We enjoyed our stay at Don Pepin. Pros- privacy, walk to the beach, private pool, outdoor cooking, eating and relaxing beautiful grounds, very responsive host. Cons- remote area, AC only in the bedrooms, no dishwasher, small living area, small inside eating area. We had some difficulty finding the house and the pin dropped by the host didn't get us there. A phone call to the host helped us find it. We were able to turn on the AC in each bedroom because it was hot in the house. We needed to go to dinner and it was getting late. The host recommended a restaurant and called to make sure they would keep the kitchen open for us. The host gave us several great suggestions.
The house was very clean. The kitchen had the items you expect in a VRBO. Because the house only has AC in the bedrooms using the kitchen to cook made the communal area very hot. We used the outdoor grill as much as possible. There are bath and beach towels provided but a few more bath towels would be better. The kitchen sink leaked and overflowed a bucket below and the kitchen light didn't work. The light was fixed but not the leak.
The beach is a short walk down the hill and can be seen from the pool and the outdoor area. The waves were strong and there are rocks in the surf but there is a tide pool area that is calm.
It is over an hour from San Juan so if you want to explore and visit the rain forest there is a lot of driving. If you want private, remote, outside living and swimming with a view it's great.