Location: Shelter Island, Hamptons, Long Island, New York, USA (80 Miles from New York City) View Map
Accommodations: House, 2 Bedrooms + Convertible bed(s), 1 Bath (Sleeps 4-8)
This little house was originally built in 1920, and although it has since been relocated from another part of the island and completely renovated, it still retains all the charm of its original design.
In only 800 square feet are contained a mud room, walk-in pantry, beautiful modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops, two bedrooms, a spacious living room, dining area, and covered front and back porches with room for seating. The partially finished basement has laundry facilities, lawn furniture, a hammock and two bicycles.
Vacation Rental Features
- Amenities
- Washer
- Dryer
- Linens Provided
- Off Street Parking
- Parking for RV/Boat/Trailer
- Beds
- Queen Bed
- Double Bed
- Convertible Bed: These sofas fold completely flat with one easy click, and are very comfortable. One note of caution however: The faux-leather covers are easily punctured and/or scratched by cat claws, and some smaller dog claws (Trust us--we learned the hard way!). For this reason, we cannot allow any cats on the premises whatsoever, and ask that you please either keep dogs off the furniture entirely, or cover the furniture with a blanket before allowing them up, to avoid damage. Thank you!
- Entertainment
- Cable/Satellite TV
- DVD
- Video Library
- CD Player
- Stereo System
- Kitchen
- Full Kitchen: Dishwasher, Combination Toaster-Oven/Microwave, Coffee-grinder, French-press coffeemaker are also provided.
- Cooking Utensils Provided: Knives, chopping board, serving spoons, plates, glasses, pots and pans are all provided. There are even some basic spices in the cabinet above the stove.
- Refrigerator
- Dishwasher: Easy to use, soap gel-packs are in a bag under the kitchen sink.
- Microwave: Combo Microwave/Toaster-Oven
- Outdoor Features
- Gas/Electric BBQ Grill
- Deck/Patio
- Communications
- Telephone
- Broadband Internet
- WiFi (Wireless Internet)
- Other Amenities
- Beach and town within walking distance, fenced-in front yard for dogs, horse stables across the road where riding is available.
- Suitability
- Pet Friendly: We allow well-behaved dogs, but cannot allow cats on the premises, because the living room sofas are vulnerable to cat claws. We had an identical sofa in NYC and it was ruined by our two cats within one day! So please, please, no cats, and if you are in the habit of letting your dogs on the furniture, please cover the sofas with blankets or towels to protect the upholstery. Thank you!
- Kid Friendly: Front yard is fenced in--good for small children.
- Smoking Not Allowed
- Activities (on site and nearby)
- Golf
- Tennis
- Sightseeing
- Restaurants
- Kayaking
- Sailing
- Boating
- Shelling
- Swimming
- Snorkeling/Diving
- Biking
- Mountain Biking
- Wildlife Viewing
- Hiking
- Fishing
- Antiquing
- Miniature golf
- Horseback Riding
- Other Activities
- Short drive or bike ride to the Mashomack Nature Preserve: http://www.shelter-island.org/mashomack.html, Yoga and Pilates classes are a short walk away, tons of great yard sales to peruse all summer long.
Rate Details (In US Dollars)
November 1st - March 31st: $150/night or $950/week
April 1st - May 23rd: $200/night or $1350/week
May 24th - Sept. 10th: $250/night or $1700/week
Sept. 11 - October 31st: $200/night or $1350/week
Cleaning fee: Btwn $50-$150, depending on # of nights and # of guests
Utility Fees range from $0-$100, depending on length of stay
Note: Until confirmed, rates are subject to change without notice.
Credit Cards Accepted:



Map & Owner's Profile
A Perfect Little Gem of a House on a Perfect Little Island
Year Purchased: 2007
Why the Owner Chose Shelter Island
We fell in love with Shelter Island because it is the same distance from the city as The Hamptons, but has a completely different personality--there is no trendiness, no hip parties, no high-end shopping or general ostentatious displays of wealth--just beautiful unspoiled nature, peace and quiet. Plus, a full third of the island is a nature preserve!
The Unique Benefits at this House
As city dwellers, we relish the absolute silence of the night-time on Shelter Island, and the clear skies full of bright stars. We love being able to walk to the beach with the dog, or walk into town for lunch or a cocktail.
Amazing BBQ and Seafood restaurant--not to be missed. Right around the corner from the house! Also a fresh seafood market.
Owner's Map of Shelter Island
I am an illustrator and cartoonist, my husband is a veterinarian. We have a dog named Oly that we found living on the streets in a little town in Portugal (Odiaxere) where we were vacationing, and two cats, named Mister and Bessie.
Property Photos
- External View - Pet Friendly Vacation House Near Beach In Shelter Island, New York
- Living Room - Pet Friendly Vacation House Near Beach In Shelter Island, New York
- Kitchen - Pet Friendly Vacation House Near Beach In Shelter Island, New York
- Kitchen
- Dining Area
- Large Bedroom
- Small Bedroom
- Bath
Guest Comments (8)
First (8) of (8). View all comments
Vacation Rentals by Owner Listing #239698
There have been 4737 visitors to this page since the counter was last reset in 2009.
This listing was first published here in 2009.
Date last modified - November 23, 2009



Positive Rating
Cara , Jackson Heights, NY
Positive Rating
Cindy ,
Positive Rating
Natalie , Union, NJ
Positive Rating
, Brooklyn, NY
Positive Rating
, Fairfield, CT
Positive Rating
Nora Cohen , NY, NY
Positive Rating
Darel ,
Positive Rating
Alex Shteynberg , New York, NY