Photo by Tray

Plum Island vacation rentals

We found 326 vacation rentals — enter your dates for availability

Find spaces that suit your style

  • Peace of mind

    Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support

  • All the privacy of home

    Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, yards and more

  • More for less

    More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

  • A place for everyone

    We stand for diversity, inclusion and families everywhere.
    Learn more

Find out more about Plum Island

Why visit Plum Island

  • Scenic Beaches: Enjoy stunning coastal views and relax on the beautiful shores of Plum Island.
  • Historic Lighthouse: Visit the iconic Plum Island Lighthouse, a must-see landmark with rich history.
  • Outdoor Adventures: Engage in various outdoor activities, perfect for families and nature lovers.
  • Cozy Accommodations: Choose from a range of vacation rentals, including charming cottages and spacious homes.
  • Family-Friendly Activities: Explore recreational options that cater to all ages for a fun-filled getaway.

Popular types of accommodation around Plum Island

Discover the charm of Plum Island with our diverse selection of vacation rentals. Whether you prefer cozy apartments, spacious houses, or quaint cottages, we have something for everyone. Enjoy amenities like private pools, inviting front porches, and stunning rooftop terraces for a convenient and relaxing stay. Choose the perfect accommodation to make your Plum Island getaway memorable.

  • Apartments: The top choice for vacation rentals in Plum Island, offering comfortable living spaces ideal for individuals and families alike.
  • Houses: A popular option for those seeking a home-like atmosphere, perfect for larger groups or families.
  • Cottages: Charming and cozy, these rentals provide a quaint escape, ideal for a relaxing getaway.
  • Condos: A great option for travelers looking for modern amenities and convenient locations near the beach.
  • Caravan Parks: An adventurous choice for those wanting a unique outdoor experience with facilities for camping and caravanning.**

Top attractions near Plum Island

Plum Island, New Jersey, is perfect for outdoor and eco-friendly vacations, boasting stunning beaches and a vibrant urban park. Key attractions include the historic Plum Island Lighthouse, the picturesque Kite Beach, and the unique beach plums. Whether you're seeking cultural experiences, family fun, or outdoor adventures, Plum Island offers a variety of activities and sights to explore, making it an ideal getaway destination.

  • Statue of Liberty: A symbol of freedom and democracy, this iconic statue stands majestically on Liberty Island, offering rich cultural insights and breathtaking views of the New York skyline, just 16 miles from Plum Island.
  • Coney Island Beach: Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere, this lively beach features sandy shores, amusement parks, and delicious boardwalk treats, located 8 miles away, perfect for a fun-filled day in the sun.
  • Sandy Hook Lighthouse: As the oldest lighthouse in the United States, it boasts historical significance and stunning views of the coastline, situated a mere 0.5 miles from Plum Island, ideal for history enthusiasts.

Things to do recommended for couples

For a romantic getaway near Plum Island, stroll along the Riegelmann Boardwalk, just 8 miles away, soaking in the beach vibes. Enjoy a night of live music at the Music Hall of Williamsburg, 18 miles away, or savor wine and entertainment at City Winery, 19 miles away.

Things to do recommended for families

Families visiting Plum Island can explore the Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area for relaxation, enjoy thrilling rides at Keansburg Amusement Park, and cheer on their favorite teams at Barclays Center in Brooklyn, making unforgettable memories together.

Things to do recommended for groups

Explore the Mills at Jersey Gardens for shopping and entertainment, just 17 miles from Plum Island. Enjoy a show at the First Avenue Playhouse Dessert Theatre, located 4 miles away, or tee off at the Marine Park Golf Course, 11 miles from your destination, for a fun outdoor experience.

*Distances are measured in a straight line; actual driving distances may vary depending on the route.

What do I need to keep in mind when booking a vacation around Plum Island

When traveling with a group, family, or pets, or if you're seeking extended stays, be sure to refine your search based on your key preferences. Here are some helpful Vrbo booking tips to assist you.

  • Traveling to Plum Island with a group: Think about how many bedrooms you’ll require, along with features like a complete kitchen or outdoor areas for group get-togethers. Luckily, you can easily filter for all of these options and much more on Vrbo.
  • Traveling to Plum Island with young kids: Traveling with young kids can be quite demanding. It's important to prioritize their comfort and safety, along with suitable amenities like a private swimming pool. Additionally, thinking about your closeness to family-friendly attractions is a wise choice.
  • Taking your pets with you to Plum Island: For many, a family vacation isn’t truly fulfilling without their furry companion by their side. If that resonates with you, explore Vrbo listings that welcome pets. Many of these pet-friendly properties come equipped with feeding bowls and beds, ensuring that everyone feels comfortable and at home.
  • Planning for a long term stay visiting Plum Island: If you're in search of vacation rentals that offer discounts for stays of a month or more, you've come to the right spot. By using the appropriate filters, you can effortlessly discover and save on monthly rentals. Don't forget to consider adding features like a parking space, a well-equipped kitchen, or a private pool to your search criteria as well.

Where to stay near Plum Island

Plum Island, New Jersey, offers a picturesque escape for outdoor enthusiasts and beach lovers. With its stunning coastal views and eco-friendly atmosphere, it's perfect for family-friendly adventures or a romantic getaway. Just a short drive from the vibrant culture of New York, you can enjoy various neighborhoods that cater to both budget travelers and those seeking a festive urban vibe. Explore the island and its surrounding areas for a memorable vacation experience filled with recreation and relaxation.

  • Sandy Hook: Sandy Hook is a picturesque neighborhood located 2 miles from Plum Island, offering visitors a delightful outdoor and family-friendly beach experience. Known for its scenic boardwalk, Sandy Hook provides access to several recreational areas perfect for picnics and leisurely strolls. The local beaches, including the family beach, are ideal for sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing. Additionally, the nearby park offers beautiful green spaces for relaxation and exploration, making it a perfect spot for families looking to enjoy nature and the outdoors.
  • Highlands: Just 4 miles away from Plum Island, Highlands is a charming city known for its vibrant outdoor activities and beach attractions. With a lively boardwalk and a variety of shopping areas, visitors can enjoy a mix of relaxation and entertainment. The local beaches and parks are great for family outings, providing ample opportunities for swimming, sunbathing, and picnicking. Highlands combines coastal beauty with a welcoming community atmosphere, making it an attractive destination for tourists seeking both adventure and leisure.
  • Atlantic Highlands: Also located 4 miles from Plum Island, Atlantic Highlands offers a quaint coastal vibe with a focus on outdoor and family experiences. The city features a bustling boardwalk and recreational areas that invite visitors to explore and unwind. With beautiful beaches and parks nearby, Atlantic Highlands is perfect for families looking to enjoy a day in the sun, whether it’s building sandcastles or taking in stunning ocean views. The charming shopping areas provide a delightful mix of local shops and eateries to complete your visit.

Booking with Vrbo is simple

Looking to save on your next vacation? Consider being flexible with your travel dates, as prices can fluctuate significantly. Plus, booking an extended stay can lead to considerable savings. To discover the ideal Vrbo property that fits your budget, take advantage of our filters to search by price, location, and type of vacation rental.

Save more with One Key

Reserve a qualifying Vrbo for your group getaway and earn OneKeyCash on the total booking amount. Being the planner truly has its perks. When you join our travel rewards program, One Key, you’ll gain access to exclusive discounts and earn OneKeyCash on eligible bookings. Sign up today and start enjoying your savings.

Vrbo Trips: Planning as easy as it gets

Vrbo's cutting-edge Trip Board offers you a convenient way to plan your travels, pick up where you left off, or organize your itinerary. You can easily find the properties you've saved or booked categorized under Potential, Upcoming, or Current Trips. To start using Trip Boards, simply visit: https://www.vrbo.com/trips.

**Based on Vrbo properties bookings.

Choose a vacation rental for your Plum Island getaway

Experience the unique character of Plum Island with a stay in a vacation home rental. You'll find plenty to explore during your stay in the area. Statue of Liberty and Cape Liberty Cruise Port are just a couple of the must-sees in the area. Whether you're planning a family holiday, romantic stay or friends trip, vacation rentals offer features like full kitchens and laundry facilities for a more convenient stay.

Activities and attractions in and around Plum Island

Are you looking for attractions to visit in the area? Venture out of your vacation home and experience everything that makes Plum Island a fun spot to vacation. Here are some of the top attractions to see, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

  • Keansburg Amusement Park (7.6 mi / 12.2 km)
  • Luna Park (8.6 mi / 13.9 km)
  • New York Aquarium (8.7 mi / 14 km)
  • Monmouth Park (9.8 mi / 15.8 km)
  • Aviator Sports and Events Center (10.9 mi / 17.5 km)
  • Marine Park Golf Course (11.3 mi / 18.2 km)

Exploring the natural landscape of Plum Island

Whether you're an active traveler or just want to spend some time taking in the scenery, Plum Island is a great place to spend some time outside. Here are a few of the area's most stunning natural features, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city center:

  • Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area (0.9 mi / 1.5 km)
  • Monmouth County Beach (1.3 mi / 2.1 km)
  • Keansburg Beach (7 mi / 11.2 km)
  • Coney Island Beach (8.4 mi / 13.5 km)
  • Seven Presidents Oceanfront Park (9.4 mi / 15.1 km)
  • Bensonhurst Park (10.1 mi / 16.3 km)

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to rent a vacation rental in Plum Island?
The average price for a vacation rental in Plum Island can vary depending on factors including length of stay, property type and season. Whether you're thinking about a sprawling villa with lots of space or an apartment for just you and your sweetheart, just enter your dates of travel to see stays with terrific value.
How much does it cost to rent a beach house in Plum Island?
The average price for a vacation home near the beach in Plum Island depends on when you're traveling and the type and size of property you're searching for. You can easily find prices on Vrbo by entering your travel dates and destination. Then use our filters to pick the number of bedrooms and amenities important to you, like WiFi, air conditioning and a hot tub.
Are there pet-friendly vacation rentals in Plum Island?
Pack a suitcase for your pooch because Plum Island has four stays that welcome pets with open arms. Let your happy hound enjoy fun with the family at one of our pet-friendly vacation rentals on Vrbo. Simply enter your travel dates and destination, then check our "Pets allowed" filter box.
What are popular rental amenities in Plum Island?
When it comes to rental amenities that guests are looking for in Plum Island, a water view, a beach view and a barbecue grill rank the highest. With Vrbo vacation homes, there are options to match your taste and style, whether you're taking a trip with your partner, your family or even pets.
Are there large group vacation rentals in Plum Island?
Take your pick of four Vrbo vacation properties in Plum Island that can host a group of five or more guests. You'll enjoy all the privacy and room you need to kick back with the people you're vacationing with — and nobody else.
Are there vacation rentals in Plum Island that welcome kids?
Plum Island has four family-friendly vacation homes to choose from. And tracking down a stay that welcomes little ones is super easy with Vrbo's "Properties good for families" filter. Besides having the whole place to yourselves, you'll get access to perks and conveniences such as living rooms, private pools and yards.
How can I find vacation rentals with air conditioning in Plum Island?
Plum Island has four vacation rentals where you'll be able to spend your days in air-conditioned comfort. To book a stay on Vrbo with this amenity, enter your desired travel dates and use the handy filters to select the "air conditioning" box.
How old do you have to be to rent a vacation rental in Plum Island?
The minimum age can differ across properties on Vrbo, so look at the rules of the vacation home in Plum Island you're interested in. But normally, it's 16, 18 or 21.
How long can I rent a vacation rental in Plum Island for?
The length of time you can book a vacation rental in Plum Island differs according to the property. Simply enter your preferred dates to look at a list of options offering extended stays. With tons of features like washing machines and kitchens, as well as some offering weekly or monthly discounts, you're sure to discover the perfect place to call your home away from home in Plum Island.
Does Vrbo offer discounts for vacation homes in Plum Island?
Whether you're after one of our newly listed homes, or one of our weekly or monthly discounts on vacation rentals, you're sure to score some great deals and discounts on Vrbo. From weekend trips to extended getaways, we've got you covered for your next Plum Island escape.

More Vacation Ideas