We are frequent travelers to Hawaii, and to Maui in particular, so we know the options quite well. There are places where you can spend over $2,000 per night, and there are very basic rentals for $100 or less. But essentially there are two types of stays in Maui: upcountry or oceanfront.
If you're looking at oceanfront, then what you will want aside from a clean and comfortable condo in a resort (which this one is), are good views, pleasant grounds, walking distance to the beach, lounge and beach equipment, etc. This place gets five stars because it has all that.
View: sit on the lanai and you'll get great views of the beautiful grounds and the ocean.
Grounds: koi pond, two pools, two spa pools, lots of places to relax and enjoy.
Equipment: provided for all activities on the grounds, or for beaches.
Beach: Yes, there is no beach fronting Papakea, but a trifling walk next door over a short foot bridge takes you to the beach in front of adjoining resorts. No need to walk out on the street, and no need to stuff everything in the rental car to go to a beach.
In addition to all these plusses, the location is great. There is grocery shopping very close by, as well. A 10-minute drive takes you to Ka'anapali Beach, the Whaler Shops; and 15 minutes takes you to Lahaina. Day trips get you anywhere else on the island.
The price is incredibly good, so you get a great value.
Unless you were thinking of dropping $1k a night or more, just stop right now and book this place!