Enter a location, property ID, keywords, and/or descriptive words.
60 ft. pool with large sailfish fountain at left end

Bayside Beauty [#247141] | View Property

Sugarloaf Key
House, 3 Bedrooms + Convertible Bed(s), 2 Baths (Sleeps 8)
From $7200.00/mo. to 10500.00/mo.
Write a Review

Traveler Reviews (24)

Sort by:
Bayside Beauty
5/5

PARADISE FOUND!

Guest: Yvette (Virginia)
Date of Stay: 04/07/12 Review Submitted: 05/02/12

My family and I have rented this lovely home for the past two winters while vacationing in the keys. Aside from the comfort and elegance that the house offers, the views are out of this world! It's like landing in the middle of paradise. The pool is amazing and the house is spacious and beautifully decorated. This is the perfect fit for our family of 7. The one level living and the elevator are perfect for any special needs that a family may have. With all the comforts of home, the pool, the bay and the kayaks we find it hard to leave to do anything else! We already have our reservation for next year. Don't miss out on this stunnig beauty by the bay!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 0/0

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Paradise

Guest: Bob L.
Date of Stay: 03/17/12 Review Submitted: 05/09/12

As the saying goes......it does not get any better than this! From our first inquiry over a year ago to today, Kris has been very responsive and a joy to deal with. She always follows through and has earned our complete trust. As to the place, the pictures do not do it justice. A picture might be worth a thousand words but can never adequately convey the feeling you have sitting by the pool with a gentle breeze coming off the bay. It is also the little things that Kris and her husband provide that makes the stay so pleasant. It was nice not having to buy basics like detergents, paper towels, etc. Other placers we have stayed nearby required that you provide everything. Julie, Kris's maintenance supervisor, does a remarkable job getting the place spotless in the few hours she has between renters. When you walk in you feel like you are the first family to ever use the house. Bottom line.....it really doesn't get any better than this!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 0/0

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Just another day in Paradise...

Guest: Relaxed at last... (Northwest Indiana)
Date of Stay: 01/03/12 Review Submitted: 01/26/12

First of all we would like to thank Jon and Kris for sharing their beautiful home, it is even more beautiful than the pictures show. The furnishings and decorations are all top notch. The kitchen has everything you can think of to make a gourmet feast including seasonings! Julie keeps the place spotless and responds promptly to any questions or concerns you might have. There were a few minor repairs needed while we were there and they were handled quickly and no expense was spared to make things right. I would highly recommend this house to anyone looking to relax in a beautiful tropical setting with easy access to Key West. If you feel they need for a little adventure/exercise it is a great neighborhood to walk in with a walking path easily accessible and kayaks provided at the house. We also rented bikes from Big Pine Bicycle rental. They were reasonable and for a small fee delivered and picked them up at the house. Whenever we come to the Keys we have a few favorite restaurants: Pepe's in Key West, No Name Pub in Big Pine Key and Hogfish on Stock Island. Though our favorite thing to do is pick up the fresh fish, shrimp or lobster from Fishbusterz on Stock Island and create our own feast! This was easy to do in the gourmet kitchen and seating was no problem for 6 adults on the lanai. We had the pleasure of staying at the house during a full moon and the moon reflected on the water is breathtaking as are the multitude of stars visible in the sky. Despite being on vacation we made the effort to get up early and watch the sun rise over the water while drinking a cup of Baby's Coffee, another favorite local spot. We have rented multiple times in the Keys and this was the most pleasant experience yet, the owners care about their house and renters. While the deposit required might seem high, it is consistent with the quality of the residence and was returned immediately upon our return. We returned home on Saturday and the deposit check was here by Wednesday! We will be sure to return to visit with our local cat and iguanas as well! Thanks again ;)

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 0/0

Bayside Beauty
5/5

PHENOMENAL vacation house!

Guest: 2BEKS (CA)
Date of Stay: 09/27/11 Review Submitted: 10/13/11

We rented the Bayside Beauty for the USS SPRUANCE Commissioning from 27 Sept to 4 Oct 2011. There were 6 adults and 2 children in our party. We had a hefty order to fill - needing something close to Key West, on the water, with a pool, with an elevator, that slept 8 comfortably - this filled the bill and more! The pictures are EXACTLY what you get. BEAUTIFUL! The home was spacious enough for 8 of us, we LIVED on the screened in porch and down by the pool/water. The bedrooms were super comfy and even the pull out couch was decent. The home is stocked with EVERYTHING that you can possibly need - tons of dishes, silverware, glassware, pots, pans, etc - perfect! The owners and the caretakers are a DELIGHT to work with - very accommodating and always prompt with responses to questions. Location wise - about 20 mins to Key West. Also good to note that the only grocery shopping (big store) is also about 20 mins out (either north or south). There is a cute little restaurant not too far away (Mangrove Mamas) that we ate at once - really good! Not really in the "thick of things" for shopping/touristy things - much more secluded and peaceful. EXACTLY what we wanted though. The ONLY improvement that could possibly be made to this property is to put a 3/4 bath downstairs in the laundry area. Having a toilet, sink and shower down there would have made this property perfect in every way. :-D But this is just being picky. LOL! All in all - we'd go back in a heartbeat and can't recommend this property enough! Thank you!!!

Owner response:Thank you, Jennifer. We're very gratified that you enjoyed staying at our home. The only reason that there is not a full bathroom downstairs is that the county won't allow it. If they did, we'd have both a bedroom and bathroom down there.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Fantabulous!!

Guest: Caribbean Girl (Greenville, SC)
Date of Stay: 07/16/11 Review Submitted: 08/01/11

This house is just as great as the pictures show, if not better. The house was very clean inside and out, including the pool, which is all very important to me. The only issue we had with the house is noone wanted to leave. We could have stayed forever and been very happy sipping colodas by the pool, fishing or kayaking on the bay, so much fun! You will not be disappointed in this home. The owners and property keeper were friendly and easy to deal with. And for those who may worry, we got our deposit check back within the week we returned home. It is close to Key West but far enough to be peaceful. This was definately a great choice!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Total Luxury

Guest: Evelyn (South Alabama)
Date of Stay: 06/04/11 Review Submitted: 06/16/11

My family and I just spent our vacation at this Bayside Beauty. You can definitely trust the pictures on this one. The home was just as magnificent as the pictures, plus a little more! I am from the south, and yes, I love to be barefoot. I immediately took off my shoes and felt that the floors were very clean. This matters to me as I have stayed in condos where the accommodations appeared clean, but after taking off my shoe...not as thoroughly as it should have been. The home is beautifully decorated and everything you can possibly need is furnished at the home. The grounds around the home are gorgeous...very tropical. We enjoyed a lot of our time relaxing under the shade of pallms trees...coconuts included. The site manager is there to welcome you with a friendly smile and all the local info you need to know. She continues to be available, via a simple call, if you have further questios or needs. The owners are fantastic as well. Emails were answered promptly each and every time. Our vacation mattered to the owners and they were accommodating in every way. Our vacation experience was well enriched by staying at the Bayside Beauty. I will try to book this home each time we visit the Keys.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 3/3

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Fantastic Tropical Getaway

Guest: Tom (Gulf Breeze, Florida)
Date of Stay: 05/14/11 Review Submitted: 06/07/11

Our experience was phenomenal. This home made it easy to truly waste away in paradise. It was the perfect setting to regroup with family who live far away. The home was clean, and well equipped. The gardens were lush and the pool was gorgeous. Kris and Julie were just a phone call away for any questions. We enjoyed snorkeling and kayaking right in the back yard. The boat lift was great to have. We rented a deckboat with a full bimini and had easy access to Marvin Key in the back-country, as well as, Looe Key offshore at the reef. The pool was so refreshing and loved the hammock! Swinging in the hammock turned into 3 hour naps for different family members. Great location - Key West is only 16 miles away and a wonderful local restaurant (Mangrove Mama's) is only a couple minutes from the front door. We have already recommended this home to friends. Cannot wait to return for our next reunion.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Even Better than the pictures!!!

Guest: Russ (Clayton, GA, USA)
Date of Stay: 04/09/11 Review Submitted: 04/27/11

The pictures of this place really caught my eye and then when I read about how well it was equipped I made my reservation. However, in the back of my mind I was wondering if it would really be that nice when I got there and saw it in person. Well, now that I've been there I can answer that question with a resounding YES . . and more. First of all, the owner Kris and the property manager Julie, are great to work with. They not only handled all the administrative rental business efficiently, they also were great sources of information for local activities and interests. In regards to the property, the first thing I noticed when I pulled up was the beautiful landscaping that provides for a very lush, quiet and private setting. The house itself is equipped for just about anything you can think of. It even has an elevator and since I must use a wheelchair to get around, it was a necessity; and it worked flawlessly during my stay. The only problem with this place is the "tough" decisions it requires you to make . . "Do I swim in the awesome pool or the beautiful crystal clear bay?" . . Should we have drinks on the bay-side dock or enjoy a raised view from the expansive screened lanai?" You'll figure it out. Of course you can have a fantastic vacation if you just stayed at the house; but it's location provides a perfect home base for day trips to the other Keys. My family and I made a couple trips to Key West and had a fantastic day at Bahai Honda State Park that included seeing a waterspout . . very cool. We all had a great time at this beautiful home and hope to stay there again sometime. You can't go wrong with this place.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

ALL YOU COULD ASK FOR

Guest: Harry (Porter Ranch, CA)
Date of Stay: 02/26/11 Review Submitted: 04/12/11

We stayed in the Bayside Beauty in March 2011 and found the house to be even better than portrayed on the website. The house was spacious, elegantly decorated, and had every convenience that one could want during a fabulous Keys vacation. The location on Sugarloaf Sound is stunning with gorgeous views from the house, the lanai, and the dock. Also, it was an easy drive to Key West. The pool was beautiful and the grounds were well manicured and attractive. Kris was extremely helpful in answering our questions before our arrival and Julie, who greeted us on our arrival was a gem!! The house was spotless and any questions that we had were handled efficiently by Julie. Also Kris handled all administrative details in an efficient and professional manner. We were very comfortable in this fantastic home and would definitely return to the "Bayside Beauty" the next time we are in the Keys.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Fantastic Vacation!

Guest: Chipie (Boston, MA)
Date of Stay: 01/29/11 Review Submitted: 02/11/11

Our stay at this home was a delightful. The owner Kris was very accommodating. My husband and I, along with our 1 year old daughter, my sister and my parents, rented this home and enjoyed it very much. The house is beautiful! It’s very nicely decorated and fully stocked with everything we needed. My family loves to cook, so we made very good use of the large kitchen. We enjoyed the home cooked meals on the lanai where the view of the bay was lovely. The house resides in a very quiet residential neighborhood, perfect for a family to relax and enjoy the warm sun of the Florida Keys. The pool was perfect, and we spent most of the time lounging there and fishing off the deck. Although my husband didn’t catch much, except a bunch of tiny fish, it was entertaining and we all enjoyed it. We used the kayaks, and paddled around the bay. Much fun was had by all. The woman who takes care of the home, Julie, kept the house in perfect condition, and very clean. She was also very helpful in recommending two great restaurants. As per her recommendations, we tried The Square Grouper, and Bobalus Southern Café. Both had great food. Overall, we had a wonderful vacation, and would definitely consider renting this home again.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Family Reunion in an Extraordinary Setting!

Guest: none (Idaho)
Date of Stay: 12/25/10 Review Submitted: 01/07/11

Our stay at "Bayside Beauty" was absolutely extraordinary! The home is gorgeous and the accommodations for our family were perfect! There are two large beautiful bedrooms , one with an equally beautiful bathroom. The other smaller bedroom is perfect for two kids. We had one little one who enjoyed the pool but we could also feel confident in his safety because the access to the pool and dock could be controlled by a locked door and porch in the upper house. The sea kayaking off the dock was just the best and was ideal for everyone in the family as the bay is protected , or braver souls can venture around the key into much more challenging waters. The owners even provide various child and adult life preservers to accompany those paddlers. The kitchen and great room are perfect for a family reunion , as all can be engaged in different activities whether it be cooking, eating, watching the big screen T.V . or even swimming and still be connected to each other by the openness of this lovely and spacious home. The owners, as well as the staff who care for the home, are accommodating , friendly and went the extra mile to make us feel welcome and attended to. Kristan, the owner, even phoned grocers in the area to check their hours for Christmas Day since that is when we were worried about obtaining food! The home is cleaned by Julie who is very attentive to detail as well as friendly and very well informed about the area. Dwight is a very capable neighbor who helped us promptly with just a small plumbing issue. The house is close to Key West, a spectacular beach called Bahai Honda, and any other amenity you might have. The neighborhood is beautiful and safe. This home is a discovery in paradise that we would love to return to sometime in the future!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Great home for a family reunion!

Guest: none (Idaho)
Date of Stay: 12/24/10 Review Submitted: 01/08/11

"Our stay at "Bayside Beauty" was absolutely extraordinary! The home is gorgeous and the accommodations for our family were perfect! There are two large beautiful bedrooms , one with an equally beautiful bathroom. The other smaller bedroom is perfect for two kids. We had one little one who enjoyed the pool but we could also feel confident in his safety because the access to the pool and dock could be controlled by a locked door and porch in the upper house. The sea kayaking off the dock was just the best and was ideal for everyone in the family as the bay is protected , or braver souls can venture around the key into much more challenging waters. The owners even provide various child and adult life preservers to accompany those paddlers. The kitchen and great room are perfect for a family reunion , as all can be engaged in different activities whether it be cooking, eating, watching the big screen T.V . or even swimming and still be connected to each other by the openness of this lovely and spacious home. The owners, as well as the staff who care for the home, are accommodating , friendly and went the extra mile to make us feel welcome and attended to. Kristan, the owner, even phoned grocers in the area to check their hours for Christmas Day since that is when we were worried about obtaining food! The home is cleaned by Julie who is very attentive to detail as well as friendly and very well informed about the area. Dwight is a very capable neighbor who helped us promptly with just a small plumbing issue. The house is close to Key West, a spectacular beach called Bahai Honda, and any other amenity you might have. The neighborhood is beautiful and safe. This home is a discovery in paradise that we would love to return to sometime in the future! "

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 2/2

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Great location ... great home

Guest: RF (New York, NY)
Date of Stay: 12/04/10 Review Submitted: 12/28/10

We spent a couple of weeks at this great place in early December. The location, the pool and the views are as magnificent as the pictures would lead you to believe and the house is perfect: spotless, very nicely furnished and well equipped. We stayed there with my parents and our little one and the accommodations were ideal for our family, with 2 large bedrooms for the adults and a smaller one for our child. The housekeeper was very helpful and friendly, providing useful recommendations (the Square Grouper restaurant, a few miles north of Sugarloaf Key, would be one of them) and going out of her way to be of assistance. We are definitely planning to go back and have already recommended this beautiful house to some of our friends

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 2/2

Bayside Beauty
4/5

Relaxing, Fun, Exciting Keydelicious

Guest: FLip Flops and Casual Tops (Ohio)
Date of Stay: 10/01/10 Review Submitted: 12/06/10

We enjoyed a delightful vacation retreat at this beautiful property. Clean is always top priority for us and this was clean and comfortable. We will definitely consider staying here again and appreciate the opportunity to enjoy a safe haven while discovering the beautiful keys. The Florida Key folk are the most kind individuals you will ever meet!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Just beautiful!

Guest: Frank (Valkaria,fl)
Date of Stay: 09/11/10 Review Submitted: 10/02/10

We stayed at the bayside beauty sept.11-18th and I will tell you that this is one beautiful, fun place to stay! The place is even more beautiful than the photos. The landscaping is a 10! The pool is sooo nice and designed perfectly.The house was clean and inviting when we arrived thanks to Julie who takes care of the house and took care of all our needs and questions prompty. Durring our stay we experienced no issues with the house and everything worked as it should the whole time. The area is nice and quiet and only a 15 minute run to Key West. The owner of the property(Cris) obviously spares no expense in the upkeep of the house and property and is more than a pleasure to deal with. It is nice for the place to be as nice as advertised because I've found alot of places are not. I will rent here again and look forward to it.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Perfect Keys Getaway

Guest: Steve (Miami, FL)
Date of Stay: 08/28/10 Review Submitted: 09/08/10

We just returned from a wonderful stay at Bayside Beauty. The house has everything one needs for a vacation. It is fully furnished, modern, very clean and located in an upscale neighborhood. The pictures of the pool and water views drew us there but the real thing was even better. I went with my wife and 14 month old daughter. My girls didn't want to leave the place and fell in love with the pool and hammock! I went kayaking and snorkeling everyday and you can easily spend all day kayaking around the area exploring. I was concerned about the mosquitoes this time of year but none of us were bitten once and honestly we didn't even see a mosquito the entire time. I would highly recommend the house to anyone considering a Lower Keys vacation, you will not be disappointed.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 2/2

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Extremely Relaxing!

Guest: Floridians (Florida)
Date of Stay: 07/17/10 Review Submitted: 08/06/10

Everything about the house we loved; we felt very safe and the house was well stocked...loved the neighborhood as well. The photos online are exactly how the house is...no shortcuts...perfect. Our greeter made us feel very comfortable. Easy to find attractions, or you'll be happy just staying put. On a scale from 1-10, 10!!!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Paradise in Sugarloaf bay

Guest: Jansens (Amsterdam, the Netherlands, Europe)
Date of Stay: 07/17/10 Review Submitted: 07/23/10

We are a couple with 2 teenagers from the Netherlands, Europe. We were welcomed by the friendly caretaker who showed us around, the house was very clean. Huge and very luxurious for European standards (two enormous fridges). We enjoyed the huge, comfortable lanai. Sitting on the comfortable couch, watching sunrise while we were fighting jet leg was amazing. A beautiful view, a nice breeze and every morning paradise comes to light. The pool and garden are even more beautiful than in the pictures! The pool is 20 meters wide and has a view on a large bay. Sitting on the deck we watched our girls taking trips in the kayaks. The gas barbeque is huge. Sitting on the deck, overlooking the bay while eating your own BBQ-ed shrimps is awesome. Key West is close for shopping and dining. We recommend Duval street with its nice shops, bars and restaurants. Visiting the south point is a must. We would definitely recommend this house, thanks for letting us enjoy it! For us it was truly paradise.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

We had an excellent vacation at the Bayside Beauty

Guest: Tiffany (Palm Bay, Florida)
Date of Stay: 07/01/10 Review Submitted: 07/23/10

Our vacation was excellent at the the Bayside Beauty! The photos are exactly what you get, just as beautiful as the photos! This home has all of the amenities that you need, just pack your bags, bring your boat(s), family and friends, and your set! It was very relaxing, the view was beautiful, the kids loved fishing off of the dock, we even snorkeled right off of the dock. About 15-20 minutes from Duval Street in Key West. Everything was Excellent! Thanks for having us and we hope to return again next year!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

We had an excellent vacation at the Bayside Beauty!

Guest: Tiffany (Palm Bay, Florida)
Date of Stay: 07/01/10 Review Submitted: 07/23/10

Our vacation was excellent at the the Bayside Beauty! The photos are exactly what you get, just as beautiful as the photos! This home has all of the amenities that you need, just pack your bags, bring your boat(s), family and friends, and your set! It was very relaxing, the view was beautiful, the kids loved fishing off of the dock, we even snorkeled right off of the dock. About 15-20 minutes from Duval Street in Key West. Everything was Excellent! Thanks for having us and we hope to return again next year!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Guest: Kerry Rhodes (Macomb, Illinois)
Date of Stay: 11/10/09 Review Submitted: 11/10/09

Our party of four just thoroughly enjoyed a week long stay at Bayside Beauty. The house and grounds are even more impressive than the pictures on the website. We have rented many houses in many tropical areas and we all agreed that this was the best yet. We will definitely return the next time we come to the Keys.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Guest: Tara32 (Waxahachie TX)
Date of Stay: 10/26/09 Review Submitted: 10/26/09

This was a home away form home. Everything was wonderful and the house was beyond our expectations. We will return again!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Great Place To Stay

Guest: Jeff K (Plantation, Fl )
Date of Stay: 08/01/09 Review Submitted: 09/10/10

I stayed at the Bayside Beauty August of 2010. The house was fantastic and it felt more like a 5 star resort then a vacation home (I cannot rate this place high enough). When we arrive the place absolutely immaculate on the inside and out. The kids loved the huge pool and we enjoyed boating to Looe Key along with various places. Both the owner and the property manager were very quick to respond to any questions that I had after I booked the trip. In addition my security deposit was promptly returned. I highly recommend this place and i plan on returning next summer

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 2/2

Bayside Beauty
5/5

Guest: Richard H. (-)
Date of Stay: 06/14/09 Review Submitted: 06/14/09

Kris and John,We have returned from our vacation to your home. What a spectacular place!! It was just what we were looking for. We must have caught 70 fish off of the dock, including a 4 ft nurse shark. The landscaping and the pool were beyond beautiful. We will definately go back. A romantic, peaceful, very private, tropical paradise! Thanks again! Janice and Richard

Did you find this review helpful? Yes | No

Helpful votes: 1/1



Page 1 of 1 [ 1 ]