VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

Show moreless regions

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Cutchogue property reviews

  • Perfect Family Vacation

    "This comfortable homestead was the perfect location for an extended family vacation. Grown children and grandchildren were thrilled with the accomodations. The property lends itself to being outside all day between Peconic Bay, the beautiful outdoor pool, and the more than adequate yard. The wooden table on the deck held all of us, and there is even a bell to ring to call everyone to meals. The outdoor shower turned out to be an unforeseen plus. Trips to local wineries, Greenport and other local villages were easy and fun. I am grateful to the owners for sharing this fabulous environment, and we hope to make this a yearly event."
    Guest: proud Mom Date of Stay: July 2012 Review Submitted: July 25, 2012
    View listing
  • Great Time Had By All

    "The house is beautiful. Great location and very clean. With a beach down the street, shopping and restaurants close by, and Shelter Island and the Hamptons a stones throw away... how could you go wrong? I would highly recommend this house to anyone looking for a relaxing vacation with family and friends!"
    Guest: LTP Date of Stay: July 2014 Review Submitted: July 31, 2014
    View listing
  • Rejuvenating experience in a charming getaway

    "Being greeted by a handwritten welcome, bottle of wine & thoughtfully arranged s'more supplies, we instantly felt as if we had arrived at our second home. As we excitedly explored each room we realized the immense thought and preparation the owners had put into ensuring our enjoyment and relaxation for our entire stay (which we took full advantage of!). The house was well stocked and supplied, with everything being ordered in a logical arrangement. There was a surplus of recreational activities (bikes, single & tandem kayaks, horseshoes, croquette, fishing rods, charcoal & gas grills) amenities (beach towels, ample linens, skincare, full music library & books to be found in every room) as well as multiple guidebooks providing great itineraries, which helped us familiarize ourselves with the North Fork. Being first time visitors we were given the tools to explore thoroughly all that Cutchogue, and surrounding towns, had to offer. For example, we rode the bicycles on a day trip through Southhold, Greenport & Shelter Island and kayaked out to the bay. We also enjoyed the local restaurants, antique shops (including the famous Beall & Bell!) and marveled at the multiple vineyards lining the roads. Upon returning to the house after our day trips, our favorite outdoor setting to unwind, relax & restore were the crocheted hammocks where we could take in the beautiful natural Cutchogue light and green surroundings. As dusk fell, we would find ourselves building a fire in the fireplace and eating our Weber grilled meals around it each night, cozying up with drinks & s'mores and capping off with lengthy late night chats. We had become so connected with ourselves and each other in this house and felt so close to nature; by the end of our stay, we had a hard time letting go and felt so fully relaxed and rested that the prospect of returning to our metropolitan lives seemed distressing. It was truly a restorative vacation. Highly recommended."
    Guest: Justin F. Date of Stay: May 2013 Review Submitted: June 10, 2013
    View listing
  • Reunion Planner

    "A group of high school friends, originally planning our 50th reunion, has now gathered at the Dartford House twice to reconnect, relax and enjoy the gorgeous views, beaches, grounds and comforts of this wonderful home. We have found the kitchen well equipped, the rooms lovely and the owner helpful in every way. The large dining room table accomodated 13 of us for our traditional seafood fest! Classmates came from all over the US, explored the North Fork, visiting local wineries and shops or staying right at the house to relax. We have been fortunate to have great weather during both our visits but, even if it rains, the fireplace and roomy common areas would provide a delightful way to spend the days. The house is very well maintained and recent upgrades have been made. We hope to come again to what has become a treasured place for all of us."
    Guest: Ann from NY Date of Stay: September 2013 Review Submitted: October 14, 2013
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement