Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Other areas nearby to Water Mill:

Recent Hamptons reviews

  • Amazing Property & great vacation for the family

    "Our family had an amazing time renting this property. The house was so spacious and the grounds were beautiful! our son had a blast running around on the huge lawn! Everyday we had deer that would great us at night while we were cooking or dining out on the deck. The house had so much room...the rooms are at one end of the house so when the kids went to bed they would not hear us in the kitchen/great room area or on the deck outside. The location was ideal too! You get so much privacy with this house but then you are a quick walk or bike into town. We enjoyed going to the beach everyday which is only a quick car ride, for the kids, or a walk down the hill. Chris was great to deal with and was very accommodating. We will definitely be looking into renting next year to continue our family tradition! Thank you for everything Chris!"
    Guest: Mary M. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: July 2, 2016
    View listing
  • 3rd time back

    "My family looks forward to our summer vacation on Shelter Island mostly because we get to stay here. Little Gem is really special--a sweet little cottage perfect for us, a family of 4 from NYC with two little girls (ages 5 and 1). Joan keeps a tasteful, clean, quaint space. We spend our mornings in the front yard, lounging in the hammock or running around with the kids. Afternoons are spent at Wades Beach, just a mile down the road. Dinner is either at Commander Cody's just around the corner or something made off the grill. The kitchen is well equipped with all the essential items to cook every meal. Joan is an attentive host--this year we rented the last week of summer to find the gas tanks for the grill empty. Joan was readily available when we reached out to her about the issue and quickly refunded us for refilling the tanks the next day. By the end of our stay, we always wish we could stay longer. We are already mapping out our return next summer. Thanks Joan for another wonderful stay!"
    Guest: Anonymous Date of Stay: August 2016 Review Submitted: September 10, 2016
    View listing
  • Dream House

    "We rented this house for a week. I rent all the time in Montauk and East Hampton, this house was by far the best! The layout of the house was great, and so clean! The yard and pool were fabulous! We had the best week and a great vacation, we were able to bring our dogs, which is hard to find. We were so sad to leave. And best of all Cathy by far was the nicest person I have ever dealt with, what a pleasure! We will definitely rent this house again"
    Guest: Susan B. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 7, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement