VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More
This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation
Recent Edgartown reviews
Lovely Stay, Perfect Location
"We stayed at this charming spacious house for a wedding on the island. The house is just as described, and the cottages made for an ideal set up for our large group of adults, toddlers and an infant. The owners were quick to respond, gracious and incredibly helpful and the house manager got back to us immediately when we reached out with a question. The house was clean and the check-in/check-out was seamless. The house location is perfect -- within walking distance of downtown. I'd recommend the house and would definitely stay here again!"
Guest: Regan P.Date of Stay: October 2014Review Submitted: March 31, 2015
"We booked this beautiful property with high expectations and they were exceeded! The grounds, the home, and the pool and hot tub were all perfect. The owners could not have been any more gracious and accommodating and were very helpful.
The home was immaculate and had everything anyone could want. It was perfect for both our base of operations on the island as well as fun evenings cooking and enjoying the relaxing atmosphere that is embodied in this wonderful setting. We enjoyed mornings on the porch, afternoons at the pool, and even late night fun in the hot tub. We ate breakfast on the beautiful back patio and two fabulous dinners on the huge farmhouse dining table. There is a great kitchen for the most discerning chef, very comfortable beds and furniture, and fantastic bathrooms.
We could not have been happier and look forward to staying here again very soon.
Guest: AnonymousDate of Stay: June 2015Review Submitted: June 26, 2015
"This is my third year renting at "magic". Absoultely love the location of the house. You are able to take morning/evening walks around the neighborhood, or for a longer stroll pick up the bike path down to south beach. The wrap around porch is perfect for dinners and night time star gazing, with cocktails. Private backyard for some games. Highly recommend trying the outdoor shower too!!"
Guest: JessDate of Stay: July 2015Review Submitted: July 23, 2015
"To owners Paul and Karen, well done! You have created an oasis in the middle of an oasis. Your guest house was just perfect for the two of us, and could have accommodated more, with plenty of additional bed-space and living space. Loved the hot tub. Loved the surroundings. We ate in almost every night -- probably upset a number of local restaurateurs, but then......
Thanks also for letting us in a bit early, and allowing us to stay a bit late on checkout day. As you know, we discovered a flat tire on our rental car when we went out to load our luggage into the car. That little surprise necessitated a hurry-up tire change to the mini-spare tire, then a rush to Oak Bluffs to an auto repair shop to get the tire fixed, and then a rush back to your guest house to load up just in time to rush back to Vineyard Haven in time to make our ferry reservation! Quite a morning, last Friday. Our trip home was uneventful, except that my suitcase apparently decided not to leave your guest house (just kidding!). It did not arrive with us as we flew home to Boise. But, I have it now, so all is well that ends well.
Thanks so much for your hospitality!
Jan and Jack"
Guest: JackDate of Stay: June 2015Review Submitted: June 15, 2015