Not sure what the previous reviewer encountered, but this place was perfectly acceptable. Yes, it's in a city, but this location was much quieter than other places I've stayed in in cities. The house was easy to overlook, and we ended up passing it by a few times, but that's not a problem with the listing. Check-in was a bit odd, as the manager wouldn't send the instructions until I was physically at the house. Similarly, there were no check-out instructions. But the place was exactly as described, and was clean and neat. I even looked under carpets and mattresses, and everything looked fine. It was the perfect place for my family to stay for our NYC trip.