Top 50 Cayuga Vacation Rentals

Houses (170)
Cottages (131)
Lakefront (238)
Golf rental (231)
Lake view (142)

Explore a selection of Cayuga vacation rentals

Family Fun on Cayuga Lake
Guests13
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Excellent! 4.6/5
$350 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 13
29 reviews
LK Access Boat Dock Hot Tub Barbecue 1.7 Acres Wine Trail...
Guests0
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$337 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 0
21 reviews
Beautiful Cayuga Lake Sunsets, Wine Trails and Del Lago Casino
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$245 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
8 reviews
Holiday Cove: "A Great Place for a Family Vacation"
Guests12
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
$210 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 12
Bring The Family To Our Corner Of The Finger Lakes
Guests12
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Exceptional! 5/5
$305 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 12
5 reviews
Fish Tale Cove: "Discover the Finger Lakes Region at Cayuga Lake"
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
$135 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
One of the best lake frontages you can find! Beautiful views of...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
$250 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
Camp Onondaga Fully Restored Historic Lake Cottage
Guests8
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$152 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
20 reviews
Country Cottage: "Full of Good Memories"
Guests12
Bedrooms6
Bathrooms2
$313 avg/night
6 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 12
Cayuga Lake Summer Cottage
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$158 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
6 reviews
Cayuga Lake Lakefront Home 4 bedroom sleeps 10 with Hot Tub
Guests10
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms2
$316 avg/night
5 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 10
1 reviews
Near Aurora, Wells College/Wine Trails/Del Lago Casino
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
$150 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
1 reviews
Timber Bay: "Relaxing Escape"
Guests12
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms3
$425 avg/night
3 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 12
Cayuga's Largest Waterfront Rental. Great for Reunions! Sleeps 24+
Guests28
Bedrooms8
Bathrooms4
Excellent! 4.7/5
$1,225 avg/night
8 beds
4 Bathrooms
Guests 28
11 reviews
A tiny home, that floats. Located in a full service marina with...
Guests2
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
$125 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 2
Charming Country Lake House
Guests10
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms3
Excellent! 4.7/5
$206 avg/night
5 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 10
11 reviews
Eagles Nest - Newly Renovated Cottage: Wineries, Wildlife and...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$167 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
29 reviews
Lovely 2b/2b, Right Downtown! Fall, Winter, Spring Rates...
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Exceptional! 5/5
$77 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 4
8 reviews
Newly updated home in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Country
Guests10
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Exceptional! 5/5
$400 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 10
15 reviews
Experience Tiny Living
Guests4
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.6/5
$93 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
44 reviews
Family-friendly Bungalow Close to Everything
Guests5
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$117 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
14 reviews
Owasco Lake front seasonal cottage with level yard and beach
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$171 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
8 reviews
Beautiful lakeside home with panaramic lake views and level...
Guests13
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms3
Excellent! 4.5/5
$279 avg/night
5 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 13
23 reviews
Peaceful accessible lake cottage, right at the water's edge...
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Exceptional! 5/5
$178 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
22 reviews
NEWLY REMODELED IN THE HEART OF WINE COUNTRY
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$331 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
40 reviews
Locke's Glen - Home of Million Dollar Sunsets!
Guests14
Bedrooms5
Bathroom1
Exceptional! 5/5
$160 avg/night
5 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 14
5 reviews
Wine Trail Cottage - Canine Friendly Home
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.5/5
$150 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
26 reviews
Beautiful Home Overlooking Skaneateles Lake, Spectacular Views and...
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Exceptional! 5/5
$343 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 8
43 reviews
Serenity Zen House on Seneca Lake
Guests7
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$288 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 7
32 reviews
New Fingerlakes Lakehouse
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$275 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
11 reviews
Beautiful Log Home, Lake side.
Guests9
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$300 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 9
37 reviews
Morning Dew: Lakefront Getaway on the Cayuga Wine Trail
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$229 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
29 reviews
Beautiful Home on Seneca Lake, views leave you speechless!
Guests7
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$375 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 7
44 reviews
Quiet, Spacious Retreat In The Finger Lakes
Guests20
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$417 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 20
11 reviews
3 Bedroom Cottage on Owasco Lake
Guests12
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.8/5
$238 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 12
23 reviews
Renovated Modern Rental In The Town Of Skaneateles.
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Exceptional! 5/5
$170 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
22 reviews
Luxurious Three Bedroom, Pet Friendly Home. Walk to village!
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$225 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
76 reviews
Quaint Country-Style Cottage On Seneca Lake
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Exceptional! 5/5
$114 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
7 reviews
The Bella Vita- Life Is Always Beautiful With The Best Location On...
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$250 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
31 reviews
We're On the Wine Trail, Book your Fall Wine Tasting Weekends Now
Guests5
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$204 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
18 reviews
Unique Space-Great View-1 Night or More :)
Guests2
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$117 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 2
57 reviews
Contemporary Home on Seneca Lake
Guests15
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Excellent! 4.5/5
$337 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 15
27 reviews
Contemporary Cottage on Seneca Lake
Guests4
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.3/5
$157 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
32 reviews
Serenity Aloft House - Book your Finger Lakes vacation now!
Guests7
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$340 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 7
25 reviews
Immaculate Lake Front Home on Seneca Lake
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful! 4.9/5
$257 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
43 reviews
Hidden gem in a great location!
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Excellent! 4.7/5
$150 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
7 reviews
Upscale Cayuga Lakefront - Right on Wine Trail
Guests12
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms3
Exceptional! 5/5
$475 avg/night
5 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 12
10 reviews
Skaneateles Lakefront House 3 miles from Village with Spectacular...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Excellent! 4.7/5
$333 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
10 reviews
Cottage on west side of Cayuga Lake for summer rental
Guests5
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$196 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
9 reviews
Adorable Lake Cottage on the East Shore of Cayuga Lake
Guests5
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Excellent! 4.7/5
$117 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
9 reviews

Cayuga, NY, USA Vacation Rentals

Family Fun on Cayuga Lake

LK Access Boat Dock Hot Tub Barbecue 1.7 Acres Wine Trail...

Beautiful Cayuga Lake Sunsets, Wine Trails and Del Lago Casino

Holiday Cove: "A Great Place for a Family Vacation"

Bring The Family To Our Corner Of The Finger Lakes

Fish Tale Cove: "Discover the Finger Lakes Region at Cayuga Lake"

One of the best lake frontages you can find! Beautiful views of...

Camp Onondaga Fully Restored Historic Lake Cottage

Country Cottage: "Full of Good Memories"

Cayuga Lake Summer Cottage

Cayuga Lake Lakefront Home 4 bedroom sleeps 10 with Hot Tub

Near Aurora, Wells College/Wine Trails/Del Lago Casino

Timber Bay: "Relaxing Escape"

Cayuga's Largest Waterfront Rental. Great for Reunions! Sleeps 24+

A tiny home, that floats. Located in a full service marina with...

Charming Country Lake House

Eagles Nest - Newly Renovated Cottage: Wineries, Wildlife and...

Lovely 2b/2b, Right Downtown! Fall, Winter, Spring Rates...

Newly updated home in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Country

Experience Tiny Living

Family-friendly Bungalow Close to Everything

Owasco Lake front seasonal cottage with level yard and beach

Beautiful lakeside home with panaramic lake views and level...

Peaceful accessible lake cottage, right at the water's edge...

NEWLY REMODELED IN THE HEART OF WINE COUNTRY

Locke's Glen - Home of Million Dollar Sunsets!

Wine Trail Cottage - Canine Friendly Home

Beautiful Home Overlooking Skaneateles Lake, Spectacular Views and...

Serenity Zen House on Seneca Lake

New Fingerlakes Lakehouse

Beautiful Log Home, Lake side.

Morning Dew: Lakefront Getaway on the Cayuga Wine Trail

Beautiful Home on Seneca Lake, views leave you speechless!

Quiet, Spacious Retreat In The Finger Lakes

3 Bedroom Cottage on Owasco Lake

Renovated Modern Rental In The Town Of Skaneateles.

Luxurious Three Bedroom, Pet Friendly Home. Walk to village!

Quaint Country-Style Cottage On Seneca Lake

The Bella Vita- Life Is Always Beautiful With The Best Location On...

We're On the Wine Trail, Book your Fall Wine Tasting Weekends Now

Unique Space-Great View-1 Night or More :)

Contemporary Home on Seneca Lake

Contemporary Cottage on Seneca Lake

Serenity Aloft House - Book your Finger Lakes vacation now!

Immaculate Lake Front Home on Seneca Lake

Hidden gem in a great location!

Upscale Cayuga Lakefront - Right on Wine Trail

Skaneateles Lakefront House 3 miles from Village with Spectacular...

Cottage on west side of Cayuga Lake for summer rental

Adorable Lake Cottage on the East Shore of Cayuga Lake