List your Property
Blue Gate Theater, Shipshewana, Indiana, United States of America

Blue Gate Theater vacation rentals

We found 52 vacation rentals — enter your dates for availability

Discover a selection of 52 vacation rentals in Blue Gate Theater that are perfect for your trip. Whether you’re traveling with friends, family, or even pets, Vrbo vacation homes have the best amenities for hanging out with the people that matter most, including WiFi and air conditioning. Prices start at $63 per night, and houses and cabins are popular options for a stay in Blue Gate Theater. Either way, you'll find a rental for everyone's needs.
AsyncDestinationUrgency

Find the best place to stay — Blue Gate Theater

Cozy ‘Haven of Rest’ Home w/ Amish Country Views!

Sleeps 8 · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom
$202 avg/night
(7)

Modern Farmhouse Lakeside

Sleeps 8 · 3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms
$126 avg/night
(23)

Cozy Amish Country Cabin on Shipshewana Lake!

Sleeps 4 · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom
$490 avg/night
(52)

NEW! Authentic Dairy Farm Retreat in Amish Country

Sleeps 7 · 3 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom
$196 avg/night
(2)

The Hook,Wine&Sinker🎣🍷⚓️

Sleeps 8 · 2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom
$139 avg/night

Private Lake, Sleeps 11, Near Shipshewana, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Baths

Sleeps 11 · 4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms
$209 avg/night
(9)

Search 52 vacation rentals

Top rated rentals — Blue Gate Theater
Stayed Apr 2021

Beautiful location, and a perfect experience!

Lisa was great with communicating, and everything she said about the property doesn't do it justice!! We were having a small gathering before my friend's wedding and needed a spot for 10 people. This house was exactly what we needed. Private, on a la...

Steve W.
Steve W.

Fishers, IN

Stayed Apr 2021

Awesome place

Exactly as pictured. Very clean. We came down for the honeyville quilt auction. So relaxing after a busy day. Lots of room to see all our purchases. The lake was so pretty and the sunrise was worth getting up for. Planning on booking for the next auc...

Patrice V.
Patrice V.
Stayed Apr 2021

Quiet and Relaxing

Was looking for a break from city life just for a few days to recharge and this house filled the bill. The house was very clean and well stocked with all the cooking and cleaning necessities. Lots of towels linens provided and the "welcome book" very...

Lydia M.
Lydia M.

Indianapolis

Stayed Apr 2021

Wonderful cottage .

My sister and I had a wonderful time at this cottage.I have stayed in numerous rentals in Shipshewana over the years. This ranked as one of the best. It was immaculately clean, cozy and comfortable. We will definitely stay there again when in the are...

Connie S.
Connie S.

Southgate, Mi

Stayed Mar 2021

Rare, Amazing Find! Very Clean and Well Maintained!

My wife, 6 yr-old and 10-month old stayed here in the cabin for a week. We can't say enough good things about our stay here. Even though the cabin is almost 200 years old, there have been many updates to bring it to modern standards including nice ap...

BLAKE C.
BLAKE C.
Stayed Mar 2021

Peaceful, Relaxing, Light, Bright and Beautiful

It is small, but doesn’t feel it because it’s so open and airy. You get a wonderful view of the lake all the time. The little beach area was perfect for our little granddaughters. My husband and daughter were even able to take the paddle boat out to ...

Julie B.
Julie B.
Stayed Mar 2021

Grandma’s birthday

We got the whole family together to celebrate grandmas 80th birthday. It was perfect. Lots of room for playing games and eating good food! The yard was nice and walking around the neighborhood was great for birdwatching. I saw multiple woodpeckers, a...

carole h.
carole h.
Stayed Mar 2021

Clean, comfy, pleasant

This is a wonderful property with a stunning lake view, and it's clean clean clean. The attentive owners have thought of everything and prepared the house to make it comfortable for your stay, even stocking extra toiletries that you might have forgot...

John K.
John K.
AsyncDestinationInfographic
AsyncDestinationInfographic
AsyncDestinationInfographic
AsyncDestinationInfographic
AsyncExploreBookEnjoy
AsyncExploreBookEnjoy
AsyncExploreBookEnjoy

How many vacation rentals are available around Blue Gate Theater?

Our 2021 property listings offer a large selection of 52 vacation rentals around Blue Gate Theater. From 48 house rentals to 11 cabin rentals, find a unique house rental for you to enjoy a memorable holiday or a weekend with your family and friends.