My wife, myself, her mom, my dad, and our two adult children all very much enjoyed our time in Chincoteague and our stay at the Inn at Poplar Corner. It is a beautiful ex-B&B and we very much appreciated that we had the whole house to ourselves. It is also very conveniently located and we walked to nearby restaurants and shopping as well as the local supermarket and coffee shop. I cannot recommend the Inn highly enough.
We cooked all of our breakfasts and about half our other meals and found the eat-in kitchen and adjoining (and enormous) dining room quite functional and pleasant to be in.
I would like to point out a few 'surprises'. We hadn't quite understood how spacious the third floor Grande Gables bedroom would be and that the pictured Sitting Area/Nook was in addition to the bedroom suite - my wife and I essentially 'took over' that floor. Second, the ground floor bedroom with the twin beds is essentially a maids quarters and while convenient for someone for whom stairs are somewhat difficult, it is not on par with the other bedrooms. Lastly, the county in which the house is located simply doesn't recycle glass - we misunderstood the wording to mean that they didn't pick it up. Taking glass to the local recycling center was futile.