VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

Show moreless regions

We're sorry, the exact location of this region is not in our database, so we are instead showing you the location of the nearest city .

Map view

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Fire Island property reviews

  • Great spot and great price

    "I had an amazing college reunion with my 5 girlfriends. Sweet and cozy and so welcoming we felt comfortable as soon as we walked in. Very complete kitchen for cooking, the best outdoor shower ever, walking distance to everything, perfect location for a great 3 mile run, wonderful shops and restaurants, overlooking a beautiful field where deer gather every evening and morning. We will be going back for sure."
    Guest: Katharine N. Date of Stay: September 2013 Review Submitted: January 9, 2014
    View listing
  • We Didn't Want to Leave!

    "We were so delighted to spend a week here in this lovely home-even with some of the worst (rainiest) weather of the summer ... we were comforted by the beautiful kitchen, sound system, wifi, comfy living room and exotic master bedroom while it rained outside for 2 days. We didn't mind staying in, playing scrabble, cooking, and enjoying the view and feeling of being in a tree house. The yard/garden is lush and tranquil and really makes you feel like you have been transported ...I was reminded of a trip to Costa Rica where we stayed in a rainforest-while just a short trip from the city! I only wish it was cool enough to light a fire in the beautiful fireplace! When the sun came out we enjoyed the clean and beautiful beach just a 1 minute walk away. We also loved having the bikes which were in great shape and took us to playgrounds, restaurants and on leisure rides to enjoy the houses and deer in the area. The island has such a great relaxed pace you feel like you stepped back in time, and getting around to other areas is easy and fun by bike or water taxi. We also loved our walk in the Sunken Forest, just about a mile and a half away, if you need a break from all the relaxing for some exercise. We were so grateful to our host for having a kitchen with all the supplies and comfy bedding with down pillows and clean and new showers as well as decks that you could spend all day on-plenty of seating in sun or shade. We also truly appreciated the artistic design touches throughout the house, including some incredibly detailed moroccan style painting on various walls! This was truly a great escape and one we hope to revisit again soon!"
    Guest: Malissa Date of Stay: August 2010 Review Submitted: August 31, 2010
    View listing
  • Family of 4 couldn't be happier!

    "Let me first start off by saying that owner is not only a really nice guy but he has paid so much attention to detail in this real nice and clean rental. It's 8 house away from a beautiful beach and only 5 houses away from the Great South Bay. The kitchen had everything you will need to feel right at home. The outdoor deck with BBQ is amazing (BTW He put a new larger table with a nice large umbrella). The sleeping for my wife and I along with my 13 yr old Son and 11 yr old Daughter was just perfect with the two queen futons (BTW He has put a flat panel tv on the wall now) We had direct tv, a real nice radio and dvd player. The bathroom was clean and had all the things one would need to make it a real nice stay. The owner has truly thought of everything from the wagon for your use at the ferry dock to the bikes you will come to enjoy in this beautiful little island paradise! We for one will be back next year as I'm not sure we could find a better price nor a Hotel that would come close to what this little gem had to offer! Book away and enjoy!"
    Guest: Family of 4 enjoying the Island! Date of Stay: July 2012 Review Submitted: July 14, 2012
    View listing
  • Can't wait to go back!!

    "I had never been to Fire Island, and this past Memorial Day my group of 8 close friends decided to make the trip. We lucked out and found this house on Bayberry – the house was perfect, everything was spotless when we arrived. The bedrooms were a little small, but since the beds were bunked we had no problems (and who wants to stay inside during the summer anyway). We BBQed on the back porch, spent most of the time on the beach (which is literally a 5 minute walk) and enjoyed the Ocean Beach shops and restaurants (a 2 minute walk). The renovations, stainless steel appliances and living room are beautiful – felt like home! Everyone’s favorite thing was the outdoor shower – hot water and good pressure (better than my New York City apartment shower)… It was also great to have a washer and dryer on premise. The owner was super nice and friendly – available to answer any questions we had. Everyone in my party had such a wonderful time; we are already looking to book our next trip back to the island. 'Son of Old Paint' will always be our first choice of accommodation!"
    Guest: Kathryn Date of Stay: May 2014 Review Submitted: May 28, 2014
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement