In a few words: we loved it and would stay again ASAP.
This property is a gem, literally everything you could want and need if you're a couple, a family, a group of friends or have a dog you'd like to bring to the North Fork. Locations is great, close to ALL things you may want to do but extremely PRIVATE.
Great rooms, plenty of bathrooms, fantastic kitchen, big driveway for parking, outdoor space for grilling/entertaining, a lovely well maintained FENCED yard for your kids or dog and surprisingly lovely views of bay and a picturesque pond from the deck and primary suite balcony (very romantic).
If the days are rainy you won't even mind because the living space is lovely for relaxing. For those who might be wanting to work from the house, the Internet connection is blessedly GOOD (we needed to do that for a few days during our long stay and were satisfied).
Our hosts were beyond accommodating and easy to communicate with. They have a list of nearby beaches and attractions that was VERY useful. House rules are reasonable, clearly explained and not overly fussy.
The neighborhood is QUIET, so if you're looking for some peace, this is the place. We loved taking walks with our pooch down the country lanes and hearing nothing but the water and the birds.
Can't say enough great things, if you have an opportunity to book it, do so with zero regrets. This is our #1 choice of place to stay while visiting the North Fork, esp with a pet!