Montauk 412 rentals

    Book with confidence Guaranteed, secure, with no booking fees

    •  
      $245 - $988 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 6 • Hither Woods
      7
    •  
      $11,000 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 12 • Montauk
      18
    •  
      $575 - $1,267 / night
      5 BR, Sleeps 14 • Hither Woods
      9
    •  
      $1,000 - $2,000 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Hither Hills
      4
    •  
      $800 - $929 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Hither Hills
      2
    •  
      $15,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 12 • Lake Montauk
      8
    •  
      $3,000 - $5,500 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
      4
    •  
      $6,250 - $15,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 9 • Lake Montauk
      3
    •  
      $1,450 - $1,750 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
    •  
      $4,500 - $9,000 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 9 • Montauk
      2
    •  
      $5,750 - $8,750 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
      2
    •  
      $350 - $857 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      10
    • *LABOR DAY - COLUMBUS DAY -- $12,000 -- BEST TIME OF YEAR * May 26, 2015 to Oct 19, 2015
       
      $600 - $714 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Shepherds Neck
      11
    •  
      $500 - $850 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 8 • Ditch Plains
      1
    •  
      $500 - $1,250 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      8
    •  
      $400 - $1,000 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      17
    •  
      $9,000 / month
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Montauk
    • May and June Reduction! Enjoy Memorial Day @ 15% Off rate!! May 12, 2015 to Jun 25, 2015
       
      $8,500 - $16,000 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 12 • Montauk
      2
    •  
      $450 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      4
    •  
      $245 - $545 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Atlantic Bluffs Club
    •  
      $857 - $2,000 / night
      5 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
      1
    •  
      $1,100 - $1,250 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Surf Club
    •  
      $4,667 - $5,000 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $2,100 - $4,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      5
    •  
      $7,500 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 13 • Hither Hills
    •  
      $5,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 13 • Montauk
    •  
      $8,498 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
    •  
      $250 - $400 / night
      1 BR, Sleeps 4 • Rough Riders Landing
    •  
      $4,000 - $6,300 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 12 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $500 - $786 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 7 • Panoramic View
      2
    •  
      $450 - $643 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
    •  
      $1,500 - $3,625 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Culloden Shores
    •  
      $2,500 - $5,750 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 6 • Lake Montauk
      1
    •  
      $5,000 - $5,133 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
    •  
      $12,250 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Fort Pond
    •  
      $650 - $1,000 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
      14
    •  
      $7,000 - $9,750 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 9 • Montauk
      9
    •  
      $400 - $800 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
      9
    •  
      $625 - $950 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Montauk
      4
    •  
      $500 - $1,500 / night
      5 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
      24
    •  
      $7,515 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Lake Montauk
      4
    •  
      $2,550 - $6,200 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
      20
    •  
      $307 - $586 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      4
    •  
      $8,500 - $10,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      5
    •  
      $650 - $975 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 8 • Surf Club
      5
    •  
      $325 - $629 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      7
    •  
      $5,000 - $8,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Hither Hills
      6
    •  
      $275 - $600 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 9 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $300 - $786 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      5
    •  
      View listing for price
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      7
    •  
      $3,000 - $6,250 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 14 • Culloden Shores
      20
    •  
      $6,000 - $7,500 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 10 • Rough Riders Landing
      3
    •  
      $429 - $571 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Ditch Plains
      1
    •  
      $4,900 - $6,500 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 5 • Surf Club
      2
    •  
      $257 - $571 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      View listing for price
      4 BR, Sleeps 12 • Montauk
      12
    •  
      $1,800 - $2,500 / week
      0 BR, Sleeps 2 • Lake Montauk
    •  
      $3,000 / week
      1 BR, Sleeps 6 • Montauk
      2
    •  
      $2,500 - $5,000 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Lake Montauk
    •  
      $9,000 - $15,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Panoramic View
    •  
      $857 / night
      5 BR, Sleeps 8 • Panoramic View
    •  
      $550 - $600 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Surf Club
      1
    •  
      $5,833 - $7,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
    •  
      $4,200 - $8,000 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $20,000 - $40,000 / month
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
    •  
      $6,500 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      3
    •  
      $450 - $536 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Montauk
      9
    •  
      $400 - $543 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 6 • Culloden Shores
      5
    •  
      $180 - $500 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Hither Woods
      5
    •  
      $571 - $1,500 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      10
    •  
      $7,000 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Ditch Plains
      1
    •  
      $286 - $450 / night
      0 BR, Sleeps 3 • Hither Hills
      2
    •  
      $7,500 - $8,500 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 9 • Culloden Shores
      3
    •  
      $8,000 - $9,000 / week
      5 BR, Sleeps 12 • Rough Riders Landing
      16
    •  
      $6,000 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 7 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $15,000 / month
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Montauk
      25
    •  
      approx $4,000/wk, depending on season US
      5 BR, Sleeps 12 • Hither Hills
      8
    •  
      $4,000 - $6,000 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 9 • Montauk
    •  
      $6,650 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Culloden Shores
    •  
      $1,750 - $3,750 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 5 • Lake Montauk
      5
    •  
      $600 - $700 / night
      6 BR, Sleeps 12 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $3,000 - $4,800 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 5 • Fort Pond
    •  
      View listing for price
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Montauk
      1
    •  
      $571 - $750 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Hither Hills
    •  
      $643 - $1,000 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Hither Hills
      1
    •  
      $1,000 - $2,300 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 12 • Hither Woods
    •  
      $150 - $750 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Hither Hills
      13
    •  
      $400 - $571 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Montauk
      15
    • DITCH PLAINS MTK MODERN BEACH HOUSE SUMMER WKND JUNE 2015! Jun 1, 2015 to Jul 3, 2015
       
      $1,143 - $2,000 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 11 • Montauk
      6
    •  
      $425 - $575 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 10 • Hither Hills
      4
    •  
      $4,200 - $5,200 / week
      4 BR, Sleeps 8 • Culloden Shores
      1
    •  
      $400 - $543 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 5 • Hither Hills
      3
    •  
      $1,000 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Hither Hills
    •  
      $6,000 - $18,000 / month
      3 BR, Sleeps 8 • Montauk
      1
    •  
      $300 - $800 / night
      4 BR, Sleeps 6 • Hither Woods
      11
    •  
      $275 / night
      1 BR, Sleeps 4 • Hither Hills
      5
    •  
      $1,500 / night
      3 BR, Sleeps 10 • Hither Woods
      2
    •  
      $6,500 - $7,500 / week
      3 BR, Sleeps 6 • Ditch Plains
    •  
      $3,500 - $5,000 / week
      2 BR, Sleeps 6 • Hither Hills
      7
    •  
      $375 - $600 / night
      2 BR, Sleeps 4 • Hither Hills
      3

Recent Montauk reviews

  • Another Fabulous Montauk Vacation

    Aim

    "This was our third year at our home away from home and another year of fabulous memories were made. The owner is a gem to deal with and was quick to respond to any questions or requests we had. The house is comfortable and has everything you could need. The adults had a great time. The kids had a great time and so did the dog! We look forward to returning yet again!"
    • Stayed July 2014
    • Submitted July 29, 2014
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Fantastic Wedding Week

    Emily

    "Recently, I was married at Gurney's and we rented this house for ourselves and our bridal party. It could not have been more perfect! The house itself is huge and the pictures online don't do it justice. It's a block walk to the beach and there are beach chairs and boogie boards at the house. The kitchen is large and equipped with all the necessary amenities. There is a grill on the upper deck and a large teak table and chairs outside, in addition to the dinning room table. We had a dinner at the house for our families to meet and there was ample seating. There is wifi, cable, and a Ping pong table in the basement. Oh and the hot tub on the downstairs deck is definitely a big perk! The owner is awesome! Our parents rented houses as well and their landlords were less than welcoming. This owner is very helpful and relaxed. She even recommended a woman who came to the house and did mani/pedi's for all the ladies! I just hope I have a reason to rent this house again! Thanks for everything!!!"
    • Stayed September 2014
    • Submitted October 2, 2014
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Montauk is Bliss!

    Laura C.

    "We had a wonderful family vacation in Montauk and our stay at this house was perfect! Close to the beach, all amenities we needed/wanted - including a pool! The owner was a pleasure to deal with and we definitely want to return next year."
    • Stayed August 2014
    • Submitted August 12, 2014
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Perfect

    dan

    "Owner very nice, location perfect , clean pleasant surroundings. Definitely coming back ! Bed and linens comfortable and a shower that actually works really well ! Well stocked kitchen and detailed info for all electronics . Linda has thought of everything ."
    • Stayed October 2014
    • Submitted November 3, 2014
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing