Top 50 Pulteney Vacation Rentals

Cottages (302)
Houses (200)
Cabins (39)
Lakefront (423)
Golf rental (333)
Lake view (224)

Explore a selection of Pulteney vacation rentals

Keuka Blue - a truly enchanting experience.
Guests11
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$350 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 11
15 reviews
Keuka Lakefront steps to the water
Guests10
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms4
Wonderful 5 / 5
$310 avg/night
3 beds
4 Bathrooms
Guests 10
2 reviews
2 Side/Side Lakeside Cottages-5 Beds/3 Baths-Sleeps 12-14
Guests14
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms3
Wonderful 4.3 / 5
$780 avg/night
5 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 14
6 reviews
Waterfront, On Beautiful Keuka Lake
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.5 / 5
$350 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
13 reviews
Fall in love with Keuka at Keuka Kara.
Guests14
Bedrooms5
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$431 avg/night
5 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 14
5 reviews
Rare Find! 140' of Private Lake Frontage with owner...
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$246 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
14 reviews
Keuka Lakefront Darling
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$326 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
4 reviews
Brand New Home, Great Lakeside Porch. Lots of Family Fun.
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 5 / 5
$457 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
5 reviews
Finger Lakes Getaways presents to you Lake Rental 6
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 0 / 5
$193 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
Finger Lakes Getaways presents to you Lake Rental 98
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 0 / 5
$171 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
Keuka Lake Chalet is the perfect Finger Lakes getaway!
Guests7
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 0 / 5
$200 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 7
A Beautiful, Fully Furnished Log Cabin Overlooking Keuka Lake
Guests8
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$142 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
35 reviews
New short stays available! Esperanza Dream Lakeside cottage on...
Guests4
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$150 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
66 reviews
Newly Renovated Family Friendly Private Lake House
Guests12
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms3
Wonderful 5 / 5
$205 avg/night
3 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 12
23 reviews
Experience Tiny Living
Guests4
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.6 / 5
$93 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
43 reviews
Family Friendly Get- A-Way
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$125 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
42 reviews
Modern waterfront cottage on Keuka Lake - close to Penn Yan...
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$220 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
40 reviews
Charming Cottage On Seneca Lake, Private, Peaceful
Guests6
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$170 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
58 reviews
Lakeside Fingerlakes Getaway- TV cable and DVD! crib and pack and...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms3
Wonderful 3.9 / 5
$163 avg/night
3 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 6
20 reviews
Keuka Lake Escape For You
Guests4
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.6 / 5
$129 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
32 reviews
Seneca Lake House - Book your Finger Lakes Dream Vacation Today!
Guests7
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$257 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 7
30 reviews
GORGEOUS Waterfront Home w/huge flat yard , AMAZING VIEWS , Wine...
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 5 / 5
$235 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
66 reviews
Keuka Villa - A Charming Lakeside Cottage on the Jewel of the...
Guests8
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms0
Wonderful 4.5 / 5
$196 avg/night
2 beds
0 Bathrooms
Guests 8
8 reviews
Lake View Chalet Located Close To Keuka College And The Keuka Lake...
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$140 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
39 reviews
Beautiful House on Keuka Lake
Guests17
Bedrooms6
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$333 avg/night
6 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 17
6 reviews
Cozy 1 Bedroom Cottage
Guests2
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$214 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 2
35 reviews
Cozy Cottage, Sleeps 4 (two Bedrooms) Watkins Glen, Seneca Lake...
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.6 / 5
$135 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
21 reviews
Large Reunion And Retreat Cottage, Sleeps Over 27, On Lakefront
Guests27
Bedrooms8
Bathrooms4
Wonderful 4.2 / 5
$406 avg/night
8 beds
4 Bathrooms
Guests 27
12 reviews
Lakeside Log Cabin in the Heart of the Finger Lakes
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$257 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
34 reviews
East Side Lake House Spacious home. Drift Away.
Guests9
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$310 avg/night
5 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 9
28 reviews
Keuka Lakefront for Fall Getaway!
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms0
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$200 avg/night
2 beds
0 Bathrooms
Guests 6
28 reviews
FALL SPECIAL: Cozy Cottage w/Whirlpool Tub, 2 Kayaks, & PeddleBoat
Guests5
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$179 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
22 reviews
The Best Spot On Seneca Lake- Beautiful Lakeside Cottage
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.5 / 5
$325 avg/night
4 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
22 reviews
Stunning Views from a Lakefront Home In The Heart Of The Finger...
Guests8
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$259 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
29 reviews
Heron Hideaway: Private, 3/4 Acre Lot W/ 135' Level Frontage
Guests5
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$167 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 5
13 reviews
Chalet overlooking Keuka Lake
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$150 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
39 reviews
12 Bedroom Luxury Villa on the Lake
Guests25
Bedrooms12
Bathrooms4
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$983 avg/night
12 beds
4 Bathrooms
Guests 25
11 reviews
Heart of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$175 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
49 reviews
Sunnyside Shore - Lakefront Retreat, 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, sleeps...
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 5 / 5
$252 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
25 reviews
Riesling Retreat on Lamoka Lake - 2 bed, 2 bath cottage
Guests6
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$190 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
35 reviews
Family and Pet Friendly Cottage On Keuka Lake Wine Trail
Guests8
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$248 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 8
29 reviews
Level East Seneca Lake Waterfront near the Finger Lakes National...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.5 / 5
$240 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
8 reviews
Keuka Lake 4 Bed/3 Bath w/120' Lakefront! Sleeps 12-14
Guests14
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Wonderful 5 / 5
$450 avg/night
4 beds
3 Bathrooms
Guests 14
6 reviews
Falling Waters Retreat
Guests4
Bedrooms2
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.5 / 5
$125 avg/night
2 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 4
38 reviews
Relax Right On The Keuka Lake Wine Trail And Enjoy The View
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$157 avg/night
4 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 8
16 reviews
Self-Catering Suite Located directly on the Wine Trail
Guests2
Bedroom1
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$121 avg/night
1 bed
1 Bathroom
Guests 2
37 reviews
Nestled Above Seneca Lake in the Heart of Wine Country With...
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$215 avg/night
3 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 6
17 reviews
FALL SPECIAL: Lakeside Home w/ Sunset View, 2 Kayaks & Peddle Boat
Guests6
Bedrooms3
Bathroom1
Wonderful 4.7 / 5
$200 avg/night
3 beds
1 Bathroom
Guests 6
20 reviews
Suitable for 2 adult couples or couple with 2-3 children
Guests5
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms2
Wonderful 4.8 / 5
$129 avg/night
2 beds
2 Bathrooms
Guests 5
37 reviews
Seneca Lake Home Finger Lakes Wineries Galore
Guests8
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Wonderful 4.9 / 5
$305 avg/night
4 beds
4 Bathrooms
Guests 8
19 reviews

Pulteney, NY, USA Vacation Rentals

Keuka Blue - a truly enchanting experience.

Keuka Lakefront steps to the water

2 Side/Side Lakeside Cottages-5 Beds/3 Baths-Sleeps 12-14

Waterfront, On Beautiful Keuka Lake

Fall in love with Keuka at Keuka Kara.

Rare Find! 140' of Private Lake Frontage with owner...

Keuka Lakefront Darling

Brand New Home, Great Lakeside Porch. Lots of Family Fun.

Finger Lakes Getaways presents to you Lake Rental 6

Finger Lakes Getaways presents to you Lake Rental 98

Keuka Lake Chalet is the perfect Finger Lakes getaway!

A Beautiful, Fully Furnished Log Cabin Overlooking Keuka Lake

New short stays available! Esperanza Dream Lakeside cottage on...

Newly Renovated Family Friendly Private Lake House

Experience Tiny Living

Family Friendly Get- A-Way

Modern waterfront cottage on Keuka Lake - close to Penn Yan...

Charming Cottage On Seneca Lake, Private, Peaceful

Lakeside Fingerlakes Getaway- TV cable and DVD! crib and pack and...

Keuka Lake Escape For You

Seneca Lake House - Book your Finger Lakes Dream Vacation Today!

GORGEOUS Waterfront Home w/huge flat yard , AMAZING VIEWS , Wine...

Keuka Villa - A Charming Lakeside Cottage on the Jewel of the...

Lake View Chalet Located Close To Keuka College And The Keuka Lake...

Beautiful House on Keuka Lake

Cozy 1 Bedroom Cottage

Cozy Cottage, Sleeps 4 (two Bedrooms) Watkins Glen, Seneca Lake...

Large Reunion And Retreat Cottage, Sleeps Over 27, On Lakefront

Lakeside Log Cabin in the Heart of the Finger Lakes

East Side Lake House Spacious home. Drift Away.

Keuka Lakefront for Fall Getaway!

FALL SPECIAL: Cozy Cottage w/Whirlpool Tub, 2 Kayaks, & PeddleBoat

The Best Spot On Seneca Lake- Beautiful Lakeside Cottage

Stunning Views from a Lakefront Home In The Heart Of The Finger...

Heron Hideaway: Private, 3/4 Acre Lot W/ 135' Level Frontage

Chalet overlooking Keuka Lake

12 Bedroom Luxury Villa on the Lake

Heart of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail

Sunnyside Shore - Lakefront Retreat, 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, sleeps...

Riesling Retreat on Lamoka Lake - 2 bed, 2 bath cottage

Family and Pet Friendly Cottage On Keuka Lake Wine Trail

Level East Seneca Lake Waterfront near the Finger Lakes National...

Keuka Lake 4 Bed/3 Bath w/120' Lakefront! Sleeps 12-14

Falling Waters Retreat

Relax Right On The Keuka Lake Wine Trail And Enjoy The View

Self-Catering Suite Located directly on the Wine Trail

Nestled Above Seneca Lake in the Heart of Wine Country With...

FALL SPECIAL: Lakeside Home w/ Sunset View, 2 Kayaks & Peddle Boat

Suitable for 2 adult couples or couple with 2-3 children

Seneca Lake Home Finger Lakes Wineries Galore