svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay pets

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Great Guana Cay reviews

  • Stunning!

    "From beginning to end our stay was amazing! Thank you Gina for all of your assistance and we cannot wait until our next visit!"
    Guest: Kelley C. Date of Stay: December 2016 Review Submitted: January 3, 2017
    View listing
  • Speechless and fulfilled

    "We searched for days to find a place that would allow us to have a small, family wedding on a private beach in January. We decided on Guana so our families could get there easily, and New Heights because of its beauty. My first contact with Mary was impressive. After we revealed to Mary that we chose New Heights partly because of its size and beauty, but more importantly because the beach appeared so private, her generosity was greater than we could have ever expected. She offered to help us plan, and we decided to take her up on it, and we couldn’t be happier. Mary put us in contact with the property manager. From our first conversation, I trusted him and knew it was all going to be fine. He went to Donna Sand’s and set up our golf carts for the week; he went to Water Toys to set up fishing pole and boat rentals, and had even offered to have Sandra travel to Marsh Harbor to get groceries and alcohol ahead of our arrival – we wanted to do the grocery and alcohol shopping ourselves, so we refused that piece but nothing else. Peter and his staff were impressive. They are professional, courteous, attentive and self-motivated. They keep the grounds looking spectacular, the house looking amazingly clean and kempt, and they are very knowledgeable of anything Guana Cay. Whatever our questions, they had the answer. This house, the staff and the setting were perfect. You can watch the sun rise and set from the 2nd story deck; you can relax under a thatched-roof gazebo on a private beach; you can be anywhere you want on the island in minutes; you can cook tremendous meals in the beautiful kitchen and eat them on the west-facing deck as the sun goes down. Swim in the ocean or in the pool – your choice. You can stay connected to the world or completely unplug. The choice is yours. Before we met, my wife and I had traveled to numerous islands in our time, and New Heights is by far the best place we have stayed. Of course Guana is a big part of that, but when it is all said and done, New Heights, Mary Boyle, Peter and his staff are what made the difference. We will be back here soon."
    Guest: Jason S. Date of Stay: January 2017 Review Submitted: January 26, 2017
    View listing
  • Best Ever!!

    "Absolutely fabulous!!! Had to talk with owner several times before trip began and felt like she was an old friend every time we talked or emailed.House was perfect! Most beautiful view looking right at the beach with some rock formations right in front of house. Gorgeous turquoise water going out to the bluest, blue water ever! I also worried that Nipper's restaurant would be noisy since it is right next door but never heard it unless we were at nipper's. And food was really good and quite reasonably priced. French fries were like McDonald's-my favorite. The fresh grouper was so good my granddaughter ate it every day! Back to house-loved it-beds awesome-brand new-as comfortable as mine at home and I have a temperpedic. Air worked great. Could also open up and let cool air off ocean blow through and it felt great. Washer and dryer also. We had no loss of power or water entire week which can sometimes happen on the islands.Took my granddaughter and friends for her graduation and can't wait to take husband there. I could go on and on forever about this house. Absolutely love it. Wish it was mine.Would never leave though. I think it would be perfect for anyone or any group.I can't think of anything that would make it any better. Also felt very safe on this island."
    Guest: Suzanne W. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: August 28, 2016
    View listing
  • What a view!

    "The property manager Gina is awesome, had our golfcart for us upon arrival. The cottage was very nice, I would definitely stay here again!"
    Guest: Dave J. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 1, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement