Additional fees apply.Taxes may be added.

Selection of vacation rentals with pool, in Shelter Island

Recent Shelter Island Reviews

  • Great, comfortable, well appointed home
    5 of 5

    We visited Dominic's property in Dec/January. It was perfect for a relaxing weekend of card games, reading and lounging. We had a lovely dinner for eight people one of the evenings and we fit very comfortably. Would love to go back and enjoy the pool and deck during the warm months. Great area, private, very close to grocery store, seafood market and liquor store. Not far from South Hampton either.

    Stayed: Dec 2018
  • Perfect rental house!
    5 of 5

    We rented this house for work and really enjoyed our time there! It was clean, cozy and thoughtfully appointed. We look forward to staying there again soon!

    Stayed: Dec 2018
x