If you are looking for quirky, this is it. The hotel is unique, authentic, perfectly decorated, located in a tiny Montana town and right across the street from hot springs and an excellent restaurant. Many of those in our large party love quirky/unique, and they were thrilled with the entire experience.
However, if you need comfort and privacy (we rented the entire hotel for our family), there are many issues with the property besides squeaky, noisy floors and rooms without closets or individual bathrooms. We did not know that the hotel is also the town post office. Customers came in talking loudly at all hours, interrupting our privacy, awakening us and even appearing irritated that we were there. The beds had flannel sheets and one couple was convinced they had bed bugs. The mattresses could have been much better. People came in off the street three times asking to use the bathrooms or showers. One sink (of two) was clogged throughout our stay. And despite a small fridge, it was not easy even to make sandwiches in the tiny common space. There is a coffeemaker, but there were not mugs for a large group and coffee could have been left for the clients by the owners, since the closest grocery store is 30 minutes away.
In sum: quirky, adorable, fun but low on comfort.