks from the subway stop at Columbus Circle and another at Lincoln Center. Second, the property owner, James, was extraordinarly helpful in getting everything set up for our arrival. In addition, he was aware of travel difficulties due to weather on our travel day to NYC and sent an email to confirm that we had arrived. As I turned off my email for the vacation, I did not respond at the time. So, he took the initiative to call and confirm that we had arrived and that all was OK. Above and beyond what I would normally expect.

Recommended for: Age 55+, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Perfect Long Weekend

Guest Betsy
Date of stay 10/18/12
Review Submitted 10/25/12

This apartment was perfect for our long weekend in NYC. We were pleasantly surprised at how spacious the apartment is and how incredible the views are! The location is great - you can walk to the UWS or hop on the subway nearby and go anywhere. The apartment was clean and comfortable and had everything we needed. James was a pleasure to work with. Overall, the whole experience was smooth and simple and perfect! We hope to stay there again soon!

Recommended for: Tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Absolutely perfect

Guest mike
Date of stay 10/04/12
Review Submitted 10/15/12

It is rare to find a rental that exceeds your expectations, but this one did. We will definitely be returning.

Recommended for: Age 55+, families with teenagers, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Excellent weekend getaway

Guest New York Explorer
Date of stay 09/28/12
Review Submitted 10/20/12

Very comfortable, clean, attractive apartment with a great view of the city and river from the balcony. A short walk to Central Park and the Natural History Museum. It is a great neighbourhood and easy to get to other parts of the city. James was very helpful and attentive, checking in to make sure we had everything we needed, providing good advice about local restaurants, and anticipating all we would need to know about using the apartment.

Recommended for: Age 55+, families with teenagers, tourists without a car, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Love New York City

Guest Kansas girl
Date of stay 09/07/12
Review Submitted 09/24/12

This is our second time staying at this apartment and it was wonderful once again. The apartment is well equipped, clean and the views are fabulous. James the owner is great to work with and very hospitable.

Recommended for: Age 55+, families with teenagers, girls getaway, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Perfect Stay

Guest Bernadette
Date of stay 08/21/12
Review Submitted 08/29/12

We ( A group of 4 friends) are delighted to have chosen this apartment. It proved to be the perfect base for our 1 week holiday and is just as depicted in the photos, spotlessly clean and tastefully decorated with a wonderful attention to detail. Whether first thing in the morning , watching the city come to life , or sipping a glass of wine on the balcony in the evening , the views are simply stunning and compliment the whole 'NY experience' we wanted to capture. As previous reviews refer , James proved to be the perfect host. Both prior to, and throughout our stay he was friendly , helpful and a pleasure to deal with. An overall fantastic experience , we absolutely loved the apartment and hope to return in the not too distant future.

Recommended for: Adventure seekers, girls getaway, tourists without a car, sightseeing.

Owner response: I just wanted to say thanks for selecting our apartment for your holiday and to thank you all for the wee Scottish treats. Oat cakes are my favorite. Please remember that you always have a home in NYC whenever you are in town. Looking forward to having you all with us again real soon. Warmest Regards, james

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Amazing !

Guest Isa
Date of stay 04/07/12
Review Submitted 04/16/12

Perfect, splendid and unforgettable !!! We are very happy to have booked this apartment. It is better than an hotel, because you are at home. All is done to feel very good ! And the view is incredible. The owner is very kind-hearted. You are not alone, if you have any questions, he is here to answer. You can go the eyes closed. It is magic !

Recommended for: Families with teenagers, tourists without a car.

Owner response: Merci - please think of our apartment as your NYC home. We look forward to having you stay with us again. James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

We'll Be Back

Guest winesipper
Date of stay 10/13/11
Review Submitted 10/20/11

We have stayed in several rentals in Manhattan, and this apartments was the best, in location, view, comfort and cleanliness, and the consideration of the owner. Located in the "back yard" of Lincoln Center, we were a short walk to Central Park, the Hudson River, and the wonderful restaurants of the Upper West Side. The apartment is very LARGE for a New York lodging, the furnishings are comfortable and the kitchen is fully stocked. This attitude of generosity comes from the owner, James, who met us at the apartment and was efficient, friendly and helpful. When we sat up on our balcony on the 33rd floor sipping wine as we watched the sun set over the city, we felt very grateful to have found this place and we know that we will return.

Recommended for: People with disabilities, age 55+, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Pictures capture it exactly--wonderful!

Guest Anonymous
Date of stay 09/29/11
Review Submitted 10/20/11

We stayed 2 nights prior to a New England cruise. Those 2 days were the best of the entire vacation. So close to subway, shopping, wonderful grocery, and we walked to Broadway and 42nd, etc. Enjoyed the neighborhood.

Recommended for: Age 55+

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Living like a New Yorker!!

Guest Jim & Tiffany C
Date of stay 09/16/11
Review Submitted 10/02/11

It's a special person that opens their city home to others to live like a New Yorker for a few days. What a great experience! The apartment is fabulous and so is James. Sending good Karma your way James. Thanks!!!

Recommended for: Age 55+, tourists without a car, romantic getaway.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Great place to stay in NYC

Guest Care
Date of stay 09/01/11
Review Submitted 09/08/11

This was our first trip to NYC, and the apartment was perfect. It is just as depicted in the photos - nicely decorated and a fantastic view. The balcony was wonderful to sit on. James was very accommodating to work with. Can't wait to go back! Highly recommended.

Recommended for: Age 55+, girls getaway, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: thanks Carolyn, feel free to stay anytime!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Perfect Vacation!!!

Guest Melissa R.
Date of stay 07/01/11
Review Submitted 07/14/11

We came to NYC to celebrate our 23rd wedding anniversary and had a spectacular time!!! We loved the apartment! It was beautifully decorated, super clean and organized, and in a perfect location! The view from the windows and balcony were breathtaking! Although we weren't in the apartment for long periods of time, we did enjoy our coffee in the morning and wine late at night on the balcony. The place was perfect and James was wonderful to work with and very helpful! I've already referred friends who are planning a trip to New York and we will definitely book this apartment on our next trip!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

So much better than a hotel--it's fun to live like a local.

Guest Pete
Date of stay 05/12/11
Review Submitted 05/22/11

Great place! Had several events at Lincoln Center, just a stone's throw away. So many advantages over a hotel--more space, a real kitchen (so many great restaurants, but it's nice to be able to "eat in" if you want, especially with the view!), living with locals and not other tourists. Being on the 33rd floor of a building in NYC doesn't guarantee a view beyond the next building, but this apartment has fabulous unobstructed views. Clean, comfortable, well equipped, a place you would choose to live. Thanks!

Recommended for: Tourists without a car, sightseeing.

Owner response: Thanks Pete. Please think of us the next time you are visiting NYC.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Fun and beautiful experience depiste severe weather condition :)

Guest Jerome
Date of stay 12/02/10
Review Submitted 01/19/11

We were among the foul tourists being in NYC during the last week of 2010 ;) and despite the severe weather condition we had a beautiful moment, mainly because of the perfect accommodation proposed by James. The apartment is very well located and very comfortable. May be more important or as important as the flat itself, I would like to thank the owner for his clear booking and payment process. We had all the information needed and for our first booking with VRBO, it was a perfect first experience. For the people worried about Web booking, deal with James; he is the perfect guy !! We will be back this spring to discover NYC without the snow lol :) and we will book the same flat again.

Recommended for: Tourists without a car, sightseeing.

Owner response: Merci Jerome....sorry you got caught up in the Christmas Snow....looking forward to seeing you all in the Spring. Thanks again, you and your family will always have a place to stay in NYC no matter what the season.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

Great New York Apartment

Guest Lee
Date of stay 12/02/10
Review Submitted 12/19/10

We were amazed at the terrific views from this well appointed apartment. Everything was as advertised and owners were very helpful. We recommend to anyone wanting a nice place to stay while visiting New York City

Recommended for: Girls getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: Thanks Lee. Glad that you enjoyed our place. Please feel free to come back anytime you like. James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 0/0

STUNNING!

Guest Lauren
Date of stay 10/08/10
Review Submitted 10/11/10

This apartment was absolutely perfect for a Girls Getaway Weekend! It's gorgeously decorated, perfectly located, spotlessly clean, and every room has a view to die for! I will never again stay in a hotel while in NY... but instead call James and keep my fingers crossed that this gem is available. Perfect James, just perfect. Thank you for a wonderful experience!

Recommended for: Adventure seekers, age 55+, girls getaway, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: Lauren, I am so glad you all enjoyed your stay and I trust we will see you and the girls again. Many thanks - James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Fantastic Apartment

Guest Barb
Date of stay 09/13/10
Review Submitted 09/23/10

This apartment was PERFECT! The views from every room were incredible. I was also very nervous about renting from a website but could not have been more pleasantly surprised. I try to visit New York every year, its my favorite place. I only wish I had known about this apartment sooner. James was also very kind and very helpful in making us feel welcome and comfortable. Thank you so much James.

Recommended for: Age 55+, families with teenagers, girls getaway, tourists without a car, sightseeing.

Owner response: Thanks Barb, you are welcome to stay with us whenever you are in town.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Wonderful New York apartment

Guest Sisters from Montreal
Date of stay 04/02/10
Review Submitted 04/09/10

Everything about this apartment is wonderful: it is well furnished, comfortable, clean, bright, well equipped, quiet, safe, the view is amazing on all sides and at all times, it is very well located (close to everything), the owners are extremely nice, the building is clean, the parking fees are reasonable, there is a nice grocery store just around the corner... We spent the Easter holiday there and I will always remember sitting on the balcony, watching the sunset over the Hudson river, after a long and wonderful New York day. I will tell all my friends and I certainly plan to go back. Thank you for an absolutely wonderful long weekend!!

Recommended for: Age 55+, girls getaway, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: Merci ! Thank you for your kind words. Please remember there is always a place for you in NYC. Looking forward to your next visit. Thanks again. James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 2/2

Guest Anonymous
Date of stay 12/09/09
Review Submitted 12/09/09

I was so pleased that the apartment was exactly as described. Beautiful views of Manhattan.Clean and very nicely furnished. My Daughter and I enjoyed the fact that it was close to a lot of shopping and to Lincoln Center. Will definitely use this place again.

Owner response: Thanks Linda, glad you had a great time. Come back soon. James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

FANTASTIC EXPERIENCE

Guest Burbank
Date of stay 10/29/09
Review Submitted 05/09/10

The apartment was perfection, the views incredible and the owners were terrific!!! We were there for the NYC Marathon and we could not have asked for a better place to stay. We were living like locals, walking to Lincoln Center to see Aida, taking the train to Times Square to see In The Heights and the next morning we watched the USS New York dock at Pier 88 on the Hudson River. The apartment was tastefully decorated, clean and so comfortable that we didn't want to go home. We were a little aprehensive about renting from a website but we were pleasantly surprised. We cannot say enough about this apartment. We have been recommending it to everyone we know. You will love it!!!!

Recommended for: Age 55+, families with teenagers, girls getaway, tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

Owner response: I want to say thank you, you were perfect guests. Its nice to see that you enjoyed this apartment and NYC as much as we do. Please keep us in mind for your next visit.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 2/2

Guest Andrew28
Date of stay 10/09/09
Review Submitted 10/09/09

Excellent location, Really nice building, Immaculate and Very pleasent owners. A few of my friends and I stayed for a long weekend. Our stay in this aparment brought to life a luxurious NYC experience only one can imagine.

Owner response: Hey Guys, thanks for staying with us. Next time you have a special event in the city please remember us. Thanks Andy James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Guest Mindi2
Date of stay 07/16/09
Review Submitted 07/16/09

AMAZING! That one word sums it all up. The views are breathtaking of the city and the Hudson River! The accommodations were clean, decor lovely and very comfortable. We had a pleasurable experience dealing with the owners and would definitely return for another visit. Highly recommended!

Owner response: Thanks Ma'am. It was nice to meet you all. Glad to hear you had such a good time. Tell the girls that Coco and I said 'hey' It was great to have you all. Thanks, James

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No Helpful votes: 1/1

Vacation Rentals by Owner

Lincoln Square - Upper West Side Luxury Apartment [#228204] | View Property

Traveler Reviews (23)

Comfy, cozy, spacious and clean!!

Comfy, cozy, spacious and clean!!

75 West End Ave, Apt P33D

75 West End Ave, Apt P33D

Perfect Long Weekend

Perfect Long Weekend

Absolutely perfect

Absolutely perfect

Excellent weekend getaway

Excellent weekend getaway

Love New York City

Love New York City

Perfect Stay

Perfect Stay

Amazing !

Amazing !

We'll Be Back

We'll Be Back

Pictures capture it exactly--wonderful!

Pictures capture it exactly--wonderful!

Living like a New Yorker!!

Living like a New Yorker!!

Great place to stay in NYC

Great place to stay in NYC

Perfect Vacation!!!

Perfect Vacation!!!

So much better than a hotel--it's fun to live like a local.

So much better than a hotel--it's fun to live like a local.

Fun and beautiful experience depiste severe weather condition :)

Fun and beautiful experience depiste severe weather condition :)

Great New York Apartment

Great New York Apartment

STUNNING!

STUNNING!

Fantastic Apartment

Fantastic Apartment

Wonderful New York apartment

Wonderful New York apartment

FANTASTIC EXPERIENCE

FANTASTIC EXPERIENCE