We rented three properties from Al during our time on Hutchinson Island for a week's duration. Nirvana Shores, Restoration Sands, and Xanadu. All three were fantastic!! We came for a large family reunion with a mix of age ranges from toddlers all the way up to grandparents. Everyone was accommodated.
I think the best part of it all was that there was very little we had to prepare for. The place was FULLY stocked (i really mean fully!!). If there are any issues, Al has helpers in the area who are merely a call away.
We went in the rainy season, but that didn't really stop us from having a great time. Given that it's tropical rain, it came in bursts, so there were ample windows for us to get outside and have fun. We also had a covered pool area that we could access, which also helped!
As far as food goes - kitchen was fully stocked (cooking seasoning, oil, cutlery, etc. etc.). There's a major chain grocery store just down the road as well, so pretty easy to restock on things.
The area is generally quiet. All seem to be vacation homes with other families visiting. At the time we were there (again, a bit of a rainy time of the season), it was not crowded at all.
Everyone had a fantastic time and are asking "can we come back here again?" Fantastic core memories made for the little ones. Highly recommend for a family get together.