VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More
This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation
"Stunning views, immaculately clean, minimalist charm, we had everything we could ask for plus the sounds of the waves...would recommend to anyone, it could not have been more comfortable and joyful.
We like to visit different places...but will certainly consider returning to this spot just because it was so perfect for us.
Spent 11 days, could have stayed forever. Our only regret was that the wind was unusually strong during our stay so we did not use the beach, swim out front or make use of the paddle board or kayaks, or sit on our deck for meals. But the beauty of Eleuthera is that if it's windy on one side, good chance it's not on the other - so we spent lots of time exploring the stunning "Caribbean" side. Great snorkeling, deserted beautiful beaches.
Cayo Loco supplies really nice beach chairs and towels - we took these with us everywhere, they were much appreciated! Bring a small cooler (we left one there) for lunches as who wants to leave the beach once you get there? Take Maureen up on her offer to supply coconut water - refreshing morning drink.
Eleuthera itself was just our speed - have never visited the Bahamas because our impression was that they are very touristy. Not so here...Eleuthera is a true throw back in time. The local people as well as all the expats we met could not be more kind and gracious, it is one of the safer islands we have ever visited.
And Cayo Loco is one of the nicest vacation homes we have ever rented. Kudos to Maureen and Alan."
Guest: Maura P.Date of Stay: November 2014Review Submitted: December 8, 2014
"I had the best vacation of my life here. We stayed three weeks. The house itself is lovely, clean, new, with all amenities you would need. We wanted for nothing. It made being away from home very easy. The location was close to everything. The view of Balara Bay was private and outstanding. I snorkeled daily right off my front yard! The tiki hut was perfect for shade and so fun. Chad and Barry, the caretakers, were professional and very personable. They made us feel right at home. We were very comfortable and enjoyed being at Caribbean Blue very much. I kind of wish I could keep it secret, it is that special. Looking forward to visiting again. Thank you for sharing!"
Guest: FlounceyDate of Stay: March 2015Review Submitted: April 20, 2015
"Thank you, Mr. Roberts and Cindy for renting Nella's Nest to us for the week. We enjoyed every second and will come back next year. We loved the view, endless beauty of turquoise sea. Outside Nella's Nest is spectacular. Inside was more than comfortable."
Guest: AndreDate of Stay: February 2015Review Submitted: March 11, 2015
"My husband and I headed to Eleuthera for my 30th birthday celebration. White/pink sand beaches and turquoise water was the best way to ring in a new decade! The cottage is just perfect. It's everything you need packed into a cute little place. I think my favorite part was the jungle shower just steps outside your door. After the day swimming in the saltwater, a cool shower in the open air was perfect. For days we didn't want to venture out, we stayed next to the pool with a cool drink and enjoyed the sunny weather and listened to the water below in the cove.
We did rent a car and went up and down the island many times while we were there exploring beaches and other towns. However, many nights we walked just down the road to grab dinner and drinks.
Kimy & Terry, your place is just amazing. Thank you for letting us experience this special island. We can't wait to go back and get back on island time. Until next time! :)"
Guest: AshleyDate of Stay: March 2015Review Submitted: March 25, 2015