Find lake rentals near Robert V. Riddell State Park

We loved our stay in Oneonta and Big Wave 1. The house was beautiful with an updated feel. It was just what we needed for two people. We loved that the kitchen was fully stocked and towels and linens included. That was a big help. Hosts were very kind and responsive. I'd love to return and would recommend this place to everyone.

We just got home from a week at the Back Stop and it was a terrific place. Just a six minute drive to All Star Village and located in between the baseball festivities and downtown Oneonta which is also just a five minute drive. The apartment is on a really large plot of land with access to the owners pool until 8pm at night. Tammy and Eddy were terrific hosts and made sure we had everything we needed. They even had homemade cookies upon our arrival and Tammy came down with homemade blueberry muffins one day which were fantastic. The apartment has two bedrooms...one with a queen and the other with two twin beds. Also includes a full kitchen and decent size living area. You can see how much care they take for the apartment and experience of the guests. They even have a bunch of all-star village pins on display from all the teams that have stayed. We actually found our team pin there from 4 years back and recognized all the last names from town. A five star experience!

This was a perfect place to stay for my wife and I. Had everything we needed and much better then staying a a hotel.

Colleen was great! Check in was quick and easy. Place was very clean and perfect for our stay while our son played at CASV. This place is perfectly located and had everything we needed. Definitely recommend.

Charming little accommodation with everything you need.

Instead of staying on property at All-Star Village, I wanted something where I would have laundry, a kitchen and space to spread out with my family. This house was perfect!!!. It is super close to downtown and just a five minute drive to All-Star village. Plenty of space to move around with a larger group with all the old town quaint upstate New York feel.

Great stay for my son’s week at all star village. Angela is awesome. I was nervous to stay alone but was totally out at ease that she lives right next door & the neighborhood is super safe. Very clean & cute. Ideal location this about a 3 min drive away. Such a great value!

A stay at the Beautiful Bay house is exactly what the doctor ordered! The home would be truly stunning if all it had to offer were the expansive views of the sparkling, serene water of Goodyear Lake and calming, lush greenery across the way, but no, among other features, it also had: ~ Striking lantern style light fixtures ~ Ceiling fans with lights ~ Easy to use remotes for climate control ~ Electric fireplace for ambiance/heat ~ Beautifully arranged windows in main living space to allow in lots of natural light ~ Honey-varnished wide wood plank slanted high ceiling in main living area ~ Finished moldings and sills showing great attention to detail ~ Satellite TV ~ Sweet touches of wildlife – both land and water – (especially LOVED the black, waterfowl wall hanging above the landing to the lower level) ~ Unique wood furniture, accents, and doorsill that are both utilitarian as well as to be enjoyed visually - Great banisters both inside and out! ~ Sweet, white painted wood bookshelf by bed that sports a beadboard interior! ~ Fully appointed kitchen with fun vibes black 'n white “focal point” window valance ~ Environmentally friendly septic and European designed upstairs toilet ~ Inviting screened-in front porch overlooking the lake ~ Canoe and single person kayak ~ Specially designed door to back patio for extra security ~ Cozy, dog-friendly neighborhood ~ Comprehensive House manual A BIG thank you to Lisetta and Jeff who were most hospitable/communicative/available -