VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Magens Bay reviews

  • Paradise Found!

    "Views were stunningly beautiful. Can't say enough about the views, they almost do not seem real. Pool was a nice plus after a long day of exploring! My family used the pool quite a lot and really enjoyed it. The house is super cute and nicely decorated with comfortable furniture and stocked with everything you could need or want. The owner and caretaker (Cheryl and Robin) were super responsive and provided sufficient information about the house and things to do on the islands. The location is great and accessible to all areas of the island. Very safe and nice neighborhood. We appreciated Robin meeting us at the airport and guiding us to the house and going over everything! As they say in the description though, this house does not have central air and it does get very hot/humid and somewhat uncomfortable in the main living areas. However, the bedrooms are very comfortable and cool as there are AC units in those. As for St. Thomas itself, we ate at Northside Bistro, Mahogany Grille, Amalia Cafe, Glady's, Sibs, and Island Time Pub. Northside Bistro is hands down the best food I have ever eaten...anywhere. It has a beautiful view, outstanding service, and tasty food! Keep in mind, that is does not have AC, but is a screened in porch and quite nice at night with the breezes. Mahogany Grille is the best for steaks and a cozy atmosphere. Glady's is the best spot for lunch downtown!! Amazing food and service. Amalia Cafe was also very nice, but we preferred Glady's. Sibs was more a bar atmosphere, and I highly do not recommend for lunch or dinner. Tables were dirty and there were cats everywhere. But if you want a beer, sure. Plus it's close to the house. Island Time Pub in the Red Hook area has the best pizza! Definitely stop by Udder Delight on the way to Magen's Bay for some delicious milkshakes. Beaches we visited that were all great were Magen's Bay, Sapphire Beach, Coki Beach. I don't know how you could go wrong with any of the beaches on either island, though. We visited St. John's for one day, and wish we spent more time there. Super beautiful, calm, and very clean island. We shopped at Mongoose Junction, which is in my opinion the best shopping area in general. Hawksnest Beach, Cinnamon and Maho were all very nice beaches on St. John. I hear Coral Bay is the best spot for snorkeling, so we'll have to try that next time. All in all, this was top 3 best vacations we have ever had and would highly recommend the islands and staying at High Blue Heaven."
    Guest: Whitney Date of Stay: September 2014 Review Submitted: September 23, 2014
    View listing
  • Quiet luxury with AMAZING views

    "Our family of four stayed here over spring break and had a fantastic time. The house is beautiful. Very clean and spacious with stunning views. The pool is larger than it appears in the photos and allowed for many games of "marco polo" among the four of us. After a day sightseeing on St. Thomas or St. John, it was SO relaxing to come back to our own private house & pool. We will (hopefully) be back!"
    Guest: Linda P. Date of Stay: March 2014 Review Submitted: April 1, 2014
    View listing
  • Perfect place for a relaxing vacation

    "We stayed in the studio for a 4-day trip. The studio had everything we wanted and needed. The location was unbelievable. It had this amazing view of Magen's bay. We woke up to a beautiful view, spent the day enjoying it, and watched the sunset. The small beach was quiet and allowed for a quick swim. Each day, we would swim to the larger beach, which was ~10 minutes walking and swimming through the water. The location of the studio was quiet and allowed for privacy. It was located close enough to restaurants and an easy car ride to town. I would recommend renting a car if you want to explore. We can't wait to go back!!!"
    Guest: Jim Date of Stay: December 2013 Review Submitted: January 12, 2014
    View listing
  • Beautiful, Quiet and Amazing!

    "Amazing condo right next to Magens Bay. It was the perfect vacation for me and my two brothers. The water in the bay is crystal clear and from our balcony we could see the sea turtles swimming in the bay. You can run or walk to Magens Beach and get paddle boards and kayaks. It is also a short distance to Udder Delight which has the best milkshakes you will ever have. My brother had one on our third day there and got one everyday until we left seven days later. We rented a car because the villa has its own parking. Navigating around the island is really easy and there are a lot of activities you can do at other beaches without having to stay in a busy hotel. That was one of the best things about the villa, you were away from everything else and could enjoy a quiet beautiful day on your own beach if you wanted to. Michelle, the housekeeper picked us up at the airport and took us to a grocery store to stock up on food. There is a grill on the balcony where we cooked our food almost every night and ate outside. Michelle also came and cleaned the house during the week. There was a washer/dryer below the condo which was really convenient. The inside of the condo is beautiful and the pictures on the site don’t really do it justice. There were plenty of beach towels and sunscreen in the condo as well. The kitchen has all the necessary cooking items/dinnerware. The condo was away from I would definitely stay here again."
    Guest: Isabella Date of Stay: May 2014 Review Submitted: July 16, 2014
    View listing

Magens Bay Travel Tips

Magens Bay Vacation Rentals Have Everything You Need

For a tropical vacation you'll never forget, Magens Bay in St. Thomas should be at the top of your list. Our Magens Bay vacation rentals offer everything you need to make your vacation a memorable one. Amenities include spacious living rooms, tile kitchens and bathrooms, private swimming pools, flat-screens TVs, DVD players, surround sound systems, and more. Why stay in an expensive hotel, when you can get much more for your money? Magens Bay vacation rentals offer an affordable and luxurious alternative.

Magens Bay Vacation Rentals Offer a Sightseer's Paradise

Magens Bay was named one of the most beautiful beaches in the world by National Geographic magazine. Once you visit Magens Bay, you'll see why. It stretches out over one square mile of white sand and beautiful turquoise-blue water. Enjoy a panoramic view of this heart-shaped beach from your Magens Bay vacation rental.

North Side St. Thomas Resorts Offer Fun Activities

Located just one mile from Magens Bay, the Devil's Triangle offers a challenging golf course for avid golfers. Or, maybe you and your family want to enjoy the nice calm water. It's great for floating and swimming. You can also rent paddle boats, kayaks, and sunfish from a water sports booth. You can then return to your your Magens Bay vacation villa and watch the sun set while sipping a cool drink. Take the ferry to St. John, a place where two thirds of the island is a national park. Rent a boat and catch Marlin, Sailfish, and Tuna, or many other game fish swimming through the tropical waters. Come to Magens Bay where you can enjoy blue tropical water, snorkeling, swimming, fishing, golfing, and a whole lot more.

Sponsored Advertisement