We had a great time in James and Mandy's home.
The owners were great communicators. The check in process was clear.
The two big draws for us were the location next to holyrood park and two beds in the second bedroom (we have two girls who don't like sharing a bed).
It was just a 10 minute walk to a large super market where we were able to get all our groceries for our stay. The neighborhood was very quiet.
Walking to the Edinburgh city center is doable, but we ended up taking under most of the time as it was only 5-7 pounds.
Just a few small things would have made the home even better. This would include some paper towels in the kitchen, Kleenex, shampoo.
Overall a wonderful place to enjoy your stay in Edinburgh.