svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay pets
Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Eleuthera reviews

  • Simply the Best...

    "My girlfriend and I just returned from Off the Reef. It was a glorious time! The view itself makes the price of a night worth it, even if it were twice the price. The pictures online DO NOT LIE! It's one of the most beautiful places I've ever been. Allan and Carolyn have spared no expense to make this little bundle of paradise functional and fascinating. Bring a cooler and chairs if you want to, but you'll never need them. The only things we actually needed were our sunglasses and sunscreen. (And who doesn't bring those?) Be very specific with any car rental company you deal with. The roads in Eleuthera are terrible and there is no middle line on Queens Highway (except for spots in southern Eleuthera). If you drive on the right at home, request a car with left-hand operation. It's more than a little sketchy driving on both the wrong side of the road and the wrong side of the car. Also, if you're adventurous (like us) you'll want to visit some of the other beaches that you'll undoubtedly read about. Make sure you have 4-wheel or All-Wheel Drive!!! Lighthouse Beach is a pretty place, but it's a tough road to get there and God-forbid if you get stuck in the sand or get a flat! I'd venture to say that heading down to The Market at Rock Sound and buying four days worth of groceries and dining at Tippy's and 1648 should suffice a couple for the week. Be prepared, though, groceries, food and drink are expensive on the island. Take your snorkel gear! I saw about 15 varieties of fish and a ray while just "off the reef". I only got out as far as the fourth rock formation and the sealife was amazing! If you feel the need to get some fresh conch for fritters/rangoon, I'd recommend heading down to Bannermantown past the turnoff to Lighthouse Beach. There are hundreds of tidepools with living sealife. We didn't take advantage of it, though. My gal detests killing things and I kind of agree. So, that's that! Off the Reef is the place to be on Eleuthera for a couple. Everything you need, nothing that you don't. Carolyn is great about correspondence, so messaging is almost instantaneous. We love her! Missing OTR already... Hope to be back some time soon!"
    Guest: Kelton C. Date of Stay: May 2016 Review Submitted: May 22, 2016
    View listing
  • Best stay at Harbour Island yet

    "This was our fourth visit to Harbour Island, having previously stayed on yacht, hotels, a different cottage, and now, Afterthought. This was the top! The description of this lovely place is spot on! The location is absolutely primo. All the amenities make for the perfect stay! The pool makes for a wonderful addition. The housekeeper Is punctual (daily!) and attentive, and was in and out before you knew it. My motto is that when you discover things that excel is quality, value, predictability, and stand out above the rest, you try to re-discover them frequently. We are already planning a return trip to Afterthought!"
    Guest: Frank B. Date of Stay: April 2016 Review Submitted: May 1, 2016
    View listing
  • Perfect accommodations with an amazing view

    "A beautiful well appointed home with amazing views that is somewhat secluded. If you are looking for island adventures or just relaxing, this is the place. Great snorkeling, fishing, and shell hunting. We loved the coffee table books, very informative of the area. Looking forward to our next vacation there!"
    Guest: Cathy S. Date of Stay: March 2016 Review Submitted: March 25, 2016
    View listing
  • Perfect

    "Perfect location, perfect house! Kayaks and bikes too!"
    Guest: Royce P. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 7, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement