Feedback

VRBO is part of the HomeAway family, the world leader in vacation rentals with over 1 million listings. We offer the largest selection of properties for any travel occasion and every budget. We’re committed to helping families and friends find a perfect vacation rental to create unforgettable travel experiences together. Learn More

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Long Island reviews

  • amazing family vacation!

    "Our family of eleven with young children spent a long weekend here celebrating our mother's 70th birthday. The house exceeded our expectations in every way. It is incredibly spacious, safe and very kid friendly with a fully fenced in pool, a swing set that the kids spent half the day on. Inside there was also a great play area for kids with toys! The house was very clean, with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The grounds are just perfect. We spent hours sitting around the firepit in the evening. (with enough comfy chairs for all eleven of us). Helen is also the kindest most attentive person we have ever rented from. A welcome note, fresh cookies and her cell number to text her with any concerns, we felt very taken care of. We left something behind and she mailed it to us immediately. The pool was cleaned professionally upon our arrival too. One of our days was a little rainy but no matter, we sat in the giant and well furnished screened in porch and enjoyed her beautiful views of the nature preserve. It's amazing to be in a place where you cannot see or hear any houses nearby and feel completely secluded while only be three miles from wonderful Sag Harbor. We will definitely be staying here again! Thank you to Helen for providing the backdrop for such a special weekend!"
    Guest: Alli Date of Stay: May 2015 Review Submitted: May 19, 2015
    View listing
  • Lovely Shelter Island Vacation House

    "We had a wonderful stay over Labor Day weekend. The house is charming and had everything we needed. The location is terrific (steps away from Commander Cody's :)) and the grounds are gorgeous. We hope to be back next year!"
    Guest: Danny G. Date of Stay: August 2014 Review Submitted: September 9, 2014
    View listing
  • Perfect Family Vacation

    "We were 3 generations, 70-year-olds down to a 1-year-old, gathering for a getaway that could not have been any better. The secluded, quiet location was nice for our privacy and yet we felt we were so close to anything we wanted to do. The lighthouse, lobster rolls at a downtown shack, the Brewery or shopping in Montauk (loved their Thursday Farmers Market), the beach with surfing or playing in the sand, golf, biking -- something for everybody! But we mostly enjoyed the comfort of the home. The beds and furniture, the house in general, were all very clean and comfortable; the pool was delightful for the grandchildren; and the fire pit was an evening treat after the grandchildren were in bed. I must say that I was also very impressed and happy that the owner checked in with me before we arrived as well as during our stay and after we left. Couldn't have been any happier with our stay."
    Guest: janice w. Date of Stay: September 2014 Review Submitted: September 19, 2014
    View listing
  • Great Montauk House for families

    "We recently returned from a great week in Montauk. When we arrived, Bob was very friendly, and prior to arrival Felice was very helpful and prompt in replying to our questions. Bob showed us around, gave a nice tour of the house and grounds. The house was perfect for us, very clean, fresh, well kept and well stocked with necessities. It didnt feel like a rental home, and there are many personal touches throughout. There was plenty of space (and then some) for my family of 5, and each bedroom having its own bathroom was a great add. The outside of the house is fantastic. The pool and deck area were perfect for lounging and relaxing away from the beach. The property is very quiet and private, we could barely see another house while sitting on the deck. Its like a forest hideaway in the middle of a busy beach town. My kids also loved feeding the fish in the beautiful pond, and all (9, 11 & 13 yrs old) asked if we could rent there again next year. Bob and Felice were great hosts; we had a minor issue with the grill, and Bob had someone there to fix it right away. We also appreciated having our security deposit returned in full promptly, within 4 days of returning home. All in all, highly recommended rental and we would definitely stay there again."
    Guest: Robert S. Date of Stay: August 2014 Review Submitted: September 6, 2014
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement