Shelter Island, NY, USA Vacation Rentals

Discover popular destinations in and around Shelter Island

Silver Beach
22 vacation rentals
The Heights
11 vacation rentals
Montclair Colony
2 vacation rentals
Wades Beach
2,752 vacation rentals
Menantic Creek
4 vacation rentals
Shorewood
8 vacation rentals
Gardiner's Bay Country Club
2,796 vacation rentals
Shelter Island Whale's Tail
2,761 vacation rentals
Crescent Beach
2,749 vacation rentals
Shell Beach
2,745 vacation rentals
Mashomack Preserve
2,852 vacation rentals
Sylvester Manor
2,745 vacation rentals
Shelter Island Country Club
2,701 vacation rentals
Havens House
2,759 vacation rentals
Shelter Island Tennis Club
2,763 vacation rentals
Connecticut
1,107 vacation rentals
New York
15,490 vacation rentals
The Hamptons
3,089 vacation rentals

Explore a selection of Shelter Island vacation rentals