This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Treasure Cay reviews

  • Casuarina has it all...and then some!

    "We just got back from one week at the Casuarina Beach House and I have to say it was everything I expected and then some! This is the 4th time I research/find/book a house in the Caribbean for our group of 11-17 friends and family (depending on the year) and this house was a huge hit! It was more beautiful than the pictures and had everything you may want and need. This year, we were a group of 13 (10 adults, 3 kids) ranging in ages 5 to 73 and there was something for everyone! The entire lot is glorious - beautifully manicured and well-maintained, on a beautiful beach that feels like a private get-away (we saw maybe 5 people walking the beach the entire week we were there), outdoor showers, kayaks, bikes, 2 grills, two hammocks, equipment for snorkeling, and enough spaces to be together as a group OR to have quiet time on your own... And Matthew, who serves as caretaker/house manager along with his wife Barbara, was stellar and helped whenever we needed it. Prior to arriving at the house Elaine provided information on golf cart booking, references for boat rentals and chef, as well as an overview of Abaco, Marsh Harbour and Treasure Cay - which was incredibly helpful. I went with all her recommendations and for the most part they worked out...with two exceptions. I booked Chef Rolle for 4 dinners and I tripled confirmed the price beforehand via email. When we got there, the price I was quoted was 'incorrect' and it went up by 4X! We paid $500 for 1 night for chicken, steamed vegetables and rice...he didn't even provide dessert! It was frustrating but we made the best of it. We decided to have him for the one night only and cancel the others. The other booking that went awry was with Captain Mark. I had been communicating with him via email since February and had (I thought) confirmed at least 3X, including the Thursday before we arrived (on Sat!!!). I emailed the captain on Sunday nite with a few questions and expected to hear back from him by the next day but didn't. I finally called him in the afternoon and he claimed to have gotten another job because I hadn't reached out. It was incredibly frustrating because I thought the prior 5 emails had served as confirmations. Anyway - Matthew came to the rescue and saved the day... He was able to book another boat for almost the same tour! It was amazing and I was incredibly grateful. Overall our time at Casuarina Beach House was amazing...we all would go back in a heart beat!"
    Guest: charlotte c. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 31, 2016
    View listing
  • We are coming back!!!

    "Thank you, Joy and Mike, for letting us share a small piece of your paradise! If needed they are just an e-mail , or a phone call away, if some problem should arrive, Renting from an owner who is near by is a big plus. This was a perfect spot for us. We appreciated the large kitchen counter space, and the two bedrooms.....not to mention the fact, that you have 1 1/2 bathrooms!! A huge bonus, and it saves a lot on the wear and tear on the legs, and the carpeted stairs!! The fact that you have a patio off the ground floor, and a great view from the balcony upstairs, makes sure that you do not miss any of the unbelievable sights of the day .If you have read the other reviews, you know that everything is within a few steps away from you. All true, indeed! If you have room in your luggage, I suggest that you put in some paper Glad Wrap, or aluminum foil, baggies, parchment paper, etc., as these things cost a lot at the local grocery store, and it seems you always need these supplies. We are coming back next year, and we have chosen, once again to stay at "The Treasure Trove", at Mariners Cove, Treasure Cay! You will not be disappointed if you decide to do the same!!! Happy holidays!!!"
    Guest: Nan Date of Stay: January 2016 Review Submitted: February 8, 2016
    View listing
  • Very well appointed unit.

    "My wife and I were there from July 2-July 9th. Out of a number of units we have stayed in from the Bahamas to the states this was one of the cleanest and best appointed places we have stayed at. The gas grill was new and even the brushes and lighters were provided. Having an icemaker and freezer packs provided was icing on the cake. We did not want for anything and had plenty of kitchen utensils to cook and entertain guests while there. The owners and the management company were a pleasure to deal with. The property and pool were in excellent condition and other owners were very pleasant. We rented a golf cart but you could walk to any of the island attractions/stores as the condo is centrally located. Having a decent pier to dock at was a must as we travelled by boat. We will definitely be back."
    Guest: Richard L. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 19, 2016
    View listing
  • Extremely relaxing.

    "Staying at Starfish cottage proved to be the most relaxing vacation ever. The location was perfect and the beach stunning. The cottage was clean, comfortable and fully equipped for all our needs. We cooked in and enjoyed meals out. A must restaurant (Touch of Class) will pick you up and return you after a wonderful Bahamian meal. The locals are extremely friendly and we made some new friends. I loved our cottage and hope to visit Treasure Cay again."
    Guest: jill g. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 4, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement