svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay pets

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Islamorada reviews

  • Open Water Paradise

    "Have you ever read reviews where the person starts out by saying something like 'I didn't really want to write a review because I wanted to keep this place to myself'. I always thought that those type of comments were a little on the selfish side. I mean if you stayed some place that you really liked then why not write a nice favorable review right? Then my wife and I stayed about 11 nights in the Garden Villa at Sue's Promise last month in January. Now I don't think those comments are so selfish any more. However I do not mind sharing. Sue's Promise is a private tropical beach house. It has 2 downstairs Villas. Owner is Charlie and his wife Terry. They are SO nice. Best of all Sue's Promise is NOT ON A CANAL. If you know anything about the Keys the vast majority of vacation rentals are although advertised as waterfront are actually located on some small canal with the neighbors right on top of you. Not at Sue's Promise though. This is a real open water front beauty. Very private as well. I used to live for many years in the Caribbean on an island off the coast of Honduras and I must say that the foliage (coconut palms, sea grapes, orchids and etc.) and wild/sea life (iguanas, spotted rays, colorful tropical fish, manatees and etc.) are very similar right there at Sue's Promise. We felt like we were 'back home'. The Garden Villa itself is good sized and very adequately stocked with start up supplies of basic essentials. So nice not to have to run to the store immediately for coffee or whatever. Needless to say we will be returning hopefully sometime this year. Thanks again Charlie and Terry!! What a gem you have......"
    Guest: Larry P. Date of Stay: January 2017 Review Submitted: February 12, 2017
    View listing
  • Just a wonderful stay

    "We really had a good stay here. The apartment was well equipped with everything you could possibly need. The layout is a little strange (the fridge is in the closet and the kitchen shares space with one of the showers) but we got use to it! The place was spotless, the bed comfy and the tiki hut just peace and beauty. My husband used the bikes to explore. We didn't do serious dinner cooking, but we could have if we wanted. There isn't a stove, but toaster oven,microwave, crock pot and hot plate covers it. All the kitchen equipment looked new. Restaurants were an easy drive. Chris was a great hostess... there when you had questions and otherwise never intruding. We liked Islamorada as a place to stay in the Keys...quieter than Marathon or Key West yet close to everything."
    Guest: Dianne A. Date of Stay: January 2017 Review Submitted: February 4, 2017
    View listing
  • Beautiful townhouse with wonderful owners

    "Alexander's townhouse is beautiful, roomy and has been very nicely renovated. Loved the complex's pool, and trying to get a glimpse of manatees from the dock! Everything worked great and Alex was quick to respond to any request (I don't have any complaints!) and was a pleasure to deal with. The complex is conveniently located with tons of things to do in the area - snorkeling, scuba diving, kayaking, John Pennekamp marine park, 'Theater of the Sea', a movie theater, etc are all nearby. I highly recommend this place and look forward to returning as soon as I can."
    Guest: Kim Date of Stay: October 2016 Review Submitted: December 8, 2016
    View listing
  • Excellent, 5 Diamonds, 10 Stars, Rent Here

    "I had a very important annual budget meeting and my partners and I wanted to get away somewhere private for the meeting and have an extended vacation as well. We decided the keys would be a great spot to unwind. We were right about that and more importantly this property was the place to be to unwind and relax. We got to this beautiful house in Islamorada in one of the nicest, if not the nicest neighborhoods in the entire keys with everything exactly in place. This rental is for anyone and everyone. This place has swimming, fishing, kayaking, biking, fun in the sun, and all included up front. No additional heckling with bike rental or kayak rental vendors. The owner literally has anything you could ask for in a vacation rental at the property all ready to roll. If you are looking for the most relaxing time of your life look no further. Rent here and you get your own personal, all inclusive slice of paradise located in the center of beautiful Islamorada. As I said in the title, RENT HERE!!!"
    Guest: Jeremy C. Date of Stay: September 2016 Review Submitted: September 7, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement