We spent eleven days in September 2021 at this property and overall were very satisfied. It is very well maintained and there were no unpleasant surprises. The house is large and comfortable and well provisioned in terms of paper goods and such. The beds were comfortable if a bit soft for my taste, but that’s just my opinion; not everyone prefers a firmer mattress.
The location is perfect—a short walk to town but on a quiet dead end, in one of the prettiest parts of Edgartown.
When we had a minor plumbing problem, Michelle responded very quickly and it was fixed within an hour or so. I really appreciated this.
We had only one complaint, and it’s not really fair to call it a complaint, since we knew ahead of time — but the lack of air conditioning, even in September, meant that we were uncomfortably warm even in September. Although temps were mostly in the 70s and only once or twice hit 80, the truly absurd humidity on MV rendered the fans of limited use. For a property this expensive, we found this to be a problem.
If you’re not as sensitive to temp and humidity as we are, this rental is an excellent choice.