Feedback

VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Shelter Island reviews

  • Perfect Vacation

    "The house was perfect . Renting was simple and easy with lots of recommendations of places to visit . Very clean. Beds were comfortable with lots of towels and blankets . Our favorite place was the deck . We had breakfast and dinner on the deck each day . Nice view of the water but grassy property was just as nice . Walked to The Mashamack Preserve from the beach. It was an amazing walk and the kids loved exploring the beach . We tried the out door shower. water was hot but still too chilly out side for it each night. We found plenty of pots and pans for cooking breakfast and dinner each night. we even baked cup cakes with all the equipment there to use .The grill was perfect for the burgers and hot dogs . very quite beach . If you want company and to meet new people this is not the beach to do it on . very good price for the house . We will rent again when going visit Greenport and wineries. too."
    Guest: 2girls320 Date of Stay: May 2014 Review Submitted: June 6, 2014
    View listing
  • Home base for grandaughter's wedding

    "We had a lovely time in this very convenient home. Lois met us on arrival on Monday afternoon and returned the following Monday to wish us well on our return to California. Because the house is on several levels, it was a great choice for those who wished to rise early (we saw the swans out on the creek) and for those who wished to "sleep-in". The pool was wonderful and enjoyed by all. The creek was fun for tubing and paddle-boating. Part of our family stayed in this house and part of the extended family had another vrbo house a couple of miles away. One evening we had dinner for 24 out on deck and up by the pool, and there were dishes and silverware for all. Weather was lovely all week. The rehearsal dinner was at the Yacht club, the wedding was in garden at Sylvester Manor with dinner in a large "circus" tent in the meadow near Gardiner Creek, and the brunch on Sunday after the wedding was served from "Rolling in Dough" food truck (lots of fun with great pizza). My granddaughter was a beautiful bride and we all had a wonderful time. I would recommend this house for a big family gathering or for a small retreat time. We did not have time to read any of Leon Uris' books, but I had read several of them previously. The owners have very eclectic taste and some great posters. So glad I found this property."
    Guest: Grandma Sue Date of Stay: July 2014 Review Submitted: August 13, 2014
    View listing
  • Family Boat Trip 2014

    "Our annual family boys boat trip is a major highlight for our family. This was our 25th annual trip and this was our best ever trip. We have been to Martha's Vineyard to Elizabeth City, NC and everywhere in between and this has been the best. The house, the rear deck, the dock, the bikes, the kayaks, the location and the owners were perfect. Each night we would all sit outside on the deck sharing a meal, stories and laughter. For anyone who wants to escape to heaven, you will not find a better location. Thank you"
    Guest: Boat Trip 2014 Date of Stay: May 2014 Review Submitted: June 6, 2014
    View listing
  • Also a lovely house for the off-season

    "My husband, young son and I spent a wonderful long weekend in this comfortable cottage after Thanksgiving. Cozy, clean and inviting, this cottage was the perfect home base from which to enjoy a more quiet time on the island. The owner was a pleasure to work with - a very easy process."
    Guest: SM Date of Stay: November 2014 Review Submitted: December 4, 2014
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement