I have been coming to Macatawa for much of my life. My grandparents, my parents, and now I am among the group referred to as "long-time renters." I have thus stayed in a number of cottages, new and old. I believe the Kirkwood is the best of a very good group. It is ideally situated in the Park, it has been recently upgraded, and while it is an older cottage, there are no compromises in this regard; its age only enhances one's experience. A great deal of this has to do with the Russells. Both in their accessibility to questions and concerns, and in the way they take care of the cottage, one can tell they are genuinely interested in making a relaxing and tension-free time for their renters. Moreover, and unlike some Macatawa owners, they don't act as if you're untrustworthy or about to break something! We were not overwhelmed with unnecessary rules, or admonitions about how to take care of a place. That makes a huge difference to feeling at home. I would particularly recommend the Kirkwood to those with children. Renters are encouraged to use all the toys and water equipment they find. My 16 month-old grandson was in heaven roaring around the porch in a little red car we found in the basement. I was grateful for their trust and generosity. Thank you, Shane and Amy. We'll be back!