Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Shelter Island reviews

  • Just perfect

    "Great house in a perfect location. If you want a house with a pool, directly on the water here you are. Bring your boat, or use the kayak. You can paddle to Shell, Silver and Wades beach here no problem. The house is very comfortable and cozy, beachy and quaint. One level, spread out and with the added advantage of a separated cottage that allows grandparents or the like a little privacy while the rest of the family stays in the main house. The pool looks over the water and is large and kept very clean. The owner is lovely and there at a moment's notice if anything is needed. Couldn't recommend the house more highly."
    Guest: Kirk M. Date of Stay: August 2015 Review Submitted: September 13, 2015
    View listing
  • Peter Mostert

    "Myself and a few friends recently stayed at Kim's house. The house was so comfy. The house is in a little secluded place overlooking a protected marsh. A great pool with a wonderful BBQ area on the back balcony with great seating in and outside the house - comfortable for a large group. You will lack for nothing from a well equipped kitchen to very comfortable beds and many diffrent areas to the house if you want some quiet time. All that was promised was supplied and an owner that was a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!"
    Guest: Peter Date of Stay: April 2016 Review Submitted: April 8, 2016
    View listing
  • Perfectly situated Shelter Island gem

    "My wife and I and our two daughters (6 & 4) just stayed here for a week in July. Grandma and Grandpa, as well as Uncle Chris accompanied us on the vacation. The house was the perfect size for all 7 of us and very well equipped. The house is in an ideal spot on the island. Short walk to Wades beach (We didn't even need to buy a parking permit for the beach). The pool is great and quite large. The yard is also quite large and has a great view of the water extending over to Shell Beach. The owner was great to work with and very welcoming. We were encouraged to utilize the Kayaks, Stand Up Paddle board, and bikes which we did! There was a nice gas weber grill and a nice charcoal grill as well. The kitchen is very well equipped and has a sub zero fridge and viking range and oven. The best part was the view. You can sit on the porch and watch the sunset and sailboats drift by. You may even spot Jimmy Buffett heading in for a landing towards North Haven in his seaplane if you are on the lookout! Truly the way Shelter Island is to be enjoyed. Great stay."
    Guest: Ben H Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 17, 2016
    View listing
  • Best House Rental on Shelter Island

    "The BEST place to stay on Shelter Island. Our family has been going the Rose Cottage for the last 3 years. The owner Dave is a "gem". We have a total of 6 in our family so the house accommodates everyone. I have worked in the restaurant business for many years and thoroughly enjoy the "chef's" commercial kitchen. Everything I need to prepare all meals and baking is on site. I was very impressed with kitchen on my first arrival. There is so much to do on Shelter Island and my children look forward to going every year. Book early and you won't be dissapointed...."
    Guest: Billy R. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: July 17, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement