I feel like we probably had the nicest place on St. John's for the money. In my research, most private villas on the island were so dated and "schmaltzy". The landscaping at the Westin was impeccably maintained, the pool villas not as much. It was pleasant for sure, and I'm sure it is really hard to maintain those properties in that climate, especially when you throw in a hurricane here and there. I wish it was cleaner, but it was certainly pleasant. The bath products are as cheap as they come - bring your own. And my last ding is the food at the restaurant. They could do so much better with such a captive market (maybe that's why -- they don't have to). The food is horrible. Got diarrhea from the undercooked salmon patty the first night which stuck with me the whole trip. Lovely. Again, I don't think we could have done better, and it was a nice vacation. There's just plenty to improve upon to make it as spectacular as the island.