"We can not recommend this place enough. The cabin is excellent. The one thing I was worried about was the bathroom since there are no pictures. It is huge, and there is a separate room for a shower.
Anyway, the cabin has a kitchen that is fully stocked with any utensil you'll need. I'd recommend bringing food because it is quite a bit more expensive once you're on the peninsula (at least compared to Chicago). There is an indoor fireplace upstairs that we enjoyed a few times. There is another fireplace outside, which is also beautiful.
Other reviewers have pointed out the proximity of the Cana Cove lighthouse. IT IS SO CLOSE. At night, in the loft, it appears so close that you would think you can touch it. Sidenote, if you're there in season take the tour. It's worth it.
There is a huge yard that was good fod us (just a married couple). It would be great for kids or dogs, too. The shore is maybe 100 yards away. It is quite a rocky shore, so you won't be swimming. But it is on the lake side, and it is absolutely beautiful.
The peninsula is fairly compact so you're only about 20 or so minutes from the bigger towns (Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, Sister Bay). Baileys Harbor itself has some nice things, too, especially its shoreline park.
Overall, I completely recommend this cabin. It's a little different in that you have some more responsibility to bring your own sheets and turn on the water heater. However, you can not beat the price.
Keep in mind that we had almost zero cell serive on the peninsula at all, let alone at the cabin (ATT and T Mobile). There is no internet or landline at the cabin, either. It was weird for the first day, but then the disconnect was kind of nice. I was a little nervous about there not being a land line at the cabin in case of an emergency, but obviously I lived to tell the tale!
If you're looking for a beautiful, amazing place to stay in Door County, look no further. The cabin is excellent, the locaiton is excellent, and the owner is excellent. Jim was available constantly when a few issues arose before and after our trip. We are already looking forward to our nect trip."
Guest: Pat O
Date of Stay: October 2014
Review Submitted: October 30, 2014