After our stay with a family of five, we left with mixed feelings about this house. So here are two sides of the coin:
The good:
House is secluded, quiet with a nice big living room and great deck. Enough space. Plenty of parking. Well equipped kitchen (albeit dated). Management was quick with communication.
The bad:
Bedrooms (especially the downstairs ones) musty, even after opening all the windows. Two bathrooms are dated. Master bedroom does not have own bathroom. Although surfaces were all well cleaned, rugs were dusty and some dirty.
Location is somewhat removed from everything, which would not have been a problem if bikes had not been sold out. Cars are a problem in the Hamptons, parking at almost all beaches is for residents only. Local beach is walking distance, but not great, rocky, not for swimming and too many flies.