Vacation Rentals by Owner
New Bahamas Private Atlantic Eleuthera Island Beachfront House [#272900] | View Property
Governor's Harbour
House, 1 Bedroom, 1.5 Baths (Sleeps 2)
From $1495/wk
Write a Review
Traveler Reviews (15)
I wish I could tell ya not to go, BUT....
Guest: Ed
(Spokane,WA)
Date of Stay: 01/12/12
Review Submitted: 01/30/12
I can't!! Allen and Maureen share a piece of Paradise that you won't ever forget! We had a perfect time. If your looking for a simple, independent, relaxing location read the reviews and then Go!
Owner response:Hate to say I told you so BUT....glad you decided to spend your birthday here on the Island and at Cayo Loco!!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway.
Great place to stay
Guest: beachbums
(Atlantic Beach, NC)
Date of Stay: 12/25/11
Review Submitted: 01/30/12
We stayed for 10 days and enjoyed every day. Even the very chilly one. Great place for 2 people to relax.
Owner response:We were so happy that you chose Cayo Loco and look forward to seeing you again next year!!
Recommended for:Age 55+
Everything and More!
Guest: sfielder
(Victoria BC, Canada)
Date of Stay: 11/27/11
Review Submitted: 01/25/12
We stayed at Cayo Loco at the beginning of December and would recommend it to anyone looking for a relaxing vacation in paradise. The VRBO webpage doesn't do it any justice. Its truly everything we were looking for and more. The owners are the nicest people and so accommodating. They also stay out of your way if that's what you are looking for. The beach was uninhabited while we were there and we had it all to ourselves. The resort down the beach has the best food and was also never busy. The house was perfect and had everything you would want. Be prepared for a bit of wind on the Atlantic side if you are there in December.Make sure you have a car rented if you want to go into town to get supplies. We rented bikes for a couple of days which was nice but the roads arent great and are a bit dangerous on a bike. I hope we can come back soon. :)
Owner response:Wonderful that you appreciated your 'vacation in paradise'! It is always lovely to hear that Cayo Loco exceeded your expectations!
Recommended for:Age 55+, romantic getaway.
Peaceful and charming
Guest: Pink and green
(East Hampton, New York)
Date of Stay: 10/22/11
Review Submitted: 10/29/11
My husband and I celebrated our 8 year anniversary in this perfect setting. The house was immaculate and had everything that one would need in the kitchen, though we did not use anything much but the refrigerator and bottle opener! The bed was extremely comfortable, plenty of closet space and the deck was amazing. Steps to the beach with your own very cute palapa and colorful beach chairs. A true beach fantasy!
Owner response:So glad we were able to make your anniversary special at Cayo Loco. Great luck with your island home and hope to see you back again on our beach.
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway.
Walking on a dream
Guest: Vivian and Pieter
(Amsterdam)
Date of Stay: 09/03/11
Review Submitted: 11/29/11
We stayed at Maureen and Alan's beach house named Cayo Loco for twelve days and it was amazing. After seeing the photos on their website and reading the positive reviews we were convinced that this vacation rental would be a great place to stay at Eleuthera. We arrived a week after Hurricane Irene hit the island. Fortunately there wasn't a lot of damage at the property. The beach house is newly built, very clean and contains everything you need to have a relaxed stay (dishwasher, beach chairs, snorkel gear, books, dvds etc etc). Maureen and Alan are very helpfull, kind and positive. Their house is located close to the rental house but you feel very private. The view is great, we spent most of our time sitting on the porch looking at the waves and the beautiful sky. Unfortunately we did not get to meet the dolphins, so hopefully we will be able to go back soon. We both have traveled a lot but this was the best vacation ever! Pieter & Vivian
Owner response:It was so wonderful to have you visit from Amsterdam which brought back such fond memories of our vacation there. We have a piece of cheese still hidden in the freezer for a treat. We are always thrilled when someone gets to share our piece of heaven. Your little friends are awaiting your return and hoping it is sooner rather than later.
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway, sightseeing.
Simple, modern, bright, airy & what a view!
Guest: Was Very Happy
(New York City)
Date of Stay: 06/24/11
Review Submitted: 07/05/11
Just returned from our honeymoon here -- it was perfect. This cottage is simple and modern, with lots of light, a constant and enjoyable sea breeze and the view from the deck is unbeatable. The beach is gorgeous and rarely has people on it, and a few properties down you'll find a great hotel restaurant and infinity pool w/ hot tub. Also, the location is perfect -- right in the middle of the island, so day trips to various destinations are never too distant (go see lighthouse beach...wow!); it's close to a supermarket, too. The property owners -- Maureen & Alan -- gave us all the privacy we needed but were there whenever we had questions about the cottage and the island. They even provided a handy book they created w/ restaurant/beach advice, maps, etc., which we brought everywhere. It's worth noting that they are very nice, down-to-earth people too (they even had a bottle of champagne waiting for us in the fridge). I recommend this spot without hesitation!
Owner response:Thank you so much for the glowing review and we are both so thrilled that we were able to help make your honeymoon so special!! Cayo Loco will be here whenever you are ready for a repeat visit!!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway, sightseeing.
Charming Oceanfront Cottage on Beautiful and peaceful beach
Guest: Julie T
(Salem, MA)
Date of Stay: 04/22/11
Review Submitted: 04/30/11
My husband and I just returned from this charming cottage on a beautiful beach and if you want to really escape the chaos of everyday life this is a lovely cottage. The owners were beyond helpful from the initial inquiry through our departure.(which was quite early)...providing helpful tips all along the way. Wonderful people......very peaceful retreat....and the dolphins just off the the beach the day before we left....breathtaking...
Owner response:Cayo Loco, Eleuthera and The Bahamas are so lucky and thankful to have you as fans. It was wonderful to meet you both and we are thrilled that you enjoyed our little slice of heaven. We anxiously await your return to paradise!
Recommended for:Romantic getaway
A very special place to vacation...
Guest: Jeff
(New York)
Date of Stay: 04/19/11
Review Submitted: 05/07/11
I will say that as amazing as the pictures of this place are, they do not even come close to the beauty of this house. We had an amazing time staying here and the pink sand beach in the front yard was one of the most stunning! I have rented from places that may stretch the truth or pictures but this was a truly special experience and far exceed our expectations. We could not have asked for more. So thank you again for your incredible hospitality and really delivering a wow with this very special place. You guys have ruined us as we don't know that any vacation could ever live up to this one! We cannot wait to come back and visit in the coming months.... I feel like as many great things as we saw that there is still so much to see and do!
Owner response:That is so great to hear from you as I know you were looking for a very special experience and we are so glad that Cayo Loco and Eleuthera were able to deliver! We have heard from your friends that you referred and will take excellent care of them as well. Look forward to your return this summer!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, romantic getaway.
Lovely place with an amazing view in a naturally beautiful area!
Guest: Mike and Laura
(St. Paul, MN)
Date of Stay: 03/30/11
Review Submitted: 04/15/11
We love it here!! This lovely place has picture perfect views and feels very private. Owners Alan & Maureen were so kind and helpful, we felt like they were our best friends throughout the planning and our stay. We found this area to be an overall friendly and safe place and great for walking miles in either direction on the beach or on the sandy bank road! Amazing snorkeling! We saw dolphins, a small shark, turtles, rays, lobsters, and a huge variety of colorful fish. The house is new, lovely, and comfortable and had everything we needed for a relaxing beach bumming vacation such as great tasting R/O drinking water, a dishwasher, maps, towels, snorkel gear, TV/DVD/docking station, outdoor shower, etc. This is a gem of a place, we highly suggest it!
Owner response:We are so thrilled that you loved Eleuthera and Cayo Loco as much as we do! We look forward to having you both and anyone you refer back to visit sooner rather than later! Thanks for taking such great care and appreciation of our precious slice of Paradise!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, tourists without a car, romantic getaway.
Perfection
Guest: Mary and Bill
(Massachusetts)
Date of Stay: 03/18/11
Review Submitted: 04/04/11
It's true....location, location, location. This perfect house right on a secluded strech of beach is a great location. It's centrally located between great restaurants, stunning beaches and a lovely little town. Maureen provided "local knowledge" about restaurants, stores and beaches that look like they're photo-shopped! In our get-away week, we went to 6 different beaches, none further than 10 miles away, and were usually the only people on the beach. We ate at great restaurants, used the local library, and enjoyed Fish Fry on Friday night. It just doesn't get better than Cayo Loco.
Owner response:We would love to have you back again in the future to enjoy our very special spot in Paradise! We are thrilled that you appreciate how important location really is especially on your beach vacation!
Recommended for:Age 55+, romantic getaway.
The best vacation/getaway spot!
Guest: Sandy
(Fort Myers, FL)
Date of Stay: 02/23/11
Review Submitted: 03/31/11
As a 20 year wedding anniversary celebration and a much-needed getaway from our hectic world, Cayo Loco was a destination that fulfilled all our wishes. Maureen and Alan are gracious hosts, meticulous to details, and the house was exactly as pictured; actually even better in real life. As for the beach experience there is really no photo that can do it justice--simply stunning, and truly our own while we were there. We loved cooking fresh catch purchased from the locals in the charming kitchen, or grilled up outside. We rented a 4 wheel drive jeep that allowed us to explore the vast island, and experience many of the wonderful restaurants, and explore Eleuthera's beaches. Maureen and Alan have thought of every detail to include at Cayo Loco; beach chairs, towels, outdoor shower, even a cell phone for our use; this encouraged us to leave ours at home which added to our experience of truly getting away from it all. We will be back to enjoy this wonderful place again, thank you for sharing your beautiful cottage on VRBO!
Owner response:We are so pleased that you chose to celebrate your 20th Anniversary with us and even more thrilled that you will be joining us every year - we will happily look forward to your returns!!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway, sightseeing.
Perfect little beach house!
Guest: Kim and Kevin
(Ontario, Canada)
Date of Stay: 12/31/10
Review Submitted: 01/13/11
We have just returned from a fabulous vacation at Cayo Loco. The house is lovely and couldn't have been in a better location. It was heavenly to relax on the porch and overlook the sea, take long walks on the deserted beaches, and stargaze in the evening. The house was spotless and well equipped and Al and Maureen were wonderful and accommodating. We loved our time there and are already dreaming about returning!
Owner response:You were fabulous guests and we glady await your return!!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, romantic getaway.
A slice of heaven and a relaxing vacation!
Guest: Allen
(New York City)
Date of Stay: 11/20/10
Review Submitted: 04/03/11
The most wonderful private spot in the world. Perched high on a sand dune overlooking the most glorious clear blue ocean and pink sand beaches. This charming one bedroom cottage was cozy and comfortable with all the amenities you need. Including a fully equip kitchen with a dishwasher and a luxurious bathroom with a large shower plus there is a great outdoor shower. Stunning views from every window. We loved the front porch were we enjoyed drinking our morning coffee to eating our lunch after an ocean swim. At night the ocean waves, sea breeze and stars put on an impressive show. The hosts Alan and Maureen couldn't be more accommodating. They are a wealth of island information. We love this beach cottage and most definitely will be back next year.
Owner response:We are so looking forward to your return. You are part of the family now. We will try to schedule a dolphin and turtle visit if they are available. If not, you've always got the leopard rays at The Current Cut!
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, romantic getaway.
spectacular
Guest: J & J
(great falls, mt)
Date of Stay: 11/13/10
Review Submitted: 02/26/11
We would recommend this perfect getaway location to any couple. The beach is ideal for long walks. We found the people on the island to be very hospitable. Alan & Maureen were extremely friendly & helpful. We toured the entire island during our week stay including Harbour Island to see the "pink sand" beach. Resturants are plentiful. Groceries are adequate for making your own meals, which we did frequently in the new kitchen. Having on demand hotwater is the best! We will be back-soon I hope.
Owner response:We loved having you both and enjoyed getting to know you. And the dolphin encounter was great to share with you! We now have a 4 foot turtle that you'll be able to swim with on your return visit.
Recommended for:Adventure seekers, age 55+, romantic getaway, sightseeing.
Vacation of our dreams!
Guest: ShinPond
(Northern Virginia)
Date of Stay: 04/16/10
Review Submitted: 04/30/10
My wife and I just returned from the best vacation of our lives! Cayo Loco far exceeded the online photos and our expectations! Maureen and Alan turned out a spotless home with everything as advertised. It is the first vacation rental where everything worked...down to the blender (gotta love those frozen Pina Coladas!). Maureen had an island reference notebook with absolutely everything you needed in the way of restaurants, local events and popular beaches. Cayo Loco as home or vacation rental on the beach is simply stunning! We have already recommended it to our friends in Northern Virginia.
Owner response:It was a pleasure having you both in our home and are thrilled that you will be back with your family and friends.....thanks for all the referrals!!
Recommended for:Tourists without a car, romantic getaway, sightseeing.