Destination guide

Find the perfect vacation rental for your Fishers Island getaway

Experience the unique character of Fishers Island with a stay in a vacation home rental. This city is well-known for its shopping and restaurants. Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea and Montauk Point Lighthouse are just a couple of the must-sees in the area. With a vacation rental, you get a home away from home—many rentals offer full kitchens and outdoor grills for some home cooking.


Sightseeing in and around Fishers Island

Are you hoping to find attractions to visit in the city? Venture out of your vacation home and check out everything that makes Fishers Island a fun spot to vacation. These are some of the major attractions to explore, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

  • Shennecossett Golf Course (5.8 mi / 9.3 km)
  • The Flying Horse Carousel (6.9 mi / 11.1 km)
  • Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration (6.9 mi / 11.2 km)
  • Saltwater Farm Vineyard (7.1 mi / 11.4 km)
  • Stonington Country Club (9.9 mi / 15.9 km)
  • Stonington Vineyard (10.3 mi / 16.6 km)
Natural features

Exploring the natural landscape of Fishers Island

Whether you're an adventurous traveler or just want to spend some time taking in the scenery, Fishers Island is a great place to spend some time outside. These are some of the area's most eye-catching natural features, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

  • Bluff Point State Park (5.3 mi / 8.6 km)
  • Dubois Beach (5.4 mi / 8.7 km)
  • Eastern Point Beach (5.7 mi / 9.1 km)
  • Napatree Point (6 mi / 9.7 km)
  • Ocean Beach Park (6.5 mi / 10.5 km)
  • Waterford Beach Park (7.1 mi / 11.5 km)
How to get there

Transportation to and around Fishers Island

Fly into Fishers Island, NY (FID-Elizabeth Field), the closest airport, located 2.8 mi (4.6 km) from the city center. If you can't find a flight that works for your travel itinerary, you might consider flying into New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London), which is 5.2 mi (8.4 km) away.

How many vacation rentals are available around Fishers Island?

Our 2020 property listings offer a large selection of 351 vacation rentals around Fishers Island. From 232 house rentals to 44 cottage rentals, find a unique house rental for you to enjoy a memorable holiday or a weekend with your family and friends.

Can I rent a seaside property in Fishers Island?

Drinking in fresh ocean air, basking in the sunshine and losing all track of time. Now that's the sort of getaway you deserve. Vrbo has 113 beachside rental homes. Alternatively, you might be after a different sort of vacation setting. Vrbo has plenty of options to pick from, including:

  • 101 water-view vacation rentals.
  • 78 ocean-view vacation rentals.
  • 54 shore-front vacation rentals.

Can I rent a house in Fishers Island?

If you're searching for a home away from home for your vacation, renting a whole house is a great idea. You and your crew will have plenty of space for all your vacation activities. There are 228 options currently listed on Vrbo. Prices begin at $98 a night. Or perhaps you'd rather choose one of the area's other popular rental options, like:

  • Cottage: 40 vacation homes. Prices start from $63 per night.
  • Apartment: 25 vacation homes. Prices start from $73 per night.
  • Condo: 22 vacation homes. Prices start from $120 per night.

Can I stay in Fishers Island in a large group?

Vacations spent with your loved ones can be a lot of fun, especially when you're sleeping under the same roof somewhere new! If you'll be traveling with a large group, Vrbo can help out. Why not have a peek at the 64 house vacation homes available here? They're the top choice for large groups of visitors. Rental accommodations around the area that are perfect for large groups include:

  • If yours is a group of 6, we have 208 vacation homes just right for that size. Spend a night from just $73.
  • If you've got 8 in your family, you'll be thrilled to hear that there are 128 vacation homes suitable. The starting price is $150 per night.
  • Hunting down places for rent to suit 10 guests? You'll be happy to know we have 66 that'll be perfect. You can secure one from just $245 a night.

So don't fret! When you travel with us you'll be able to bring your uncle, your cousin and all your besties to Fishers Island.

Where are the cheapest rentals in Fishers Island?

Vrbo has loads of great economical rentals. Treat your loved ones to a memorable evening out or extend your vacation for a few nights with the pennies leftover. Old Mystic is a bargain-hunter's dream. And with 18 Vrbo rentals at an average price of $184 a night, it's not difficult to see why. Pawcatuck is another place to check out. We've got 18 rentals here, and the average price is around $242 per night.