Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Shelter Island reviews

  • Best House Rental on Shelter Island

    "The BEST place to stay on Shelter Island. Our family has been going the Rose Cottage for the last 3 years. The owner Dave is a "gem". We have a total of 6 in our family so the house accommodates everyone. I have worked in the restaurant business for many years and thoroughly enjoy the "chef's" commercial kitchen. Everything I need to prepare all meals and baking is on site. I was very impressed with kitchen on my first arrival. There is so much to do on Shelter Island and my children look forward to going every year. Book early and you won't be dissapointed...."
    Guest: Billy R. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 17, 2016
    View listing
  • a perfect family getaway

    "I look forward all year to our family vacation on this beautiful quiet island and this year we created more wonderful memories at this charming house. It was spacious with many choices to gather for sharing a meal or a cocktail. Our family of 5 sprawled in comfort. The central location to the ball courts/field, food shopping and short bike ride to the beach made it easy to keep all ages happy. The owners are responsive and easy to work with. A perfect family getaway location!"
    Guest: Eileen T. Date of Stay: August 2015 Review Submitted: March 23, 2016
    View listing
  • cute and quiet little hideaway - kitchen is perfectly equipped!

    "This is a really lovely place, great location, amazing hammock to enjoy, and a fenced yard. We saw wildlife every day -- bunnies, deer, wild turkeys, chipmunks. The home is small, but really nicely laid out, and we had plenty of space for 4 adults and a toddler. It's well decorated (mid-century modern style), well-provisioned and clean. The kitchen is really well supplied -- and there is a great grill out back that's available for use, too. You are very close to grocery shopping and a little commercial hub in the center of the island, but it feels super secluded and private. Though off a main road, the home is tucked away in the back, so you are never bothered by noise or other people. Joan herself is super responsive and friendly, even going so far as sending someone, on a Saturday, to replace the grill's gas line (which an animal had chewed through) so that we would have it available for use. We were really happy with our stay here and would definitely recommend it to others!"
    Guest: Joanna F. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: June 15, 2016
    View listing
  • AMAZING! 3rd year in a row! Won't stay anywhere else.

    "Wow. I was impressed from the moment I drove up to the home! The accommodations are immaculate and the best in town. The doors and ceilings are huge; I bet there are a dozen double french doors in this place. Floor to Ceiling windows with a view are everywhere. The pool, tennis courts, and bocce court are so well maintained! Ram Island is a hidden gem within paradise. My favorite thing to do after playing tennis for an hour is to sit by the tennis courts in the shade with a drink in hand. You will feel like you own your own country club. Did I mention the kitchen? It is a gourmet kitchen. If cooking isn't your thing, then just go to the beach and order lobsters on the beach. Perfect location for riding bikes. I am very active and my spouse likes to relax. It is the perfect blend of both!"
    Guest: Carolyn G. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 11, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement