This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Other areas nearby to Sodus Bay:

Recent Sodus Bay reviews

  • Quiet relaxing getaway

    "This was a nice relaxed, remote area cottage for a romantic weekend with my husband and also seems to be a great family area for all ages. We did not realize it was only accessible by boat until we received the directions the morning of our trip so make sure you do your shopping ahead of time. They have a pontoon boat to get all your bags and groceries to the cottage. Then you receiving a fishing boat of your own in addition to kayaks, canoes and a paddle boat you can use on either the bay or the lake. There were lots of people fishing but you need to bring your own pole and supplies if interested (we took the boat back to the marina and drove to Walmart 30 mins away and bought a cheap one). Scott and Martha were very welcoming and gracious to provide some of the condiments we forgot to bring. If your dog is friendly they can roam around off leash and there were frequently dogs coming by to say hi to our dog. All the dogs we met were very friendly and calm even if our dog barked at them initially. We also really enjoyed the fire pit and the hot tub at night. The neighbors were very quiet- no parties here. There are amazing stars with the lake area being without much artificial light at night. We laid on our backs on the dock one night and saw multiple shooting stars and tracked satellites. The bed was comfortable downstairs. We didn't try any beds in the loft but it looks like it holds a large group. The kitchen has all the cooking supplies you need... just bring your own coffee, condiments, cooking oil, etc. The only thing that needs improving is the bathroom and some of the seating areas. The toilet seat has a crack, shower is small and the bathroom has some stains. That said the shower was hot with good water pressure; just small. The main leather couch was nice but the upholstery on the other seating areas looked worn and dusty. But don't forget the gift basket! That cheese is amazing! We bought more at the stand on the way out of town. We also enjoyed the wine, crackers and chocolates. Thanks for a great stay! I would definitely come back."
    Guest: Heather S. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: June 30, 2016
    View listing
  • Wonderful Week!

    "The house is even more beautiful and well equipped than the photos. The views of the bay are outstanding. We stayed for 7 days with 4 adults and 3 children and had plenty of room with 2 extra bedrooms we didn't even use. Each couple had their own floor with the kids in the basement. We brought our boat for fishing, tubing and sightseeing every day. The house was perfectly set up to relax, even on rainy or cold days. This house is equipped with everything we could have needed and is perfect if you don't want to pack a lot. The rooms are beautifully decorated and very clean. All towels, sheets, detergents, games, books, magazines, cooking equipment, etc. are included. With the washer/dryer, all you have to bring is your personal items. Jim and Marji were very warm and welcoming and we would be very comfortable renting from them again. Thanks for a wonderful week!"
    Guest: Laura Date of Stay: August 2015 Review Submitted: September 2, 2015
    View listing

    "My husband and our grown kids with spouses and grandbabies went here. The grandkids had a blast ages 11 and two are 8. We used the kayak's, the motor boat and the hot tub and of coarse Lake Ontario! We loved the view. I would say my only complaint is there were spider webs on the chairs stacked in the house and spiders and there was a lot of spiders out on the porch(some of us get freaked out over spiders). I did sweep the webs and we killed a few spiders too. Now, I'm not saying we wouldn't go again because you couldn't get ANY NICER OWNERS than Martha!! She is a sweetheart and she did a treasure hunt for our 3 grandkids!! She is a wonderful Lady!! The beds were comfortable and they had wine, cheese and crackers for us. They also furnished towels and wash clothes and linens for the beds. Its sure helps when you don't have to pack all that too! We won't be able to go next year because my son and wife are having a baby and getting a new place but we hope to in another couple of years. Thank you for everything Martha!! The only thing I'd like is to have a vacuum and mop available for us to use. There was a broom but with the kids and us swimming we couldn't mop up the water. Thanks again!!!! Beth, Cliff, Kenny, Rochelle, Paul, Becky, Cliff III, & Frankie!!"
    Guest: Beth R. Date of Stay: September 2015 Review Submitted: September 23, 2015
    View listing
  • long weekend reTREAT

    "We decided that we wanted a weekend get-a-way, and within minutes we were booked! Everything from booking, to the time Martha met us at the marina, went very smoothly. We arrived on Friday afternoon, called Scott & he had Martha to us within MINUTES! She took us by pontoon to the cottage where there was wine and cheese (and a bubbling hot tub!) waiting for us- it was pure relaxation for the entire weekend. Upon arrival Martha helped us get our things to the cottage, we grilled up some salmon (on the VERY clean grill), hopped in the hot tub and enjoyed the rest of our evening watching the sunset over Lake Ontario and drank some wine. (the hot tub is RIGHT on the water!!) We realized that my husband forgot to pack the eggs and Martha graciously offered to go to the camp and get some for us. The next day we watched the sun rise over the bay, took the motor boat to Sodus (to get some eggs), fished from the dock while drinking mimosas, took the paddle boat out for a spin, had a bon fire and then settled into the hot tub for another beautiful sunset! The next morning while on the Lake Ontatrio beach, my husband made the comment that "wouldn't it be awesome to see a bald eagle fly over and grab a fish out of the lake"--literally 5 seconds later a bald eagle flew 20 ft over our heads out over the lake! God is good! Although we chose to be completely isolated for relaxation, there are a few restaurants and pubs that you can get to by boat (during the light hours). The cottage was very clean. We had everything that we needed: lots of towels, pots, pans, spices etc. When we called to be picked up for our departure Martha told us that since no one else was renting the cottage for the next night she would let us stay one night for free--unfortunately we had to be back to work so we declined. They were the most gracious hosts that we've ever dealt with! Good people!!! We will DEFINITELY be back!!"
    Guest: Kristin S. Date of Stay: September 2015 Review Submitted: October 10, 2015
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement