VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

Show moreless regions

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Northeast property reviews

  • A Perfect Vacation Spot

    "Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time at the cottage. It is perfect-sized for a family of 4 and the layout if perfect for little kids to run around without worrying about them getting lost or hurt. We spent hours on the beach and water, and enjoyed the sunsets on the swing each night. The cottage was compact but included everything you would need. Wireless internet and coffee was a plus. It was clean and cutely decorated. Definitely well-cared for. Val and Ed were great hosts, we really felt welcome."
    Guest: The M. Family Date of Stay: August 2013 Review Submitted: September 5, 2013
    View listing
  • Privacy plus

    "We stayed at the "Tuthill House" for a month, so our "likes and dislikes" may not be typical. From the time of our first inquiry about the property, until the time of our departure (and even after), the owner was always available and quickly addressed our needs. Calling this place a cottage is not is much, much more! Ample room for 2 couples! The house was clean and neat upon our arrival, and there was ample bedding. The amount of glassware, silverware/utensils, dinnerware and pots & pans was amazing, and the gas grill better than we have at home. Privacy abounds; the setting is in the nicest residential neighborhood on the lake, and yet, shopping and restaurants are relatively nearby. The hard-sand lake bottom extends about 400 yards out into the lake (about 4' deep), and is great for playing in the water. For us, being away from home for 6+ weeks, the included WiFi was a godsend. The resident mallard ducks are always looking for a hand-out and will even eat out your hand if you're patient enough. What didn't we like? The beds were unsatisfactory.....too soft and sagged toward the middle. The dark log interior begs for brighter lighting. The sprinkler system wets downs the front porch (and everything on it) every morning. And, although the dock is nice, it's shared with the next-door property, and with the house being on the East side of the lake, it is usually too rough for small boats, but GREAT for water toys. Not much for "dislikes".....we had a great time and would probably rent again & could certainly recommend it."
    Guest: Robert M. Date of Stay: July 2013 Review Submitted: September 9, 2013
    View listing
  • Great Cottage! Great Week at Otsego Lake!

    "We stayed at this cottage July 10-17, 2010 (two adults and four kids). The cottage is exactly as described and the pictures are current. The owners were just fantastic!! They met us at check in (and out) on time and checked on us during the week to make sure we had what we needed. The cottage was well maintained and very clean and everything was in working order. No issues whatsoever. The beach was clean with toys for the kids to use, and had plenty of seating and a new fire pit for our nightly campfires. We just had a fantastic time! This was a great experience renting a property. We already have the calendar out and are figuring out how to make it back there next year. Awesome!!"
    Guest: Terry Date of Stay: July 2010 Review Submitted: August 17, 2010
    View listing
  • Kathy/Bob

    "We are renting the waterfront unit. It is absolutely wonderful. I can hear the lake from the bedroom. The cottage is roomy, clean, well-supplied. We are near Petosky, a beautiful "Cross In the Woods," and the lake is beautiful. There is a t.v. and internet service, helpful on rainy days like today, and serene wooded walking trails right by the cottage. I absolutely recommend this place! Thank you for a wonderful experience!"
    Guest: Happy Visitor Date of Stay: July 2014 Review Submitted: July 8, 2014
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement