We've been visiting St. John for 11 years, and Heaven's Gate has some of the most spectacular views we've ever experienced! The sunrises are breathtaking, the pool is fantastic, and we loved the covered outdoor spaces and peaceful location near Coral Bay.Hugo was a great host, and we appreciated the fresh greens from his family's organic farm. The trade winds kept the main living areas comfortable, and the bedroom AC worked great. The solar battery system was also a huge benefit during an island-wide power outage lasting over two days. One suggestion would be to provide guests with battery status updates so they can better manage energy usage.Unfortunately, cleanliness and upkeep were disappointing. Floors and windows were dirty, and we spent considerable time cleaning the kitchen before using it. The kitchen was also disorganized, lacked some basic utensils, and contained spices several years past expiration. We encountered a mouse in the oven and later found evidence of activity in the spice cabinet. We understand tropical island living, but this went beyond what we've experienced at other villas.Some furnishings also differ from the listing photos, and the outdoor showers had very low water pressure.Overall, Heaven's Gate is a beautiful property with million-dollar views and tremendous potential. With better cleaning, pest control, and attention to maintenance, it could easily be one of our favorite villas on St. John!