svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay pets

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Other areas nearby to Fishers Island:

Recent Fishers Island reviews

  • Great Condo, Great Host!

    "This is the perfect condo for a weekend getaway. I just returned from my stay with two other friends, and it accommodated our group perfectly. It's more spacious than we anticipated, and was spotless upon arrival. Working out the details during the rental process with Sal was extremely seamless, as he was very responsive to any and all questions. I would 100% recommend staying here!"
    Guest: emilee c. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: June 28, 2016
    View listing
  • Amazing!!! Couldn't ask for any better!

    "Beautiful home, super easy to work with! Couldn't ask for any better. Amazing time! Would do it again in a heart beat!"
    Guest: Tobias H. Date of Stay: September 2016 Review Submitted: September 8, 2016
    View listing
  • Dream House

    "I'm not overstating when I say that this house achieves the ideal. I could live there for the rest of my life. My wife and I spent NYE here with dear friends, cooking lobster and playing monopoly by the fire place. Then, on the January 2nd, after our friends had left, we celebrated our first wedding anniversary watching the moon rise and waves crash. So friggin romantic. Waking up in the master bedroom with magnificent views of the ocean. So many spacious rooms for friends/kids. Huge bubble bath. Great eats in Greenport. I have not seen it in summer with beach and pool, but for us, it's a winter paradise. Definitely be back."
    Guest: Danny Date of Stay: December 2016 Review Submitted: January 12, 2017
    View listing
  • Fantastic Weekend

    "Our family spent Fri-Sun of our Thanksgiving weekend at Duffy's in Montauk. The property is as described and photographed. So clean, that we felt at ease to let our baby run around. The property is maintained very well and we were able to roast marshmallows one night at the fire pit against the lake. The town was quiet, which was just what we wanted as a getaway from NYC. Rick and Kelly were fabulous hosts and were available to answer any questions that we had. We will be sure to stay again in the future!"
    Guest: Peter C. Date of Stay: November 2016 Review Submitted: November 28, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement