Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Coral Bay reviews

  • Comfortable and charming - again!

    "Once again we had a fabulous week at Christmas Cottage. The description is accurate, but as I said last year, it's a bit better in person, full of personality and very comfy. Super clean when we arrived, and Marcia is an attentive, experienced host, always just a text away if we have a question or need anything.Would highly recommend for anyone who wants a true island experience. Although it's close to her other house, it's amazingly private! As always we enjoy everything about St. John and particularly Coral Bay. Dinners and music at Skinny Legs and Concordia (esp. Monday night), dinner at Oasis more than once...and Aqua Bistro was also very good. Lots of hiking and time at the beaches. We'll be back!"
    Guest: Linda R. Date of Stay: March 2016 Review Submitted: March 13, 2016
    View listing
  • Perfect for us!

    "Catherine was fabulous! Met us at the dock and took us to the grocery store on the way to the house. Loved the location! Easy access to everything on Coral Bay. The home is just as the pictures show. Maybe even better! Clean. Cute. Perfect for us. Has all the amenities. We didn't mind not having AC. Great breezes blow thru the bedroom every night. Lots of stairs. This is not a place for those with difficultly walking up and down stairs. This was our second trip to St John and our first at New Moon. We will definitely rent it again every trip. We will be back next spring!"
    Guest: Julie G. Date of Stay: May 2016 Review Submitted: June 8, 2016
    View listing
  • Love, love, loved this cottage!

    "Such an awesome place to stay on St John. My husband and I only stayed there for 3 days and then met the rest of the family at a villa on Cruz bay. Wish we had the whole 10 days at Catch and Keep. We will definatly go back! Can't wait!!"
    Guest: Theresa D. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: July 13, 2016
    View listing
  • Can't Wait to Go Back - AGAIN!!

    "This our 5th time to going to St. John and our 4th time staying at Coral Rays (we didn't know any better the first time). Everything is always PERFECT while we're there. Coral Rays is our standard for other rentals elsewhere and honestly, we haven't found anything that beats it. The views are like none other. The pool is perfect. Everything in the house is top notch. We've been there with up to 10 people and as few as four. It is always comfortable - like home. I can't wait to get back there again - and we just got home this morning. There's NO PLACE I'd rather stay."
    Guest: LoveToVacation Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 1, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement