The nation’s oldest seaside resort delights visitors to the southern shores of New Jersey’s Cape May Peninsula. Perfect for history buffs, the entire city is a cherished National Historic Landmark, with almost 600 elegant Victorian buildings peppering its streets. It’s got beautiful beaches too, not to mention great shopping, gorgeous green spaces, and a lighthouse with views across Delaware Bay and the Atlantic Ocean. Whether you’re planning a weekend break with friends, a summer vacation with the kids, or anything in between, Cape May rentals give you the freedom to create your own adventure – and enjoy it at a pace that suits.

Create your own experience in Cape May rentals

Renting a vacation home in Cape May allows you to craft a vacation that’s individual to you. But, first, let’s look at what sort of rentals are available, the coolest spots to call home, and the best times to visit.

Where to stay in Cape May, NJ rentals

Cape May comprises three postcard-perfect spots: Cape May, West Cape May, and Cape May Point, rentals in any one of them your ticket to a coastal vacation to remember. Cape May rentals sit right on the shore, as well as in the heart of the historic district, while rentals in West Cape May are on the doorstep of the lush Cape May State Park. Head further west again to find vacation rentals in Cape May Point, this rugged spot home to the landmark Cape May Lighthouse.

Types of vacation rentals in Cape May

There’s plenty to choose from when it comes to Cape May rentals. There are cozy Cape May cottage rentals, of course, these traditional picks often sitting right on the beach. Then comes plenty of cute options for couples, along with smart beach block condos with communal pools and heritage homes full of character. Cape May house rentals mean you can bring the whole family, with pet-friendly pads available to those for whom family means pooch too.

Best time to visit Cape May

The summer months of July and August see visitor numbers peak in Cape May, though it’s not unusual to see the city packed out for Labor Day and Memorial Day Weekends either. It’s these times when demand for Cape May vacation rentals is at its highest, so booking early will often avoid disappointment. Cape May winter rentals are popular too, the holiday spirit around town coming courtesy of carolers, decorations, and horse-drawn carriage rides.

Top activities in Cape May

Whether you’re looking for family fun or lazy days, it’s all on the agenda when you choose a rental in Cape May. Dive in to discover some of the very best things to do.

Tours of Cape May

Once you’re settled into your vacation rental, Cape May pulls no punches. It’s time to explore and the best way to do exactly that is on a guided tour. Several local companies offer tours throughout the year, many including a look inside the Stick Style Physick Estate. In the holidays, visitors can go it alone on a self-guided Christmas Candlelight House Tour – a lovely decorated trolley tour that’s filled with holiday cheer.

Blissful beach days in Cape May

For those travelers looking for sand and salty air, this hotspot on the Jersey Shore doesn’t disappoint. Cape May’s beaches stretch along much of the city’s Atlantic coastline, accompanied along the Beach Avenue stretch by a paved promenade dotted with ice cream parlors and candy stores. For a perfect change of scenery before heading back to your rental to wash off the sand, check out the blissful shores of Cape May State Park.

Make a splash in Cape May

There are tons of ways to enjoy the water in Cape May, though at the top of the list must be the chance to join one of the whale-watching cruises that chug out of Cape May Harbor and into the Atlantic between May and December. Lighthouse and firework cruises are also popular, as well as private cruises and fishing expeditions, with kayaks and jet skis among the water toy rentals available to those who prefer to explore under their own steam.