VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

Waterfront Charmer on Idyllic Shelter Island for Summer Rental

You sent a message to this owner.


Last updated: 11/05/2014
Check availability
23 Available
21 Unavailable
22 Today
23 Selected dates
  • Minimum stay:30 nights
  • Internet:Yes
  • Pets considered:No
  • Wheel chair accessible:No

Shelter Island Heights house description

Situated on one half acre of protected waterfront, this house has an open floor plan to entertain with ease and style. The gourmet kitchen includes a Viking stove and two prep areas. Your dining experience will always include water views, whether you are indoors in the dining room, or on the outdoor deck at a teak table under a market umbrella. The first floor also includes a sun room, small media room, and an additional bedroom and bath. Upstairs there are two master suites with generous size bedrooms and baths. A deck surrounds the house in addition to the front porch. Sun or shade can be found any time of day from sunrise to sunset. One portion of the property has a sandy beach that is perfect for swimming and kayaking, while there is adjacent bulk heading and dock to accommodate two large boats. Exterior features also an outdoor grille and outdoor shower. This house is the perfect setting for the ultimate summer living experience. Just bring your suitcase and enjoy!

This house affords the opportunity for outdoor living, water sports and sandy beaches at your finger tips.
It is clean, easy to maintain with an open feeling that makes you feel like you are outside even when you are inside.
It is a boaters paradise on sheltered water with quick, easy access to open waters.

It is a three minute ferry ride to Sag Harbor and 10 minute ferry ride to Greenport.
Summer festivities in these places and on Shelter Island are numerous.
There is the Perlman School of Music which offers free concerts, several Town Beaches offering great swimming in pristine waters and Mashomack Nature Preserve offering hiking with magnificent views. The wildlife with deer, osprey, egrets,and great blue heron is unparalleled. The restaurants on Shelter Island are top rated and offer a variety of fare from casual dining to elegant.


We offer vacation rentals for every budget

Choose from a wide variety of properties

No booking fees

Free to book with no hidden costs

We help you travel with confidence

Every listing is guaranteed against fraud

Experienced property owners or managers

Average five years in the business

Property Type

  • House
  • 3000 sq. ft.

Accommodation Type

      • Vacation Rental


          • Guests Provide Their Own Meals

          Onsite Services

              • Housekeeper Optional


              • Long-Term Renters Welcome
              • Children Welcome
              • Non Smoking Only
              • Pets Not Allowed
              • Suitable For Elderly Or Infirm
              • Wheelchair Inaccessible

              Bedrooms: 3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8

              • Bedroom 1: 1 king

                suite with bath and private waterside deck...moreless

              • Bedroom 2: 1 king

                suite with jacuzzi bath, shower, & office/child's rm...moreless

              • Bedroom 3: 1 queen

                First floor bedroom...moreless

              • The house has two master suites upstairs with generous sized bedrooms and an additional guest bed and bath on the first floor. Suite one has a king size bed, spacious classic bath and a sun deck overlooking the water accessible by French Doors. It is perfect for waterside breakfast, afternoon cocktails, or just leisurely reading. In summer, the Big Dipper is directly over head for nighttime stargazing. Suite two has a large bedroom with king size bed and an adjoining office (or child's room with space for a crib). High speed Internet access with wonderful water views makes any office activity a pleasure. Suite two also has a Jacuzzi bath and a large shower. High ceilings and ceiling fans give each suite a country feel, and the central a/c is rarely needed. There is a high efficiency washer/dryer in a common area closet between the suites....moreless

              Bathrooms: 3 Bathrooms

              • Bathroom 1: toilet, combination tub/shower


              • Bathroom 2: toilet, shower, jetted tub


              • Bathroom 3: toilet, shower


              • Bathroom 4: outdoor shower


              • Each bath features wainscoting and tile with a retro look.

              Other Amenities

                  • Available Long Term for Memorial Day - Labor Day


                  • Books
                  • CD Player
                  • DVD Player
                  • Games
                  • Music Library
                  • Radio
                  • Satellite / Cable
                  • Stereo
                  • Television
                  • VCR
                  • Video Library


                  • Adventure
                  • Away From It All
                  • Family
                  • Romantic


                  • Bay/Sound
                  • Churches
                  • Cinemas
                  • Coin Laundry
                  • Marina
                  • Restaurants
                  • Winery Tours

                  Local Services & Businesses

                  • ATM/Bank
                  • Fitness Center
                  • Groceries
                  • Laundromat
                  • Massage Therapist
                  • Medical Services

                  Leisure Activities

                  • Antiquing
                  • Beachcombing
                  • Bird Watching
                  • Horseback Riding
                  • Sight Seeing
                  • Walking

                  Location Type

                  • Beach
                  • Beachfront
                  • Rural
                  • Water View
                  • Waterfront
                  • Waterfront

                  Sports & Adventure Activities

                  • Cycling
                  • Deepsea Fishing
                  • Equestrian Events
                  • Fishing
                  • Golf
                  • Hiking
                  • Jet Skiing
                  • Roller Blading
                  • Sailing
                  • Scuba Diving Or Snorkeling
                  • Snorkeling
                  • Sound/Bay Fishing
                  • Surf Fishing
                  • Surfing
                  • Swimming
                  • Tennis
                  • Water Skiing
                  • Wind-Surfing


                  • Dining
                  • Dining Room
                  • Seating for 8 people


                  • Air Conditioning
                  • Alarm Clock
                  • Broadband Access
                  • Ceiling Fans
                  • Clothes Dryer
                  • Filtered Water
                  • Garage
                  • Hair Dryer
                  • Heating
                  • Internet
                  • Iron & Board
                  • Linens Provided
                  • Living Room
                  • Parking
                  • Parking Off Street
                  • Sofa Bed
                  • Telephone
                  • Towels Provided
                  • Washing Machine
                  • Water Cooler
                  • Wireless Internet


                  • 4 Ring Stove
                  • Blender
                  • Coffee Grinder
                  • Coffee Maker
                  • Cooking Utensils
                  • Dishes & Utensils
                  • Dishwasher
                  • Freezer
                  • Grill
                  • Ice Maker
                  • Kitchen
                  • Lobster Pot
                  • Microwave
                  • Oven
                  • Pantry Items
                  • Refrigerator
                  • Stove
                  • Toaster


                  • Balcony
                  • Beach Chairs
                  • Beach Towels
                  • Bicycles
                  • Deck / Patio
                  • Fish Cleaning Table
                  • Kayak / Canoe
                  • Lawn / Garden
                  • Outdoor Grill
                  • Outdoor Grill Gas
                  • Unscreened Porch / Veranda
                  • Walkway To Water
                  • Wood Deck

                  House Cleaning

                      • Housekeeper Optional


                      This property does not have any reviews yet.

                      Be the first to write a review for this listing...

                      Rental basis: Per property
                      Dates Nightly Weekend Night Weekly Monthly * Event
                      July 2015
                      Jul 1 - Jul 31, 2015
                      30 night min stay

                      August 2015
                      Aug 1 - Aug 31, 2015
                      30 night min stay

                      * Approximate Monthly rates, actual rate will depend on the days of the month you stay

                      Additional information about rental rates


                      • Final cleaning $150
                      • Utilities $300
                      • Taxes Included


                      July 1 - Sept. 7 (LD) $50,000

                      July 1- July 31 $22,500

                      Aug. 1 - Aug 31 $25,000

                      Aug. 1-Sept. 7 (LD) $30,000

                      Utilities and final cleaning not included

                      multiple payments

                      Please wait... Travel with confidence

                      Pay with an approved method (credit card, check, or bank transfer) to protect your payment up to $1,000. Before making a payment always call the owner at the number listed on our website, and never use instant money transfer services such as Western Union and MoneyGram.

                      Don't forget your vacation protection! Get protected now

                      Adding our Vacation Protection services can make sure your getaway goes smoothly, no matter what. We offer Cancellation Protection, Carefree Rental Guarantee, and Damage Protection so you can truly relax.

                      Protect your payments in case you need to cancel.
                      Guarantee the rental meets your expectations.
                      Ensure you're prepared in case of accidental damage.


                      Last updated: 11/05/2014
                      Check availability
                      23 Available
                      21 Unavailable
                      22 Today
                      23 Selected dates


                      45 Miles
                      Nearest Airport
                      LI Macarthur Airport
                      1 Miles
                      Nearest Barpub
                      3 Miles
                      Nearest Ferry
                      North Ferry
                      1 Miles
                      Nearest Golf
                      3 Miles
                      Nearest Train
                      Greenport/ Bridgehampton
                      25 Miles
                      Nearest Motorway
                      Long Island Expressway
                      1 Miles
                      Nearest Restaurant
                      0.5 Miles
                      Nearest Beach
                      Shell Beach

                      Car: Recommended

                      Shelter Island is a peaceful respite between the North and South forks of eastern Long Island. Access to the island is by car ferry; from Greenport on the North Fork, a 10 minute ride, or from Northaven on the south side with about a five minute ride. The island offers all the pleasures of east end summer life, including pristine beaches for swimming fishing, or boating. There is a 9 hole public golf course and plenty of places to eat a wide range of local cuisines.


                      Owner info

                      Contact us

                      Speaks: english, italian

                      Guestbook comments from the owner

                      1 of 6


                      • Bring your boat & bathing suit

                        Bring your boat & bathing suit

                      • View from West Neck Bay

                        View from West Neck Bay

                      • Sun Room overlooking deck and dock

                        Sun Room overlooking deck and dock

                      • Gourmet kitchen

                        Gourmet kitchen

                      • Enjoy waterside outdoor dining

                        Enjoy waterside outdoor dining

                      • Front proch

                        Front proch

                      • Wild life abounds

                        Wild life abounds

                      • Bath


                      • Available bikes

                        Available bikes

                      • View from dock

                        View from dock

                      • View from second floor deck

                        View from second floor deck

                      • Looking East from the dock

                        Looking East from the dock

                      • Early spring view from the deck

                        Early spring view from the deck

                      • Enjoy open living space

                        Enjoy open living space

                      • Sun Room

                        Sun Room

                      • Indoor water view dining

                        Indoor water view dining

                      • Covered Porch

                        Covered Porch

                      • Toward West Neck

                        Toward West Neck

                      • Bed Room Suite

                        Bed Room Suite

                      • One  master suite

                        One master suite

                      • Upstairs Deck

                        Upstairs Deck

                      • Available Kayaks

                        Available Kayaks

                      • Sunrise


                      • Arrival
Jim Colligan photo

                        Arrival Jim Colligan photo

                      $22,500 - $25,000 per month (USD)

                      3 Bedroom / 3 Bathroom
                      Sleeps 8

                      View calendar: Updated 11/05/14
                      Minimum stay: 30 nights
                      Dates are unavailable
                      Please stay a bit longer. A stay of nights or more is required for these dates.
                      This listing requires that rentals start on a .
                      Get an instant quote
                      Member since: 2011
                      Speaks: english, italian
                      • Calendar last updated: 11/05/2014
                      Email owner

                      +1 516 456-9839
                      before 8pm est

                      Please wait... Travel with confidence Guaranteed, secure, with no booking fees Learn how to pay safely
                      Add vacation protection services to your booking

                      Three services to protect your trip:

                      Protect your payments in case you need to cancel.

                      Guarantee the rental meets your expectations.

                      Ensure you're prepared in case of accidental damage.

                      Get it now


                      Share this property via Email

                      Waterfront Charmer on idyllic Shelter Island for summer rental

                      Shelter Island Heights #364166ha

                      3 BR  3 BA  Sleeps 8

                      You must be signed in to share this property by e-mail

                      Share this property via Email

                        Please correct the following errors and resend:
                      • Enter one or more valid email addresses separated by commas.
                      • Oops! You have exceeded the limit of 10 email addresses.
                      • Your message may not contain markup. Please remove the markup and try again.