Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Fire Island reviews

  • Magical

    "We rented for 2 weeks to have all of our nieces and nephews and their children along with our adult children and assorted rotating grandparents get together. The house is great for big families and is very kid friendly. It is perfect for quickly coming in and off the beach (1 lot to stairs on one side and a few houses in the other direction to stairs to beach w/I lifeguard station). Well equipped kitchen - satisfactory even for foodies. The master bedroom has a picture window to the ocean and a big deck right next to it - no need to turn on the AC with all the cross ventilation. No matter how hot it was walking from the ferry, when you push through the gate, you feel the strong sea breeze. While large, it is absolutely still a beach house, one meant to be loved and lived in, not fussy or Hampton like, other than in the conveniences. The owner is easy to work with, answering questions right away when we had them, buying helmets when we said we'd have kids riding the bicycles, and providing useful local tips. Great vacation! To comment on the earlier review, the rooms now have curtains, except for the master with the picture window, and I wouldn't want them there. The light is beautiful. If you need dark, wear airplane eyeshades. The stove is propane tanks I assume. I think it is as good as that gets. You can't expect it to be the same as a natural gas line. The grill worked fine - maybe new? No problem with the freezer. Plenty big, didn't need the extra one in the laundry room."
    Guest: Deborah D. Date of Stay: August 2016 Review Submitted: August 15, 2016
    View listing
  • Great House and Owner/Manager

    "I've stayed in many Fire Island rentals in the past and my experience with Mike the owner and Dan the manager were fantastic..I was there with for a week with family and two kids and the house was clean when i arrived and supplied well with plastic utensils, paper goods, pots/pans, etc. This is an updated house and well kept. The central A/C is a added plus as most houses have window ACs. Great block, between the beach and close to Ocean Beach town. Any questions prior to booking were answered quickly. I would definitely rent this house again."
    Guest: Chris G. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 31, 2016
    View listing
  • Fantastic!

    "Our second year here and this time we stayed for 16 days! Everything is perfect, from the bay breeze all day and night to the closeness of the ocean and town shops. We had several major parties for friends and family and everyone had a marvelous time on the beach, grilling on the deck and celebrating the sunset with all the rest of the town folk, who come out every night for the best sunsets this side of Key West. Roberto and Phy were attentive to everything, including replacing an entire refrigerator on the eve of a big party - could not ask for better hosts. We had a bunch of teenage boys on their way to college stay over, a continuing series of teenage girls heading to high school dropping in, and everyone fit comfortably and had a great time, young and old. The house has so many nice sitting areas, from the front yard to the screened in porch to the huge back deck, that is easy to both have quiet space when just the family is there and also host a widely varied group of guests who can all find places to talk and enjoy themselves in smaller groups. We've probably stayed at 8 or 10 different houses in Fair Harbor but this is now two years in a row for us at this great place. Book now!"
    Guest: Steve M. Date of Stay: August 2016 Review Submitted: August 30, 2016
    View listing
  • Diane

    "Just returned from a week at this wonderful house. This is the second year we rented and could not have asked for anything. This house has everything for a great vacation. Having the two floors was wonderful as everyone can spread out. We can't wait to go back next year. Len is the best owner. He is quick to answer any questions and just wants you to enjoy his house which we did."
    Guest: Diane P. Date of Stay: August 2016 Review Submitted: August 28, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement