VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Harbour Island reviews

  • Adorable & Lovely Cottage! Perfect for a couple

    "My boyfriend and I stayed at the Conch Pearl this past April (2014) We had an amazing time! It has everything you need for the perfect getaway for two. The house is decorated so beautifully it made the stay a very happy one. Harbour Island is known for their local cat population, and this cottage *luckily* has just about the cutest ones on the island visiting on the back porch. If you stay don't forget to feed them :) The cottage would also be ideal for a big family to rent along with the larger home called 'The Conch Shell' next door. Will definitely be returning. Thanks Trish!"
    Guest: Sally Date of Stay: March 2014 Review Submitted: April 22, 2014
    View listing
  • Perfect Family Vacation

    "Our party of seven, including a 3 year old and two teenagers, had the most wonderful time at Afterthought for a week. The house is well laid out with every vacation rental amenity possible and the convenient location worked perfect for us. We were pleasantly surprised by the bedroom and the pool size, they were bigger than anticipated. The owners were very nice to deal with and prompt with responses. The house is just a few minute walk from the Governor's Dock and we actually walked everywhere, even with a 3 year old. Francine, the housekeeper, was very helpful and kept the house very clean. We can't wait to go back for an extended stay!"
    Guest: PA Family Date of Stay: August 2014 Review Submitted: August 22, 2014
    View listing
  • Perfect house!

    "Our family of 6 stayed for 7 nights in this home. We LOVED it! We walked with our 7 rolling suitcases about 100 feet from the gov dock to the front gate of the house. Our golf cart (from Sunshine Rentals) was waiting for us by the gate with the key in it. (Golf cart was a bit ragged out, but they made it right) The home is adorable on the outside, and beautiful, clean, spacious, comfortable, and well equipped on the inside. Lawrence helped us when we asked, and Judy was like a little elf (came in quickly while we were away and made the house look perfect again). She never touched our personal things (which we really appreciated) like some hotel cleaning ladies do. The owner sent us detailed directions and tips after booking that came in very handy leading up to our vacation, and during our stay. The beach chairs and umbrella provided were so wonderful to have. There were boogie boards and sand toys to use. Handy outdoor shower. We loved having the large back patio for all of our wet hats, towels, snorkel gear, and stuff at the end of the day at the beach. Plenty of pots, dishes, cooking utensils, etc in the kitchen. I would load up the dishwasher each morning and start it before we left for the beach or Eleuthera…and Judy would always unload it for me. Our kids loved all of the space to spread out and play. There is a 5 gallon jug of bottled drinking water under kitchen sink with a spigot at the sink. The owner told us to call the water company on the bottle for a replacement and sit the empty jug out on the front porch with $6. It was that simple both times we called for a replacement. The owner provided an extra full jug for us, to the side in the kitchen,…so there was never a time without water. Bring your own refillable water bottles from home, so you can fill with the house water and take with you to the beach. A large bottle of water at the Blue Bar at the beach is $5.50! This home is convenient to the dock and little cute town. It looks out at the dock and marina side of the island. We felt safe. It's not the beach side, but a fast 3 minute FUN golf cart ride away from the beach. We highly recommend this home for your large family or group. We were sad to leave!"
    Guest: FunFamily Date of Stay: July 2014 Review Submitted: July 21, 2014
    View listing
  • Look no further!

    "My family of 8 spent a week at this house (called Sanderson House) in February. We also rented the guest house behind it. It's hard to describe how fabulous this house is--the layout allows for many private spaces as well as places the group can be together. Every possible amenity has been provided, i.e., everything for the trip to the beach (towels, boogie boards, umbrellas, etc.), as well as a gorgeous pool on the premises, outdoor grill, bar, TV's in many locations, and a kitchen with everything a cook could imagine. It is clean and well maintained and actually, the photos don't do justice to the appearance of this very special home. The bedrooms are spacious, the baths (especially on 1st floor) are luxurious, and the outdoor verandas and porches are so inviting. Everyone's favorite spot was what I call the "widow's walk" on the very top of the house, with amazing views 360 degrees. Whether it was morning coffee or evening drinks, there was always someone up there. As for getting around, we rented 2 golf carts even though we're all hikers, walkers, etc. The house is not far from the center of the little town yet far enough to be really private. The owner and his family were most helpful with every little detail we asked about, and were available for anything that might go wrong. (Nothing did.) A housekeeper was there to clean every day, which was another bonus. I saw some other rental properties on Harbour Island and I'd definitely put Sanderson House at the top of the list. So look no further, this is the place to stay on Harbour Island."
    Guest: Squeek Date of Stay: February 2014 Review Submitted: April 1, 2014
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement