Shelter Island cabin rentals

We found 2 cabin rentals — enter your dates for availability

Find spaces that suit your style

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support

  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, yards and more

  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

  • A place for everyone

    We stand for diversity, inclusion and families everywhere.
    Learn more

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to stay in a cabin rental in Shelter Island?
Big or small, basic or fancy — Vrbo has cabin rentals for every budget. To find an escape that suits yours, use our price filter. You can narrow your search results by the maximum total or nightly price. The cost will vary depending on what sort of property you choose, but the one thing that remains constant? The joy that comes with spending your break in one of our Shelter Island cabin rentals.
When is the best time to book a cabin rental in Shelter Island?
If you have a specific date in mind, it's best to book in advance. You'll get to secure your dream cabin rental at a good price. Also be aware of any local events and festivals that may be on during your stay in Shelter Island, as they could affect how much you pay and the availability.
Where can I rent a Shelter Island cabin rental with great views?
Experience Shelter Island from a different perspective by securing a cabin rental with great views. Use our intuitive filters to refine your search based on your desired location type — and the killer views that come with it. Book now and let the vistas be the backdrop to your unforgettable Shelter Island adventure.
Does Shelter Island have any lake cabins?
Whether you'd like to experience the beauty of Lake Montauk or Bashan Lake, we'll help you find your ideal lake cabin rental in Shelter Island. Spend your vacation time exploring picturesque landscapes or just enjoy the peaceful moments that come with being around water.
Can I book a luxury cabin in Shelter Island?
When you select a luxury cabin rental in Shelter Island, you can expect your trip to be taken to the next level. These escapes come with quality amenities to keep you feeling comfortable and pampered during your stay. Use our filters to look for cabins with high guest ratings and offer perks like outdoor fireplaces and swimming pools.
Can I book a cabin with a hot tub in Shelter Island?
Pick a cabin rental with a hot tub and take your Shelter Island getaway to the ultimate level of relaxation. Just check "Hot tub" under our features and amenities filter to discover stays with this premium perk. Immersing yourself in the bubbles after a busy day will make the highlight reel of your trip.
What are the top things to do in Shelter Island?
It's no surprise why many families love Shelter Island, with top attractions like East Hampton Main Beach, Orient Point County Park and 67 Steps Beach to explore. Check out this destination's best sights together and then return to the comforts of your cabin rental.
Why should I book my cabin rental with Vrbo?
From the second you book your cabin rental until your trip is over, we'll help ensure your stay is hassle-free. You're automatically eligible for the Book with Confidence Guarantee when you make and pay for a reservation through our site. Should the unexpected arise, we'll take care of you. On top of that, you can easily change or update your booking through your guest account. Worried if you have to cancel your cabin rental? Our flexible cancellation policies offer that extra peace of mind. And thanks to our One Key™ loyalty program, you can collect OneKeyCash™* on all eligible bookings on Vrbo, Expedia and Hotels.com. *OneKeyCash disclaimer - OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Vrbo, Expedia and Hotels.com.

More Vacation Ideas