We are a multigeneration family with 2 dogs. This is our honest review. We needed a place with a bedroom and bathroom on the first floor for our elderly father and room for four adults, 1 child, and a couple of small dogs. The location was near downtown, and we quickly got to different parts of Eureka to see family. Unfortunately, we didn't get to enjoy the gazebo due to the weather, but it looked lovely. My family liked the living room for gathering, the kitchen had most things we needed (more than I've seen at other places), the bathrooms were stocked (loved the number of towels) and there was a washer and dryer (which we needed).
If you are traveling with people who can't navigate a narrow steep staircase, this might not be your place. It is clear in the photos but none of us paid attention when booking. Both bathrooms are downstairs so you will need to navigate that staircase if you need the restroom. All the rooms have the basic furnishings you might need (dresser, lamps... obviously bed). The beds are full size upstairs and very springy (ie noisy for those wanting adult time). As for comfort, they are okay for a couple days but beyond that everyone struggled to sleep through the night. Both sink in the middle and make noise with every move.
The shower head in the main bathroom might need to be replaced (it was a trickle) but having a bathtub with a child was a godsend so we seriously did not care about taking a shower. Water was hot and bathroom was clean! Heidi was very responsive!
The neighborhood is... close to things but not exactly walkable and honestly that is the state of many parts of Eureka right now (we are frequent visitors with immediate family there). It rained the whole time and no one was out but my walks with the pups were fast and I kept a good eye out. We've stayed at the Carter House Inn and had the same experience walking in the area. There was some late night activity/commotion with the garage across the street (roaring engines, some yelling). Happened a couple nights but that was it. I would recommend this place to anyone wanting to be near downtown and loves classic Eureka old home charm. It is super cute and Heidi was awesome to deal with (earthquakes struck right before our trip, so I messaged her a bunch).