Wow, what can I say? The villa itself and the location were outstanding. You cannot find a better place to enjoy Tuscany and the small towns sprinkled throughout. There are lots of great restaurants and wineries nearby and the sunsets and sunrises over the vineyards and hills were amazing. I would easily give the villa itself 11 out of 10 stars!
The management of the property, however, was...fussy. As mentioned in other reviews, there are extra charges that aren't outlined super clearly (or outlined at all) in the listing, such as the hot tub, internet, and gas. Be warned that you will undoubtedly end up paying something for gas (even if you don't use the heat) as the gas used for hot showers and cooking adds up. Cooking essentials (like olive oil), TP, garbage bags, dishwasher tabs, body wash/shampoo/conditioner are not included. Luckily, we were able to use some of what previous guests had left behind. Directions for parking were not clear (and we bore the brunt of someone very angry that we had parked in the wrong place) and although I know the villa is part of a working winery and oilery with a restaurant (or maybe two?), it wasn't very clear how to take advantage of those amenities.
But...if you can get past those small annoyances, you will love your stay here!