Vacation Rentals by Owner

Perfect Place for Peace & Quiet

Guest: Spaniel Dad (Philly)
Date of Stay: 11/01/11 Review Submitted: 11/08/11

This home in just perfect...shown well in the pictures....well maintained and stocked, exceptionally clean and just wonderful for those with four legged "kids"! We had a wonderful week on the island and it's beaches.............our city dogs learned how to be country hounds real quick. Perfect weather in November even had us using the hammock and grill dailym Commander Cody's around the corner is a must for casual delishious food and AMAZING fish market. For a big night out........try Vine Street Cafe.....One of the top 5 meals of our lives! We will be back for a longer stay next time!

Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, families with young children, girls getaway, pet owners, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

exceptional place to stay!!

Guest: LesEtoiles (Brooklyn, NY)
Date of Stay: 05/06/11 Review Submitted: 07/22/11

My husband and I had a wonderful time here and plan to return in the fall. Great amenities and loved the style and design of the house. The owners put a lot of time and thought into the remodel. Nice finishes. Kitchen is fully stocked. Loved the Roku so much we bought one! It is so peaceful and quiet you may never want to leave the property, except for dinner at Vine Street Cafe, (Planet Bliss is unfortunately closed) a bike ride or walk around the beautiful island. Loved it!!!! Perfect getaway from the city.

Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, families with young children, girls getaway, pet owners, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

3rd stay.......love this place.

Guest: Jan G. (Easton, PA.)
Date of Stay: 03/19/11 Review Submitted: 03/21/11

Joan, just got back from a weekend stay at your cottage. As usual, everything was perfect. Each time I stay here I discover new dining spots and beaches to stroll on. The Eagle Deli is wonderful! I also found a place called All Dogged Up that has all sorts of great dog stuff and doggie day care or house sits for when we want to do a wine tour on the North Fork. Wades Beach is still a favorite for walkig my Greyhounds. Everyone in the area is so freindly. The fenced in yard is such a PLUS for us with dogs that love to play outside. I would love to know what kind of mattress and pillows you have in the smaller bedroom......I slept like I was on a cloud! Thanks again for giving us a little bit of heaven Jan , (hounds, Booker and Bella)

Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, girls getaway, pet owners, romantic getaway, sightseeing.

A wonderful and relaxiing place to vacation

Guest: Nancy-Ron-Maggie (United States)
Date of Stay: 05/02/10 Review Submitted: 05/19/10

We had high expectations for this Shelter Island location, and we were not disappointed. The house was nicely maintained and very comfortable and had everything we needed for a relaxing week with our little chihuahua, Maggie. We enjoyed walking and biking around the island, and shopping right around the corner for groceries and other vacation goodies. Maggie loved running around the fenced yard and sunning in the hammock with us. We will certainly look forward to our next visit!

Recommended for:Age 55+, families with teenagers, families with young children, girls getaway, pet owners, romantic getaway.

Cottage review

Guest: Claudia SC (Brooklyn, NY)
Date of Stay: 03/31/10 Review Submitted: 04/14/10

We had a great time. It is a lovely house, very comfortable, clean and well decorated. The location is private and quiet. It has everything you need for your stay. We are looking forward to going back.

Recommended for:

Guest: Cara7 (Jackson Heights, NY)
Date of Stay: 10/01/09 Review Submitted: 10/01/09

We enjoyed our time here immensely. Since we didn't have much time this year for a vacation, the fact that we were able to stay here for just a long weekend was so appreciated and convenient. The house was cozy, clean, and aesthetically pleasing without the clutter. The location was super peaceful and we also loved the convenience of the fenced in yard where our boston terrier had a chance to stretch his legs which he normally doesn't get to do as an apartment dog. The proximity to Wades Beach is a plus too. Thank you Joan!

Recommended for:

Guest: Cindy89 (-)
Date of Stay: 09/25/09 Review Submitted: 09/25/09

This quintessential cottage is an absolutely perfect getaway. It is equipped with everything one needs for a Summer "get away." We cycled all over Shelter Island and really got to know it. We also used a Vespa Scooter to enhance the travel experience around the Island. We found that we never wanted to go off Shelter Island during our 3 week stay. We bought everything to cook right on the Island:local fish markets, Readings Market and organic vegetables from the neighbors!! We always wanted to come back to the cottage and the hammock as it is so peaceful there. The house is set way back from the road and you can't hear anything but nature!!

Recommended for:

Guest: Natalie S. (Union, NJ)
Date of Stay: 09/09/09 Review Submitted: 09/09/09

We loved our stay! Joan was so helpful and accomodating. The house had everything we needed, even bikes, beach chairs and a beach umbrella. The modern kitchen was great. We were close to everything. Our chihuahuas loved the fenced in yard. Everyone enjoyed the hammock! We can't wait to come back next year.

Recommended for:

Guest: Anonymous
Date of Stay: 07/29/09 Review Submitted: 07/29/09

This is the PERFECT little cottage on a perfect little island! It is nicely restored and equipped with modern, comfortable furnishings. Just what you need, not any clutter! Can't wait to come back.

Recommended for:

Guest: Anonymous
Date of Stay: 07/20/09 Review Submitted: 07/20/09

Our family of two adults and two 15 year-old sons enjoyed our recent visit. The house is thoughtfully furnished for visitors with beach chairs, towels, two good touring bikes, kitchen supplies, etc. It is ideal for two adults and 1 child; two convertible living room couches are also available. The area is tranquil and pleasant, and the house is very well located. The owner was responsive and accommodating. We recommend the property and Shelter Island.

Recommended for:

Guest: Nora Cohen (NY, NY)
Date of Stay: 06/05/09 Review Submitted: 06/05/09

We thoroughly enjoyed our weekend in Shelter Island and having this fabulous vacation rental as home base was the highlight of our experience. From the latest amenities to the modern yet cozy décor, it truly felt like we were in a home away from home. In advance of our arrival, the owners were kind enough to provide an enthusiastic description of their beautiful home and recommendations of the island's attractions, and boy were they spot on - everything in fact exceeded our expectations. We are very much looking forward to our next stay later this summer!!!

Recommended for:

Guest: Darel (-)
Date of Stay: 06/03/09 Review Submitted: 06/03/09

We had a great stay over Memorial Day weekend, thank you so much Joan! The place was perfect, the bikes enabled us to get some exercise, and the seafood place around the corner was delicious! Looking forward to coming back again soon...

Recommended for:

Guest: Alex Shteynberg (New York, NY)
Date of Stay: 05/18/09 Review Submitted: 05/18/09

We had a wonderful time, even though the weather was not the best. Exectly the type of place we wanted. Not huge, but lovingly decorated. House had evetyhing we needed, clean and warm. The yard allowed us to relax and let our city-dog run "wild" without warry of him running away.

Recommended for: